Gag Order on Tennessee Attorney for Criticizing CoreCivic Lifted by Judge
Nashville-area attorney Daniel Horwitz will no longer be barred from publicly criticizing a private prison after the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee amended its rules in May 2025.
The development comes three years after a judge issued a gag order against Horwitz for commenting publicly on a wrongful death lawsuit he pursued against the private prison company CoreCivic. Among other social media posts, Horwitz had written on X that “massively deficient and constitutionally non-compliant staffing” in CoreCivic facilities “is just business as fucking usual.”
CoreCivic successfully made the case to a federal magistrate judge that the statements were prejudicial. The gag order required Horwitz, a civil rights attorney who had filed numerous lawsuits against CoreCivic, to delete past posts criticizing CoreCivic and to refrain from making public statements about the company.
As PLN reported, Horwitz, represented by Institute for Justice, sued in federal court to challenge the gag order. [See: PLN, Dec. 2024, p.56.] But while the case was still pending, the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee voluntarily changed its rules in May 2025—scrapping the policy Horwitz challenged and ending his gag order.
“I’m thrilled that my First Amendment rights have been vindicated, but more importantly, I’m thrilled that I can resume informing the public about civil rights abuses across Middle Tennessee,” Horwitz said in an Institute for Justice press release.
Sources: Reason, The Tennessean
More from this issue:
- Class-Action Suit at BOP “Rape Club” in California Settled for Record $116 Million
- From the Editor, by Paul Wright
- Free Calls in Massachusetts Lead to Defunded Prison Programs
- $12 Million for Former California Prisoner Exonerated After 17 Years
- 14th Alabama Sheriff’s Employee Pleads Guilty in Jail Detainee’s Death by Freezing
- $340,000 for Former Massachusetts Prisoner Whose Baby Was Stillborn, by Douglas Ankney
- Latest Jail Booking Info Is Based on New Data Source
- JPay Loses Bid to Revoke Class Certification in Washington Prisoners’ Challenge to Crummy Products and Service
- Trump Pardons Virginia Sheriff Convicted of a Bribes-for-Badges Scheme
- Over One-Third of Older Texas Prisoners Suffering Cognitive Impairment, by Matthew Clarke
- New Jersey Supreme Court Refuses Guard’s Challenge to Firing for Failing to Report Kiss with Prisoner, by Douglas Ankney
- Oregon Prisoners Can Now Seek Economic Damages for Future Lost Income More Easily, by David Reutter
- Bold New Orleans Escape Calls Attention to Poor Jail Conditions
- Sixth Guard Sentenced in West Virginia Killing of Pretrial Detainee
- D.C. District Court Dismisses Class Action Against BOP Over Earned Sentence Credits
- Gag Order on Tennessee Attorney for Criticizing CoreCivic Lifted by Judge
- Nearly $60,000 Awarded to Mother Of Dead Missouri Prisoner In Suit For His DOC Records, by Anthony Accurso
- New York City Loses Bid to Withhold Jail Records, by Douglas Ankney
- Eleventh Circuit Announces New Deliberate Indifference Framework in Dismissing Georgia Prisoner’s Claim for Skipped Anti-Seizure Meds, by Douglas Ankney
- Ninth Circuit Affirms Dismissal of Arizona Challenge to Private Prisons
- Wiccan Nevada Prisoner Wins 18-Year Fight for Religious Items, by Clark Nelly
- California Prison Plagued by Toxic Water and Chronic Illness
- Former Prisoner Informant Appointed Deputy Director of BOP
- $22.5 Million Verdict Arrives Too Late for Wrongfully Convicted Illinois Prisoner, by David Reutter
- Washington Jail Settles DOJ Allegations of ADA Noncompliance in Failure to Treat Opioid Use Disorder, by Douglas Ankney
- $42,000 Paid to Wisconsin Prisoner Allowed to Harm Himself While Under Observation, by Anthony Accurso
- First Circuit Revives Rhode Island Prisoner’s Excessive Force Claim Against Guard, by David Reutter
- Ohio Supreme Court Says Sheriff Must Get and Disclose Records of Private Contractors, by Douglas Ankney
- Ongoing Detainee Deaths Push Rikers Island into Federal Court Receivership, by Anthony Accurso
- Trump’s “Border Czar” Was on GEO Group Payroll
- Colorado Passes New Law to Expand Prisoner Visitation Rights
- First Circuit Affirms Denial of Qualified Immunity to Maine Guards who Ogled Prisoner During Childbirth, by David Reutter
- Massachusetts High Schooler Detained by ICE Caught in “Collateral Arrest”
- DHS Removed Sanctuary Cities List After Complaint from Sheriff’s Association
- Lawsuits Filed After Fatal Assault on Elderly Prisoner at Kentucky Jail
