Dep.ar~ment.of J.ustic,e I.n~pe~J:or General 'Questionnaire Regar.din9. [)eta'ine~s

D.OJ.-:DIG INVESTIGATIVE QUESTIONNAIRE
FOR ItI;VIEW AND USE tiNLY BYINDIVlr>UAL FBI ItESPON[)ENTS
..
.
[)p. NOT FORWARD OR D~.~EMI~ATE
~UESTIONNAIREID:tes~00000022

.~s·of ~IJ.~ l;:Ist time this qu~troon;:lire.W;:l~. Sa\(~d" some require.d fieldS' havJ=r n~~ !leen cQ~ple~ed.
~I~s~,r.e'yiewyoUr

resp()nses..

.

r!r~~~=··········
Please pfovidethe following information:
1. Fir.st name'
i. Midgle !nltial:
3: Last name:
4. E,riteted on Duty'DCite (EOO'):
,5: Current otVisiQn/Field Offi~e:

6 &,7(; FER A~REEJ¥I~N.T
'6 &'·'1C P.ER AGREEMENT
6 & .le PER AGREEMENT
6, &, 7C
:t; ~ 7C

'6;. Curr~l)t job ti.t1e: '

$pecilp.l. Ag.ert
6 &, 1c. PER. AGREEMENT
fi &::7(; PER,AGREEMENT
'6 *IC PER AGREEM~!'IT

7/; Dirett dial bffice"telephone number:
8, FBI i:~I'r phQne'nurnb,¢r:
:.~., fB,I p~~enJUtnher~
to'. Best cQntact nur:nber for'you~,

B'a Ba'ckground

6 & 1C PERA'GREEMENT.

of S'pecifte D,epl.oynie·nts or 'Assig'nments

11. At any time a·ftEi't1Sep,tember H

t

'ZO,01{ ctid 'yciu se'rvea'$ a memtier bnne u.s,

Military, or as an

·employ~e.or contractor of the. FBI:or any other .government agency, ,at Guantanamo Ba'[(. Ci.lbai Iraqi

:

Afg11i;3J:li.st g!1;'or ii} pr~q$ cantroll~ ,~y,t:he 1):5. MJlj~ry or-a Y"S. jnteUig~.n!=~s~r)lj~e in 'CQn(1~,c;:ti0n.'Wit~ 'the'

.9I,pbal,~~ron !~rroi1

:

·@·Yes

0' No

12. Enter the humber ,oftimes you were.deployedof'8ssig ned to-,each of the, f6l1owin{1,
(G,uant~namo BaYt 'd~(ba~, ,~@q; ,,~fgl:t~rii!?tan;
int~lIig:enCe

seryice) ':2

.F~r'e~c~ deRI()Ymen.~ 6r
Lo~ation

..

I Ct
.'\'
.. ~se e~ _0!l!'!J
ri'

'qr In.-any c;lreas 9?f1troJled py !h~' u,s.

fo~ations

M.i1r~rv <?r.a U:~:L,

~ol)1pl'et~;th~ following ~ec~lon,."
Deploymertt:or',asslgnment begiln on:or
DeploymelJ1:or~asslgnmentendedon·
itb9J1~
or lIb~ut:

asslgl1rt:lent

Ri~na~QiB.ai
OS/2002
.07/Z002
....
........... .......
:f2a~ Wllat \%.S .the ·9.elle(~H hature ana purpo~e' of YO'ur:assiQn,ment. and :actiVities?
_.,.....:e-.~.A.~

~

~.)O

.'

IntervIewer
,
l2:Q., PI~ase p.rPvi,de':t,he"nam~s ofthe ~pe~jfic,calT1P$, b,9-s'es/or'faGilit.i~swh~r~ ypu wQrke~i.

.t g'mp

D~IP3,

f2G. Note: If infOl1TIatibn. about a specific,camp:, baseit orfucility' is,dassified ci'bbve SECRET,
'please"r:hed<. here. Dr. iJidQde-.in your :ansYlief ih~t 'you ha:ye ',ia:dditi6.iiaj 'irif6rma~ion '01~ssfried aboVe
'~E~R~/" and, if y.ou krow! id~ntlfy tQ~ da!?$if!cat'ion, level" ticket, 'coJl)p_artrp~nt, Jlrogram,:or'ot,her

~esi911!3tlotnha~ applies t<;:qheJlJfprmation, ,Do l10t incl4de the'add ition_a',! ¢~s~lfjefi inform?ltlo!1, In your

ttuestionnaire. r~spon$es.

mB p-ers6iihel·with the, neceSsary :c1eara'nce will c;00.tgC1: yo.u'to receive it;

OIGQ-005435

1-'

~.

' a'-

;i~~,)]~a~ Ic[~~~fy:~y ~~~'~~"ii~ 2Qsltlo~)Jj~~ ~~~T=~,f~f~~~njl~I~=~tib:!t! Y~U=~i~eS~)Y £~2rt~~:
0:Ui ~~~QtrTI~n} 21 ;isl@Pi~ni.,;
;~~

rlri9:'i

Name

Position

b6

l_________________________~~i;~;:~~~~

I

_

'b7C

~

,:12e, Did you jointly interVieW or interrogate any detainee with non-FBI persotmel?

'0 Yes
'0 N.o
=- W~h' 'Wh~t- Ki~tis-'q{nb';;~FI3~ p~;~hnel:d id Yb~ ;;Q~k ~intIY?' - - - -

: 0' €ITf'
'
,: 0' ;Other'U.S~ Military'
.
: D. Us. intellig'ence agencY

!it For~ign:m.Hitary

~

; D Qther
....- _...

Rr ~J1telligen:G~:~g~.ncy

__ __ --- - .-\-- -- --- - - - -- -' - - - ---- _.... - -- ,...

,..-

- - - - ~ - - - - - - - .• - - - - - - - - - - - - _.

,

......

,-.

-.

- ........ - -

--- ........

12.[ DJt(YP'U-jdlntIY pla~:-~rty d~tai;ee,i;t~(~iew~ or~inteirQg~ti9rt :st~£eg
:FBI p~r~~mnen

®
-

.........

-

...

'"

-.

--

,-"-

..

-

.......

_.-

>

-;.,

".

_

......

-

-.

--

-

-

-

-

-

-

--.~

-.

-- -

,... ......

"-

-

- ....

-

-

--

,0 No

y~S
-

_..... - - -- - - ....

v:;bj~iv~'Qt.tiJi~; w~h ~Qn:--,~

-

....

-..

-

.....

-

': Y'(Jth wl)al kir:t.d,~ Qf ngn,.F8~ per~tJnf21 did YQl,l wor~join~ly?

....

-

-,~

~'-

-

-

-.

.. , , . . .

-~,

"'"

""'

,...

.......

-

...

-

...

-

~

-

-

-

......

'

: 0.C;ITF

,: 0, Oilier U.,S." MiIi,tary
: 0 W.S·, ihteiligence agen'¢Y
,: 0 F.6tejQh mi'lita'ry or ihtelligerll:le"a9,eney
~ D ,Other
'
.
.
:'''''_

....