- Tennessee Board of Parole Spanked for Failing to Make Recommendation to Governor on Prisoner’s Clemency Application
- Arkansas Ex-Police Chief Known as “Devil in the Ozarks” Re-Captured After Prison Escape
- New Hampshire Rolls Back Bail Reform
- Preliminary Injunction Issued Against Milwaukee Jail’s Mail Policy in HRDC Suit
- First of 10 Guards Charged with Killing of New York Prisoner Pleads Guilty
- Third Circuit Rejects U.S. Sentencing Commission Amended Compassionate Release Policy, by Douglas Ankney
- Former Death Row Prisoner Whose Case Changed the Law Dies in Texas
- A Colorado Jail Has Banned In-Person Visits Since the Pandemic
- $250,000 Verdict for South Carolina Prisoner Pepper-Sprayed in Face Without Cause by Guard, by David Reutter
- Wisconsin Robbery Suspect Frames Immigrant Detainee with Forged Letters Threatening to Kill Trump
- Eighth Circuit Affirms Judgment for HRDC in Arkansas Jail Censorship Suit, by David Reutter
- Florida Sheriff Charged in Connection with Massive $21 Million Gambling Ring
- South Carolina Prisoners Granted Class-Action Status in Suit Over Low Wages in Prison Industries Jobs, by Douglas Ankney
- Former New Jersey Jailers Plead Guilty to Beating Detainee for Tossing Urine
- $550,000 Settlement After Juvenile’s Suicide at Charlotte Jail, by David Reutter
- Seventh Circuit Revives Former Illinois Prisoner’s Claim for Delayed Hepatitis-C Treatment, by David Reutter
- Guards Used “Blast Grenades” to Break Up Mob Attack in California Prison
- Hyundai Parts Supplier Stops Using Prison Slave Labor in Alabama
- The Dangerous Practice of Late-Night Jail Releases, by Anthony Accurso
- Sixth Circuit: Michigan Tolling Statute Applies to PLRA Administrative Exhaustion Requirement, by David Reutter
- $1.6 Million Class-Action Settlement for Virginia Prisoners Subjected to Delayed Release
- Trans BOP Prisoners Win Restraining Order Preventing Transfer to Men’s Prison, Discontinuation of Hormone Therapy Medication, by David Reutter
- Solving the Carceral Understaffing Crisis: What Works, What Doesn’t, and Why
- Nearly $2.6 Million Paid to Former Minnesota Jail Detainee for Injuries from Delayed Withdrawal Treatment, by David Reutter
- Alabama’s Oldest Prisoner Dies in Hospital
- Ohio Sued by Non-Profit Law Firm for Opening Prisoner Legal Mail
- Percentage Of Prisoners Serving Life Without Parole Is Up Despite Overall Decrease in Prison Population, by Anthony Accurso
- Kentucky Supreme Court Voids Prisoner’s $10,972 Jail Fee, by David Reutter
- $95,000 in Settlements for Illinois Prisoners Retaliated Against for Class Participation in Prison Education Programs, by David Reutter
- Nearly $70,000 Awarded for Illinois Prisoner’s Excessive Force Claim, by David Reutter
- News in Brief
More from these topics:
- $95,000 in Settlements for Illinois Prisoners Retaliated Against for Class Participation in Prison Education Programs, July 15, 2025. Retaliation, Education, First Amendment, rights.
- Federal Court Blocks Idaho Executions Until Media Access Improves, June 1, 2025. Death Row, Access to Media, First Amendment, rights.
- Fourth Circuit Upholds South Carolina DOC Policy Restricting Prisoner Access to News Media, June 1, 2025. Access to Media, First Amendment, First Amendment, rights.
- Eleventh Circuit Revives Volunteer Pastor’s First Amendment Claim at Georgia Jail, May 1, 2025. First Amendment, Clergy, Proselytizing, First Amendment, rights.
- Oregon Pays $50,000 to Settle Retaliation Suit by PLN Contributor, Who Wins Release, Feb. 15, 2025. Retaliation for Litigating, Retaliation for Media Contact, Settlements.
- Allegheny County Settles Suit, Lifts Media Gag Policy for Pittsburgh Jail Employees, Dec. 15, 2024. Access to Media, Guards/Staff, Gag Order.
- Tennessee Attorney Sues Federal Court Over Gag Order in CoreCivic Suit, Dec. 15, 2024. Corrections Corporation of America/CoreCivic, Attorneys, Gag Order.
- FBI Visit to Oklahoma Woman in Response to Social Media Post Sparks Debate on Free Speech, May 15, 2024. Racial Discrimination, Religious Discrimination, FBI, First Amendment, rights, Police State-Surveillance, Social Media.
- $125,000 Settlement for Wisconsin Prisoner’s Claim That Guards Set Him Up For Stabbing, May 1, 2024. Guard Misconduct, Racial Discrimination, Retaliation for Media Contact, Retaliatory Segregation, Prison Gangs, Failure to Protect (General).
- Eleventh Circuit Revives Claim Against Florida Jail That Forced Detainee to Scan Legal Mail Into Computer with Memory Chip, March 1, 2024. Jail Specific, Supervisory Liability, Municipal Liability, Legal Mail, First Amendment, rights, Attorney/Client.