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - -- - -- - - - ..... - - - _... - - - - - - - -- - - - _.... --.- - -.- - - - -- - - -- - - -- .... - ... --

£~g-:W~r~y~~ ~~~r-oth~~is~ i~v.~iv~d i~d~t~i~~~;'int~~i~~; ,~~ rnt;r~g~ti;n-; -;ith-";o-n=Fir -~~s;~~e1?: - ~
~ 'res
'0 No
'

~

·Please,describe:GTMO Task,Force,was:organized 'into teams.consistihg of an FBI agent/CITF agenti I;)H
:p~J?qnnE:J,.,C? pd i3 trao!?latl?r.: ,
'
.

. =.-"-'-.- - - -:- - - -.. - -'-'- -,- -- - ---,'--~- _._¥-..-..; - ' - --- ,Lo~~tio9 (~ICiCt,~nCl~.

~::~~Vfneii~,or ~~~igh~eritlleg~n ~Ji;or~;.~rJ:ent!Jr:asSIQriini!~ ~ndea'l?n

j!3uantariall1o
.Bay
....
........

;12:l20:02
.

'

,. '"

--~-...

06/209.3.

l2a. Wliat was the general nature an,q P,uq?Q~e, qf y.our,as:Signrn~nt:ahcl :<lp;ivities?
~ssigtied to'interview 760
12b. 'Please,provide'the names of the specific-camps; basesT or facilities where you worked.
C--amp DeltCl'
'
i2G. "foJ:~: If infQrtmnLQ,n 9JiQ\J~!;l :sp~Cifj~ c;;arnp.T pase~ q:r faClIjty is das~Jft~~ :aQQv¢ '$~C;REJ',
plea~'yl1e~~ her~, D 1 )nGlude. in Y9ur .a'nswer that YbU h~v:e:llaCldltf9nqlinf9rmatlC!n;G1qssifieCl aQoye
'SECRET/" and, if you knowT identifY the.c1assification level, ticket, compartment, programror;other
designatiOn that applies to the, information: Do not include the,add itionardassffied information in ,you!"
.
.
- . . ,
..

I

~

.:

- - - - - - " - - --,;- - -'"''':'''-,-''-.- - , - - - ' - -'-""- - ' - - . - ' - ' - - - ' - - ' .

b6
b7C

-,

OIGQ-005436

Questionn13ire re:sponse$. bIG. pers,cnnel with the, necessary clearance will cc;mtact you to rec~ive it.

n

'

'~~~-----~---~-----~------~-----~-----------------------------~-------.
,:1,2d. Please identify, by' name. and pdsition ?It the time~ the FBI personnel tQ' whQm you pirectly reported.
'~~~~ito~!~;~~i~~~~~~~~Qh~~~---~-----------~-------------------------Position

N::amp.

b6
b7C

,fBI Su perv.isor
FBI Supervis.dr'

F..BI·5lJpervisor'
'GTMOcase Agent

:12e. DIe( you loi,n~ly i~t~;Yi;; ~r-ln~r~g~t~ ~n.Y,d.~fgTn~~

0 'fes
'0
- .... - - -- .. -- ... - - - - - - -' - - -- - - .- -' - - -- - - - - • With wliat kinds :of non-FBI p'ersbrinel d.id yo,u Work joihtly?
~o

,.

~-.

.....

"'"

"'"

....

....

.......

-.

,: d CITF

'

~

.

.,.

,...

.

Wl1:h,-~oD:fBl p~~;~n~I?-:- ---------------:
,...

,.

......

"'"

- ... - -

~~

....

- .... -- -- - _. - - - ..
....

~

.;-'

-.. ....

"

'

.: 0 OtherU,S. Military.
.: 0 U.'~" intelligence ~geflqr

: 0' 'Fdrelgn mlll,tc1/}' 9r Int~\IIge-n.~e,agency
:0

'.
~

-

'o.tli~

-'- -

,- -

'"

-

-

-

-

-: -

-

_.- - - -

-

-

-

~-

-

.1:2f. Old. Votljolntly plan any :dclalriee
::FBI personnel?

-'so

h'ltervleW pr Interrogation :str;3tegy~, o.bj~lves~ or' tactlG~ With non-

--

-

...... -

-

-.- -

-?-l -

-- -- -

-

_.- -

- - .... - - - . - -

-

_ ..... - . - "";""-, -

-

-

-

-

-.,- -

--

.'
•.

'

@ Yes

,

'~,

a'No

(

':\~~h-Wh~t ki~d~-;(I1~h::-F6i p~r~~ieT iii~ y~U ~;b;~ j~lfjt~?

: 0 GITF

.

--- -~ ---- --- -'.' --- - ~ ------ -- -_.-::

''',

:'

: 0.:0tfierUS. Milital1'
.: 0' ..u.S•. iritellig'~nce ~g.ency

"
"

:: 0' Foreign' military-or intelligence,agency

'; d

..

...-

b~her-

__

4.,..

..... ; ' - .... _

--

_ _ :-- .... _

-'--

__

....

_

,...',,-:

_

-'- ,-

"':'" _

~

_ _ . - , _ ....

",:,,''"; _

-:-

;'t.......... ,.,."""" -

-

-,.. -

-.- -.-

~

...., - - - '

:~~g:::;W~r:~·Y~~~~;r-Q1h~r~.is,~in~;T.~~~ir1d~h;;i;;·~e··iD.~e~i~w~,orint~ir99~ti;~;-V1ith-~on;~B'i-person~ei'i

':"'-.- -- -.. . -- -- - - -.- -._- --- - _.- - -- - -~_Y~----~-~q.:: __ - __.
II

~ ---

;1.3~ Di~ .x0u :rec:;ehi~ .~~y ~rainirJ~l~ .iristtudib£1, ;oJ 'guid~lri,C;'e :specifi~ally in pr.eparatipri

,_.

,

-:
- =;

,

far' any:cif y.our

overseas depl0¥ments or assignments?

Dyes

'@No

QDo Not Recall

OIGQ-005437

14. In preparation for any of your overseas deployments or assignments, did you receive any training,
!nstructlon, or guldpnce conC,emlng the .stanqards 9f condu<;~·applicable to~hetreatmel')t~
intervieWf ~r .ih.ter,rdgatfon of-detainees by' Fal persQnn~l?

·.QYes

0No

ODQ riQt Re~al r

15'. II). pr.eparation 'for allY.ofy-our OVefSeqS deployments Of a;;SKIO[l1ents, did you' receive any trqinjng,
In~rUC,!:lplJ, Of 'gu Idqnce qJliCernlng the .s.tan9ard s: pf conp uct <3 pp Iitabfe ~o the 'tre.atl11en~,

intervieW"

or in:.te.t.ro~,ati6,n, o(detain~es

~y li~m-fBI p'ersonliel?

'0No

OYes

-aDo Not Recall

i6'. in p.:rep,a.rationloJ arw"of yqur over~~s d~p.!oy'm~t$·.iJrassignmelJt?r,d id' you

re'cejy~ 9ny 'training;- :
In'~rlJeti6n, Pr"':g'uldcinre ~oiiceniin'g whaq~9~ Were $!JPp:O~d ~o 09 i.f YOl!9bSe~e(l or tJeard ;-al:i,oyt
the"treatmeht,' interview" of'interrogation ·6.f d~tajnees. by FaI perSQliriel r 'whim YblI'be.lieved. to,
be inappr6p'rfate.i.- unprofessional, coe'rci\leia'busive, ot'urUaWfu I?·

:@No:

,~bDo Not Recall

17', tn pr.epprqt.iprl'1'Qr arW.9f ,YQur :oyersea$: depl~ynients''qr ,as$lgn'ments, t:lid yqu r:e~¢jve<'any trcllning, :
in'strUctioh, :or"guidcH'ice .coriceniirjg wnat you were 5uPP'osffi 'to, do ifyou ,ob'serV,edbr heard ;a b'ouf .
the'treatment,'interview~ or interrogation of detainees by non,.FBI personnel; WhiGh you beliEwecf
to be. inappropriate" unprofessional, coef~ive, rclbusive, or unlawful?

I

lB. Tr.alning, During. Ov.erseas Deployments or' Assigtnnemts'.
1~,. Owing ;?ny 9f Y0j:!f oversei3s~eplqyrpents 9t as~ignn:tent~~c\id Y0t,J receive <;lny ~@il]ingT i,lJstr,u~ti9.nr.
'Qr~uJ~J.~hC~·cQI)'C~rn·in~ the stat1di=1'rd~ qf q:md!Jet .aPPl!cable to the:tr$tme~tj:lnJetyiew" o'r
in:ter[Qg'atiQn 'of detain'e~s by FBI pei:'spnli'~1?

·0ygs:

,6r

'ONa

OOQ lIJotRe'Gail

,l,8c!. Wl:fo "proVided this. J;rainingf- insltu"{::tiohr
,gui.da:nc~?
fB~ sup,e!Yfs:or, :q~se Agent, BAU
.
,
l.sb. !3rie,tJy describe the sub?~?!nG~C0r.thetrain,i'19', in~fu~ion; !'1lf gUid~n~e proy[ded to'yOu,
WelccimeAboard, g,eheral standards" LmderStaYnding: Arabic -Culture, etc.
18,c. WC\s\arrY'onhe tiai.nin'!;j, instr'uctibri( or SJuid.afi'ce provided ili'writing?

.¢Yes -ONe'

(j Do !'lot ~E?~an

...

II

19~ D~r:ing any ,ofYQur·pver.,~ds,deproymen(s.o r a'S$.igom~rits;pip yp,U T~~~iy~ an-y trqlning, ll)sfruction,
or guidance'con<:eming thestat'Jdards pf'¢onducLappli¢able to the treatment, interView~,df
ihter'regation ,Of detain'ees by non-FBI personn'el?'
' .

ONo

.0 Do Not Recall

OIGQ-005438

i9a. who proyided thi~ training" insJruction, or gUid,ancel
CITF Supervisor j.GITF Behav.ioral Scientist f Military JAG'
19b. Briefly des,oribe tliesubstanceofthe trairiing~ instructiorlr. or guidance provided to, y6u.
WekQme AboarpJ g:~n¢ral ;standat.ds, l1nderstandio.g, Afabi~ CUlture, E;tC.
19G. Was, any qfth~ trainln9, lhstru¢tion i orgu(dante ptovide9 in' wri~ing?
,
0Yes ONo 0' Do. Not Recall
fl

...

.20.!;>l.Jrioy'any C)fy~)Ur C)versea~ deployment~ or assignments, did yqu .re~eiye any'fr.:jJning; instruction"
or'guidgn.cecpncenilng what YOl.! wer:~'5uPP:9g'eO to di:? if yo,u ,o,Qserv.~d or heard .about ~he
treatment, Interview", 'or Interrogation 6,f:del:Qinees QY FBI perSQnnel,. Which you b-ellev~d to' be
inappropriate! unpr.ofessional" coerCive" abuslve~,ot unlawful?
'

Byes,

'aNo

0'00 Not Recall

'20a. Who proVided this trainIng; instruction( or'Q,uidance?

,I

l.

",'

'

"

b6
b7C

"

:20b., Briefly:qe5cribe the su b.sta'nce, ofth¢ ,trainIng, in$tructiQn, br' g'l1ida,nce, P.rovidel:l to: 'rou.
General state,rp~,~t~~ ne meqe 19 ~rrF PersOQ~~1 ;that ~f)1p,~.a~i?ed the 'fBlinye?tigFlt~s
b.ehaVibu.r to~r9s;d~,tatn'e~,s, wnich WPl.1ld 'JJe;<;onsrder~ abu$lve:
.tOe. Was:,any 'ofth~ training, "instruction, 'or guidgnce provig,ed in 'writIng,?
,
O:y:~s ,0J\liJ .Q D~r Not Re'cali

21. Du ring any. of you r overseas, deployments or assig nments~ did you receive any, fraining,~ i'nstruction,:
qr 9 u.ld.anG~:co/J<:~rnln,9 What Y9u w!3re ~lJ RPQ~ed 'tp (10 If ~6U 'qbs~rve90r r~~rda,bqu,t th,e,
':~reatment, interYlew,..or int¢rr:cg:l.afiQri'Qf~,~t~jjneesby non-FlU per.sonn~l:, Y(hi~b yp~ Q¢I1~.lI¢~ tq ,
be inapptopricHep unptofesslot\airc;ci,e'rcllle~.. aJjusiile! ,or unlaWfui?
'

;ONo

@Yes

QDo NdtRecall

:2la. Who 'pr6.vid€d this training" in'stfucti6A/,;orguida'lice?
CITF S,lj pervf~r
'
:?l,b, '~r1~f1Y'~\=$~rlbe th~ sUbstpn~e oftlle trC!)nl!1g;-tns~r.l:l,ctlonjqr,guldanf'=,~p,rov[ded ~o YQ\l"
General statements made/during scheduled meetings, .
'
~2:1c. WaS. a,ny 'oHhe.traiiiing l instruction, bt gUida,nee P't6.\iided ih-W[i~iI;l9,?
,
'6y~ '~NO' :0 oq.l\1ot Recall;
'~I

"",

Ie. Adequacy dfTr,ainirig

,
,
,-_.
---'
2-2.'In your opinion, ,d id you reeeive -adequate training r itlstructionr or gUittance relating' to .standards,
'of conduct by FBI afld non-F~I :personnel relating to, treatmentj 'interview/. or ihterro,gation of
;c;l,e~a,inees prior to YO,ur.depl(;)yrn~nt:qr<!sSj9nrne'Qf1
,,/,

, ·~i~'.- ~I~as~ 'd~~ib~'th; ;@Y-$-tr. whiG~'Yd~
.• '

~

inatlequClte:
....

-

.......

'':;''''''

.......~

7

~

~w-

~

~

-."

-~,.-

.,.

A

_ _~~';,._.',

byes, 0

No

~~ii~y.~ th~ ~r~!ning; ins~-r~c1kJ~:o~ g~ld,~ri';e'w~'~ -- ~ ... _..
_

'.,~

_.

~.~.. , '

._

•

_'.

'"

......

-.

-0

... ..... ""_'"';

~<;..-:o~

""_w'"

",,"

".

'" ""' .........A_~

OIGQ-005439

__

~_W~

~~._~

__

~_.

~

~

__ M __

~_~.~_~

~_W~~_~

__

~~~~~._~._~

__

._~.~.

_ I~~re _~as~~o~ ~!h~~ !~a!T:wh_a! ~~s p~ov!d~~ .~~~ol;J~ h ~o.f!Tl~! ,!~I!l!n.9 _a!1~ ~~p'~r~e,':l~~" ... _ .

j.

.

23'.,1n ypuropinlbn, dId you r;ecelve adequate training, itrstrudlon, or-guidance relating to standards
'of conduct by FBI and nQn-FB-I personnel relating to treatment j 'inferviewr or interrogation of
detainees during yoW deploymen.t or ,?sslgnrnent?

eyes

d.

No

24. In .your opJrii'on, did YQU receive apequate ~rcli,hil1g, instruction, pr guida'nee concerning what yOU
were $U pposed' to :d6 if "you, 6b~erv¢d b'r' heara, abo.ut theJ:reatriiei:Jt(, inte,I".Yiew, Qr interrogatiQn bf
:d'etainees r by FBI or. non-FBI ,perSonriell'that you believed was inappropriate/: unprofessional,
,coercive, 'abusive" ef unlawful?'
@'Yes
~?,:(opt,on,al) In,whc(t ~ays
~ssjg nments?

0

No

€C!11 tt:J~ f'r31 ilTJpg>Ve",traf':llng, Olrthls $lJbjeg:t 'f9r fut1.!re l;i,~ploy,lTJ~nts 9r

At, the ie:a~l. - Prior' ti;fdeplpv.I,il~r c~nil?let~ <i ~~If paced ~o·re;qltric.uium·:<1ht.iCl~ materl<;l'1 whl~11' c<N:ers,;
,Counterterrorism' Matters Ie. 'Middle, E~rs.tern history /Islam /Kbran:j. Arab-Israeli Issues / basici'Arnbic:
langtlage f etG.

ID. 'Oomments'
4'§. 'P I¢gsj~ Po «Wjd,e 'a ny ;~~ d'itiqria.1 :i r)fdrr'n~tiQ n' cor:ic;~rni,iig tr:a,in'j rig fdr'. 6'Ve:r:s~~:s d,ep.loym,en1$.;,pr
,issig,n'r'n¢fitS of FBI petspnneJ you baliev.e is, rel¢vant.

'

r had to,:stated to;sev,e@1 peOple in ,genernl;dis'c,u~sjtm. fr9'm all ag'~nci~'thaf'P'n,ce the :dust settlcll in
early 2002 - >'OU'!' (Coo nterterrerism .university) shou Id have been- DU i1t ,as.a joiht ag ency proi'ect - Prior:
'tQ"conducj:i,ng, any, il)tervieW5 911 p'er$9.nnel ~bbulq ha-ve I:!a.<;f"refr,esner"'~railling' as weli qS b~en
,
,
'
:schoqled in poli<;y fqr an C!pprbxirrtaJ¢ t'iVo \fJeek: peri~d.:
( still beli~y:e th(s would be aViabJe epur,s,eof a~tfon if(TIt'1Q;survi\fe~! ,

~~,::_}~®;~~.'
I)

0

~,

D IC'

!

'~:~;n:';,
" : : '

• ,

.

:Inlroduction to .Part: III: In:.thls,s·e,ctlpn'" We 'ate :seeking, inf,OlTl)atlon reg ardl.ng ·a Wiele, r.ange bf'
'ihtervieW,or' interrogation teehniqu,es and other; ,types, of de'talriee: treatment' allegei:f' to, naye :0CCU rred.
You should notassume, justbecausewe.are:asking about a particular techniq.ue..or practice, that we hav.e
qmcluq ed ~ha,t it- in. '@c,t 'Qq::lJ~r~d. We ,reGog nize thi;lt::$Om~ of these tecbni~l,Ie'?' Qr PJC!g:Jc;:~?' mi;lY' at ~ime~
ti~ n-e¢e?$r:Y. f~f :$f~t:y i3h9 s~uritY Ih a '<!~~eh~IQn ~etting·. ~t1 atl9lti9Pf V')I€ re~pg:n-IZ~ ll\~t;S9m~ ,qf these
techdittues'Qr'pfadide5, may haVe been a-othorized 'for use oy m,i1itiir'y or othet',goy,ern'meilt'persb.nnel.
IJYitp TE!~p~!=t to, eac~ .id~'1tif!ed t~chn i~I:I.le,p.r..ap:ic~1' -or tYF~ 'of p;md uc~:d e,sc;ribed,bel0o/ ~~ 'an~ seeki.IJg
I;

'infqrin'atiQn:~l:'-Q'l,Jt it$ p,~\;ljrreri~~ s:f~rinJI :or in cQrine~tio'n wi.th th~jJ~t¢ryi~)iV or i.nt_erl:o~~ti9n'gf!i
d~taltu:f~,ord.!.Ir~fj"g. the cJ¢~~f\J'Q.ri (jf a !J,~tain:ee p:~,yond w(tat I,s ng~¢q ,fqr '~.aff;!,ty a'nd $¢~uriJy:

In tnat ;cbnt~t! we will ask' ¥ou to tell us .wnethef 'Qhe or tnbfe of the followi n9, ;statements :ate true:

OIGQ-005440

1. 1 personally observed this conduct.
..2. r.ol?serye(l:detaln~(Q) In .a ,~.or)<;Iltiqn th9! led m~ ~9 Qelleve. :thaphis: t;:onduC):' had 9~cyrred,
3. D.et9ir.i~e(s) Jold me th~t this ccin-ducfhcsd pcciJrr..eil.
.
4,. p~hers. who: ops~rV¢d ,thiS: ~Qnct(j?::~- de;scrlbe,q J~ to m$.
5". I have relevanf information· classified above' liS ECRET" .'
:6; I nevecoQserv:echhis co.nduct nOI; he~rd a'bout jt 'from'~Qrnepne,Whodid.
2.7. D,eprivihg.a detaine.e Qff09d :6.t water
a'.
b,;

D
0

I perSonally observed this,condud.

['observed'detainee(s) in'a condition that led me to believe that this conduct had :occurred.

c. [j Detainee(s) told me that this- conduct had :occurred.
d..

D

q~hers' who observed this con:d uct described

It to me,

e.

o II hq~e relevant il')fofma~10t:1 c1assf(ied qb0Ve II·SECRET·...

f.

0' I nev.er 0bs..erv~·g

t!l\!?'czondu9t

Dar: l'!~rd

ab.ou~ it from sqmeQne. wh.o did.

;28. O:eprlvlng :a',detalnee: of.'c1o.ihlng'
a~

~,

c:-

0 I' personafly' ooserved this conduct.
0 Lo!;lserved' ~et~lnee{s) in.a 'cond itioD t,h<;!t led

me'tQ' ben!?ve -ttJal::~his condm:t. had ·Qccurr~d.

o 'Detahlee(s) told me Jhahhls: conduct had ·occurred.

d.f D Others' W~9 ob~er.v.ed this C9nd.uct,de?criQ~~ it to··m.~.
e.:

[l'

r bave relevant InfQrma~lorrtia~slftetl Clhpv~: I!SEC~"·.

t 0' L il~Ver oQS,¢r\(ed' ftils·amdLJd: Ji()(hear:d ·abQui it from SOlT1¢Qt1~:wh\:t did.

~29. Depriving

a detainee ofsleep" or interrupting 'sleep by fre9liehtcell relocations ,or .other methods

(]' il p~rson·ally·o,b.~erve,~

~hi.s 'Cpndu!=t.
bi- D ir-()b~er-vec!'deti=llnee.(s) in :''l'C9h.d itiqn'tbcjt Jed.
to ~E?ney~ th~t this C;;:Qn~u~t !1?~ ·o'G,curred.,
!=:' o 1D~~~inee'(s)-to!~ ,m~ that :t/:1l~ C;:bn9.lJc.:J: had ncc;u.rr:~f ..
d .. D !6tMm iNliQ p!:5seryed .t~is CQt\duct d'escnbcil 'tt ~q me.
e, D Ii hj.;lv¢·r'~I~yant infprmatiptn:;';;fs·sifie.d.~bove lI:SECRET"',
f:
I~, neVer 0 Ds¢rv:ed this ;cj)ndU~t nor 'h~ rd ,3 bout It from .someone.Who. did.
a'..

me

o

.30. Beating a detainee

OIGQ-005441

..

..

.,

b.

D
D

c.

o !Detainee(s) told me frat this conc(lJd ~ac! 'Qccuf,red.,

a',

d.
e.,

I personally observed thls..conduct.
II.observed detainee(s) in cl'{';ondition that led me to believe that this conduct had occurred.

0 tJther,s. who ob$er:ved this COhduddE;s<::,ribeq It to me:
have relevant information classified al;)Ove "SECRET".
D I-----_
. _------ ----_. _... -

,...- -'-

'.-

10 r never obse~ed this tgndl!d nor heard a~o~t. it from SQmeone~ho did.

f.

,31. ,Using water'to prevent br.eathlng byadetalriee,or to create the "Sensation; of droWnln.g

'i!l.
bi

0
0

I, p~rspnally' ops!=l"f~d tbis:cqndu(::t.

~;.

p

De~aine'e(s) tQld rn~ 'thqt'thi~ l:::onclu~t had 'Qccurr.ed.

H)I;l's~,rved det,~inee{s) In :a:cqndltlorp;h~t I~ 1l1~ ~o' b.elleye· thqt this c<?nduc,t had 'ocrcurrec,L

<1:, D Others, WhQ Qb~ry~ this; GQ[),<llJ~t-,d,es'~dl;le9 it tp:me.

e'. 0

I have
'relevant lnformatlon'tlasslfled
.ab·ove
"SECRET''',
""
'"
,,'
" .
' , '
~

,

f. ._0,1(.._...
riev.er,6pse!"l.ed
someorte,whq
dIet.
--# thiscontlu~.tfJpt·hea'td
..
. _.. _._-- ...._._..ab,out:
- ---_.it from
_..
.. :--._-----'-

-

_~_.---._.~~_.-

~--------_

----~.-

~

__•

¥h

...

~

__ •

__

._-_.~

32. Using hands, rope, or anythil')g else to choke or strang.Je a 'detainee

a. 0 I p,er~nQny·opsetvea thi~ ~ondud.
I); 0 I 9b~~rv~d d'eti3inee(s) in.:a.:cpnd it1ol) that I¢P m~ tfn)~lJeve
c: D pe:ta1n¢e'('i) mid me that ~hl~ t'(>l1dlJ.tt hat! occurr.~.

t,hanhi.!! q'onc!!Jl;t o~(Fo¢c,urr~#,.:

d.

o fOther's: Who oQserved this con:dutt,deS:cribed it tq. me.

~.

0

I' hp,ve T~lev.a:nt i1'lformatiori' tlas,sified 'aboVe II S.EC REf" .

f.

10

I n~v.er ob'se:rv~d: this conc:iut,t liQrhear~ GibOUllt .frOm.sOMeone. who did.

-33, Threate,nillg other actjon to 'cause' physical pain" injury,.d fsfigu,rement" or d:eatlT

•;:r. 0 I' p~e(.sqfl~lIy'obse-l'\Igd. ~hls:condut::.t .

b. D. r: olJ.setved detalrte.e(s) In :.a ~cond itioll that ied me. to belleYe'that this cqlid.Uct haao:ccurr:e~.
c.

D

,Detaine$(5)

told

m:e tHat (iii?, crondl-{ct' ht:\d ot¢'orreo.

D Others' W.h.D observe'd thiS't:oritl,uct.destribea It to me:
e. 0' r havexele.varit il'1formatiotJ classified a50Ve '$ECREr".

.d.

t

10 I never o.bseived this, conCl uCtnpr heard a bout. it froni, sorrieeile who did.

OIGQ-005442

34. Othe'rtreatn:i~nt ot adion causing significant
death,

p~ysical

pain Of injury, ort;a'using disfigur:ern.¢nt or

a. D I per9Ql1aIlY'qb?erved thl$ con<;iuc,t.
q. D I pb;;e:rved detainee(s)' jn ,a ttmditipn thi?t led me to belie~e that:thi~,cohdutt had occurred.
c. D oeta'inee(s) tol9 me that this conduct !lad ;o¢curred.
(1. D IOth¢.rS: WhQ pbser)leo tl'ii!? conduct ~eschbed It.tQ me.
..
e. D l' ha-qe relel,iant ir'\formatiotl c1a$'sifiecl above, "SECRET".
f. 0 [ never ob:;eliied this :cQn~uct nor hea ref 'a bou,t; it from -someone wtio dieL

~3'5.

Placlhg a detalnee:on a hot surface or burning a detaInee

a', D I per.~nciliy QDserveti ~lils cpnpu¢t.
b, D Injb~s-elV~d gexaine¢(s), in' :a:~oiid jtio(ithatl~ me tb' b-eli~v(;Hhat tlii$" !=oi\'tluj:;!: ,hap qcc;t,lrr¢tl.
c: D Inetainee(s) tOld TfI~ that thi$, conduct hc(d ,occurred.
'd',

e.

D Othe'rS' wh'Q ,6b$erV~

D
f. 0

T. haVe

this p,dndu'Gt des¢Hb.ed it

to me.

relevant infon'riatibii Glassified above '~SEc.RETJI.

I.ne\tet observed

this,cQndu~t

nor,hea(d about it.f(om.someoriewho did.

a,. D L petsdni,dly' (jbse,ni~d' this i=6fidu(:~.
b, D- r ,obsetve'd aetain~e(~) in:a c9r1ditiOri that le,d nie: to beii~Ye that thi.s e<:YnduGt had .occu:rr;~d.
c. D petaine~(s) told Tn'e that this cOliduct ha'd ,occurred.
! - ~d. D Others~ who ooseJited 'this conduct d.escribeo it to me.
e: D II have relevant 'information cJ:assified abov.e !!S,ECRET''\
f: lil..llnev.er 0bserved this'C0nduct nor heard ab0ut It 'from ,someone, who. did.

~j, ReqUirh.ig:,a.get4in~:to m<;ilnb;lin, or re?trciinin11 <;i'detainee in, a 'slress.fu.J Qr painful po~ifi(m

b.

0' !1 personal!y' observed, this ,conduct.
0. II' obserVed ,detalnee(s} in a.condition that led me to, Eieliev.ethat:1.his conduct had ,occurred.

c.

[j !Defainee(s) tala me that this cond'uct fiad :OcQ.lrred.

a.

OIGQ-005443

-

,.

IS

e. D I have relevant Information classIfied above '(SECRET".
f. [j r never observed this;conduct nor heard about it from someone, who did,

,g'. Pl~a?e pJQyidetlie apprQxilTF~te tirne'frar.n,e dOJlng which t,his c<?nduct"occurred,
From Q~fZ002 to Q,5!2002
Dno NbtReccili
h. Th~ det?linee(.§) tre.ate9 in this way were loc~~ed at the time in:
i Ji::rGl!antan!=lmo
2 D ,I!C;!q
;3 D Afghanistan
II D Other LOCatiQn
5 D Do Not Recall .
i. PlffiseJdeotify'the defain.ee(s)
[ can not recall'
' '

by name and

'j. Ple51se, i<;l~ntif'i th~ 'P.~r!?9,n (~j, Whq lr.~~te~l
n~m!=Cs), anA 9:9Y~rnrtrentagen.cyo.e·s):

Qne of eadt o'manizatiofl.

'

,..

number;'

,

th'e, qe,taln~e{$)

in t,h is; rtl~l)ner i' incl,ll(fitig their

,

.~. PI~ase'ldehllty,a'i1y.r,mJ~r F~i lJer~nn'ell:?r nQn-FBI .p~rSQI:lI:leIWli~' O!;l5€rved 'd,et91ne.e(~) m~at.ed
'iii this: manner,- including their name(s) and 'a9'ency(ies):
I do ,not remember Qut 't'his, was- a ,pig issu~ ~Qd ,hlg Illig ht~d ,~,urilig ,the next dgys' meeting..
'I. "(tiis conduct oecurred in 't;:,9nneq:ion w.i1:t1~
i0 0IJe,d~~C1fnee
2 Q ~$,ey.e(al cie~aine¢s' (2-4)
!3 ,0 M~l'nyQ~ta.ihe-e5 (mbr~ th;:ln'lg.l
4 d Do Not Recall

.

m. (-bptipnal) Plea.se describe, tlte' r~leyant dt:curnstances: in 'mote d~tail:
,

,Ade~c;llnee w9's.$'Crea.rnl.ng in Arabic In:or~er to,cQmmuni,cateto pther.~et9"nee's nQ,i t9 cq~perqt~,
iii 'one,of the intervIew r~om,s. ~dm¢6tle de~i,de.d t6 rerhQ'Ve: h[s ,ph.air and h,ave 'him stand hunched
over. I ,was, observing' the ,adjbihiii~r interView 'room frori1,theobsehiatlbn rooin and saW the
'd~ta'inee lay .down on ~he fl!"Dr ,and tlJe guards f1)ad~ him stan,d:
'
3~ .. furd\lg a deta'inee' to-perfo!,Tn:dernaudfng pl)Yslcal'exercise

,a.

b.

D II p"~rsOnaliy o,pserve:d this Condl1ct.

o II cibserVeddetafrtee(s) in fa condition that led me, to betleve ~hat this- con'du!=lha'd dtcurrep.

t. D fDetalnee(s} told me thC\t this- cond uct had 'oc,curr.ee1.
!o~hers; wh~ obse)'Ved this Gbflci uc,t d~~c;:tibed it to. me.
e. D hav,e:relevEint l!'lf6tmatibi:i Classified above "SECRET".

.d.

d

II

f. IiI'

II never o'bserved this.conduet nor heard about it froni someone 'whb did;

OIGQ-005444

'39. -Using electrical shock'en a detainee
<;1.

b'.

0 t personally op~n(ep this cQnduct.
0 I' ob:Serv~d ~etal,liee(sJ in';;:1 cond ition that I~

me. to belieY~ thanhis conquct had dccurreJ:f.

c. J;!~tai ne~($~ tQlq me that this t:oncllJ!:t hi3'd occu rred.

c--

d.

o pth.ers: Wh'o observ~d this conduct de.s~rlbed It to me.

e.

0

f.

I have relevant iMQn:ilation .classified abov.e '!SECREf"'.

It1 iI never observed this;coh'duct not heard ,a bciut it from s0meone\vho did.

40;'. 'Threat~nipg to use 'e,lect[ical shock:gn a detainee
a.

D'

I pe:r.sPnaliy ol:l,servep this,conduct.

b',

o

Ir,.O~se'rv,:e:d,MtaineeXS) In ,a:cotid,lti<:m'that 1M me' to

c.

0
0
0

Detainee(s) told me that this conduct hao O€Cll'rred.

,d.
e.

bgUeVe t,haUhls, c,on:duct had ,oc,tuned.

Others who ,observed thiS condUct describe-a it t6 hie.
~'have rejevant lliformatlon classified aboVe '~SECREf\
.....------"._ .. '"

f. ~ l' never Observed thiS :,condliGt nor'heartl,abblit it ftGlni,someone'who did.

41. IntentiotlC)l!y delaying ,qr~enyfng

detainee med"<."al :cc)(e

0 I personally' observed this conduct.
b. 0 I ,observed 'detairiee{s) Iii ,alcond ition that.le<I me to believe that ttitS conduct had ,0ccuti:eCl.
c. 0' ID'etalnee(s-) told me that thls eoilduct had 'occurr.ed.

,a.

d.

o lathers who ,obserVed 'this conduct descr]lJed it to me.

,e.jO I have relevant inrormation classified a'bov.e ~!SttREf".

f, 0 t

42'.
So,

nev.er,o,bserveq thl? 'Co'lldy~t f1~r hEX!rd -about: it from sQmeO!1~ "Yho, did.

'Hoo:dihg,or blindfolding :a'd.etaine,e~other ~han :during tr:ansp:o:rtatkm

0

b. el

I perSonally obse'rved this conduct.
I observed detaineets) in a c::ond ition'that led me to believe that this conduct had ;occurred.

c. 0 Detainee(s) tC?ld me that this condt:let had :occurred.
d.,

0

Others who observed 'this COhductd~cribed ft, to m~

OIGQ-005445

e. 0

·

I have relevant Information classified above- '!SECRET",

f. It! I never observed this:conduct nor'heard about It from someone who did.

43.. SUbj~il'rg :a.detaln~-ro .~tr,eh1eIY cold d~ hOt room .temperatures-for extehtled p'eriQds.

a. 0 I personallY observed this·eoOOud.

b. 0 [·observed detainee(s) In 'Cl condition that led me to believe that this. conduct had 'occurred.
c. 0' Detalnee(s) told me that this conduct had ;occurred. d. 0 Others who .observed this rondu.ot·described it to me.

0 t hav.e relevpri~ [t:lfqrrnp~h;m di3?~jfi;ed :Clb9V~ "SI;CRET"·
t. 0 ~. n!:?-ver·observ~'d ~hl,s"eQn~l,l~ '!lgr .h~r.d "q,bgut: I~ :frpm ·sqrneon~who did.

~.

-g. P'~~·se. P.J('jv\(j¢..~h~ ~pp'rQxim:ate time. frame'~l,lrlng.WhlaJllh.i$: co'(f~tlf9t {:!p;:.Lirred.
From .04l2QP:3. to (A/20(n
000 Not, Recall
h. The~etqln~(§'l tr~t¢Q :In .tI}rs way were' IQ~ai:~.atJt):§! ~ime 1!1.:
1 [i;:J ·Gu~ntanamQ.
';i 0 IraQ
3,O,Afqh"anis.tan
:4 0 'Ofher location
sO Do Not Recall.
I. "Please'ldefltlty"the;detalr1ee('s) by hame and. humber;

76'0
j, PI!'!ase". fdetttify the person(.sYwho .treated .the detaine.e(s)

hi' .thls· ma.nnelif fncludlng their

name(s),·anCl ,goy.emmerit ag'eocy{ies)~
Unknown
.
k, PlesSe. iil,entitY any' otner. FBI. p'ersQnt\el

of n6n~F.BI

personn'el WhO:observ.ed detalnee{sr tre"a"tetl
,

I in ·thiS mj~j,..IIiCJUding their nam~(s);and.agendY(iesJ~

b6
b7C

i. Thjs.:.cfji'il:ll!¢t .ocG.llrt¢d in tQnneq:i.pfl wtth':
:I,..C!) .(jn·e. d:e~ain~

2 0 .Sev.eral d.e.t"airi~ (;2-4)

3'0 Man'y.:tletairie:es {nioreth"an 41"

:4-.0

Do Not Recall

rtl. (DptIO.ri:::lI)·PI~se: deScrtbe. the. relevant clrcumstan'ces In more"detall:

Aft~'injti,lIIy refUsing .to taJ'k in the ~~inl);ing (01/2003) of .allr

pr0ect '.?6.0:.a;gf'ee:d tot<iIK 'and

OIGQ-005446

appeared toa'ctually enjoy our meetings. Then one day he refused to talk, hot one word and he
looked very.upse~
land I spent"a 16ng time with him "explorIng why he behaved so
my,sterlously.. Sqrprlslr19l.y ~tTe n~xt day ~e beh¥lved as nothing had happene~. When askeg why
he,satd Ilis Qa<;:k bp~her:eg him Q~use he had ,been I~ft in' 'a tot~ rOPm prior to OC,lr meeting.

:44. Supjecting. 'a de~aJnee

_.

to loud. f.TlJ.lslt

__

__

a....- D
1i p¢rs6naily
this conduc.t.
........
....-... - obs~rved
.. - _ ..........
._ ..

... -.- ..
..-- _." ,-"- - _.. .--- _.. _...... -_ .... "_. --' ......... '--D I obser:v~d .detainee(s) ih ,a cbnd ition ~hat led me to be;lie.v.e that this' cbhdu,ct- had occurred.
0 'D$,tainee(s·) told m~ .that this. condutt ha,d ,dccurred.
0 IOthers.' who nbse.hred tms conduct described it to Ilie.
D I have relevant information c1assifieda'bolle "SECRET'!.
0 I never' Q,bserved this"conduGt nor' h5:lr(f about. iUroni.someone Who did.
,.

b,
C;:.

d.
e.
f.

b6
. b7C

~._

-..-

~-

~.

~.-

~._,-

'

45,.s~pjectil1g, a detainee to bright flashing lights qr d~rkness

a'. 0" l' P:erS9n~liy:6~S~rv.~~ t.tiis!:cdndu~~.
,

h. D. I:Qb:setv.ed· d¢taln~~e(s): in:a ·cp'nd·iti6n.'that I¢d 'm~ to oelie'l¢ ~ha,t this cgn'd,uCt had :occurred.

c.

0 petainee(sj told rtJe ~Mt this- O:Oridu.tt had ,oc!=urreq,.

d,

o lothers' who observed t.his ceDtruct d,¢s'crlbe(i It to me'.

'e. 0' r have relevant information Classified aBove, '~ECR6T".
f.

0

never-observed this colicfucf:nor'heard 'aboi:Jt.itftoffi' someone'\,vh6- did. '

46., Isolatl~g' ?lge~ainee f9.r an ~~endec;l perl0r:t

a. D r p~r..s9haliy,.ob~rve:tr this.c6ridQ~t.

..

.

,

b., d hi,bserveti det.aine~(s.} In.;:1 conp ltlon'that, led me, to belle,v~ ttidt.~hl$' <;:ondlJl:t naL! 'qd:ur~e#:
t: 0' iDetainee{s), toid me ,that this c,ond uC,t had 'o.ccu'rr:ed.
,I

observed 'this tqndLict d,e~cfib,ed it,to.m·e.

d. D
e:ID

O:therS: wbo

f. Itf

r. riev,er observed. this"cohduct nor heard about it from,someo'rie'who did.

1 have 'relevant Information classified ~boYe ':SECRE[".

47. Using, duct t-ape to' restrain,,!l§.g.jor

~:.:.;n:.:.;:is;.:.;h;..;·8::...d:;..e::.;t.;;;a;.:;in:.:;e.::,e

_

OIGQ-005447

,

0 I personally observed thls,conduct.
b. 0 I observed detainee(s} In a'cond ition that led me to believe that this conduCt had 'Occurred.
c. 0 D~~ajnee{s) told me that tpis condl,Jet ~ad 'occutTec;I ..
d. 0 Other? who 'ob'$erv~ 'thls cpndiJd !;I.~qibed It to me;
rerevant information classified ab'ove "SECP.EfJI..
--------------- -------e.f. 00 rI hav.e
n~v~r 9.bserved this t(jn9~d nor heard abp4l it from '~me~>.ne'who dip.

C3~

: - - - : - - . _ - - - _ •• _-_.~--

•

> ---_.

48'. Using, rapid respbn,~e teams -and/or forced tell·extr.actlbhs

Itf r. personally observed this cond.uct.
b. 0 [obser:ve(j-detalnee(s) In'a'condition that led me to belle:vethat·this c0nouct. had occurred:
e,_ 0 Det-ainee(s) tol~ me that this. ~ondUl;:t h?d occqrred.
~: 0 OtJ~e~.? w:h9'?Rsery~d this ~.c;)I':)ql,g:t c!~~9ribe~ j~ tq n:Je.:
e., 0 I h,?v,~ Jel~va~nt IlJf~rmatlq.n. ~1~~s.lfl~ C! b9V~ "$'ECItET'! ..
f, O' ~ n~Ve.r o~perv~,q this 1<;Qnd u¢t n9r h~r~ ;-abOllt· it from: sOI)1~~n~·1.Yno did.
a.

. £1.. Please' provide the ~p·pr.o~itnat~time 'fr'im~.. during~h!c'h this Gonduct:qcGUrr.ed, .

~(qm .c.M!QtrYYY format or MfYYYY) to (M/D./'fffY·; i6~mat 'or M/YYYY)
in 'this wP¥ were I6cateP a.t the tirii'¢ ji1:.
'1 0 Gllanta'i'lamd
2.0 I~q

0D'o Not Recall

b. 'rh~ ·d.etaitl!=~(s) tr:eated

3D.Afghanlstan

.4: 0 ·Other Location
.50 09 ~ot R~lI
i., PJease,identify,the..'d"etaii1.ee(s) by name and numbe(:'
Ldo
not·
reca II
" .
"
', ....

pr~ase id¢ntifY th~' per~6ri( 5) 'WhO' .treated the d.e~ainel;{~} iii t.his rtyanber;., jr'iGiuding ~h:eit
':Iame(S):aild 9o,VernmerJt cl9'ency(lesJ:
.
0;5. Army 1 National ,Guard. personnel

1.

~. Please identify ari.Y' O'ther' fBI pe'rsom'1el or non-FBI personnel Wh-o observed detainee(~). treated
in 'thlS'"manner~ indud'ing their name(s) and 'agencyXies)~

I. T~is-c(;mguc~ occllrredjlJ corrnep:io!" with:
1 0 ·One detainee

2 ~ ·Severp.l de1pinees (2-4 j
:3 Q Man'y 'detalnees'(more t~an 4)

OIGQ-005448

4.0

09 Not Recall

fl:l. (Optional) Please d,escri~e'the

Tel~ant c;:ircumstances

In mOJe detail:-

I .onIV' remember the ERr team deploying sev:eral times but can not remember w.itnessing them
interact wittr a qe:taio~

49. lJsing a military. working dog on or near a detainee'other than during detainee transportatio"n,-__

a. Ii'! I pe~naIlY'obs:erved this tOnduc.t.
b. D tdb~rv.ed·detalne~fs) it) :a·cpnqitiont.hat. Jed me t6 belleye ~ftat this: conttup:. h!=l~ ·ocQJrr~d.
c. D E!.etain~(s)tbld me tha.t thl~ t(;:lt)'dutt I]aet :6CCl,!rr~_
iL D Oth.erS whO bbser'Vea :this' conduct described it tb me
a. D I' have relevant InformatiQn' tlas,Slfled 'above ~S.ECRET".
f. D I. neve'r ,obser'vea this ,coMuct not hea"td alXilit It .from,sOmeone·who did.

:g_

Please provide .the a'pproximate tiine"fraine.dunng "whiGh this l":OOdI.kt:.Ol":Cu'tred.
Frqrn Q~/LQO~ to b7l200.2·
Lto.o Nat; ~,ec.a1J
h. The d.etainee.t"S) treated 'in:ttifs way .werJi located at the time'ln.
,1 Rf'Gllantanarrio

2 D'iraq
:3 0 Afg~111~tan
4 0 ·O.tlier location
B6 Not Retali

'sO

I; .,rl~se(i.qenilfy ~he: detC!ln~(~) b,y.·n~m.e al1~( n!,lmber,:
,All 'tletainees ~urin9 iiiitial-arrilial irrcom"p.ourid.

oj, Please Identify' the perwn(s') who Jreated the'detainee(s;) In ·this" manner:1 im;:luding their
n~~~(~)·~n"q gq:r~rnrn~ta"gel]tya~~t

Natlo'na'i Guard

~ PI~.~ ~dentifn'll1Y:dthel" FBI R~rsQnll~! !'Jr' nQn-FBf personne.1 'whp-'Qb~rv~t;f d,etalne~{s) tr~t~
10 1h!S niatinet-I IncJut;fi('!'g ~helr na;rn¢'(~) arJtl,ag~h'd{(IeS);
Most·'
..
.
I, This 'conduct 'occurred In .connectien with:

1·0 One deti'linee
2 ¢ $everal t;fe"t<;lin~ lZ-41
3:0 Many t1etainees .(rn(jn;~ than' 4t
4 ,0 Oq}~ot ~II
.

OIGQ-005449

Upon in'itfal'aiTiva.l dete'lineeS- .were placed ~utside the yarQ

working dOgs b,eing

so. Threate,nlng t<;>

pres~nt.

awaiting pr.oc~~ing 'anct

r rememb:er

use mUitary wo(klng dog$ 'on' .01' near- a (Ida!nee

0 I perSonallY obserVed this ,conduct.
b. q r .0bserved detalnee(S) In :a.eond Itlon that led me. to. believe that this conduct had occurred"
Co, 0, Ioetaihee(s) told me that this eo'nduct hi3d occurred.
d. 0 O,thers who observed this conduct described it to. me.
e. 0' I have reJev.alit Information' c1asslfiedabov.e 'lSECRET"·.

a.

f~ ~~

a.

II, l,1::v~robsery~_ thfs ·£o~rl~c:.tn9rh~ rp ;a bb~~~t!~~_~m~on!=;

W~9~d ld.

I

o ~ persal)ally;.6bserv:ed tl1is.,cohdi.i~t.

f

Ji. 0 ~ 'bti~erved.detarnee(s) ih ~ cond1tioh that led me to beli~:ve.that this ,cQ"nduct had 6,cturred.

c. 0
d. 0

Detainee(s) told me thatthis conduct had ,occur.red.
Others who obseritea :this. conduct descrfbed it to me.

e.

d

f.

0 I

I- have releYant informatiOn classified above ',lSECRET'\
never observed thls:condud nor heard 'about It from 'someone who· did.

52... Threatenjng to l:fse'~pid~J:S, sc;orp'ionsr .snC:lke~, or 'other .anim9'ls ona (!e~inee

a.

0

I' perSciriany observed this t6Jiduc:;:t.

b.. o II,.observed detaine,e{s) iri :a,condjti6h that led me 'to believe .tliaUljis, conduct. had ',oGcurteCi.
o hetatr'iee(s) tQld me' tliat this condu,ct had .o.ccurred.

c:

'd.

ef lOt herS' who oOSehled tHis celiduct.tte.Scribed

e.

0,

it to me.,

L nave relevant information classified above. !',g-EGRET".

f: [~f I'neverobserved this 'conduct nor heard about it from someone who did.

53. Disrespectf\,JI ,statements, ,handling, 'Or:qetiOns' involVing the' Koran

OIGQ-005450

0

a.

I personally observep thl~ -<;Qndu<::t.

o ir observ~d

b.

d~tain~e(s) ip:a .col1d)ti9-n that led '!I.e to believe that ~his ~qr:tdu9: had oC;<;l,Irred..

o tDE:!h'linee(s)-tol~ m~ that th'ls COn91J.C~ h<ld 'oc;curred.

G·

Q, 0' OtherS Wh9 ·observ¢.d 'thi~ !=:oJlduct des,c'rfbed it tq. me.
.e. 0 i haVe tele"~nt information dassifie:d above "SEGR,ET".

0

f.

,g.

I.nr=~eq)b?erved this conc,tuct npr'h~rd C!b91J.tidrom somep.nr=wh9'9i.d.

Please

provide .the approximate timerrame.durihg whicli .this, conduct.occurred.

From 01{2003
to 0'6/200:3.
h. To!=, ,detaine~(s) '.treatei:l·

DDo ,Not Recali
'.'

hi this way. w.ere lotated at the time In::

l'@'GUantanarfld'

20 Iraq
3 0 Afghqflistan
4- 0 'Qther LQcation

50

Dp. N¢t Recpli

t.· P'1e,ase:lden~lfY·the:eJetalnee(s)

7pO

'

by. name an.<f number:

j. Please identilV the per-sones)' who .treated the'detainee(s) in this manner/. induding their
"name(s) and g9vernment agencY.Des}: ,
."

'I<:. Please identify aiiiothei FIJi per.seinnel orno'rr-FBI:persormel 'Who..observed detainee~?) tfeated
in this manner/ including their'name(s] and i:\gency(ies):

I

I

b6

'

b7C

I. Thls;~bildI.Jct ,ol;:dmed in tonnect~on .with:
f ~O 'Qne.. detainee .
2 0 .,Several detalh~s (2-4)'
3
Many' detainees '(mbre than 4:)
,4;
0e;>. ~ ~t Reca II .

-9
P

:m. (Optional) Plea'se describe the: relevant Circumstances. in more,detail:
I'seerri to remember atfis(:ussion with :Z60: in WhiGh he rela'V,ed

that otber-.detainees· we'fe~Li,pset

be€a.use the guardswel'e ha'ndlihg theirKorails.
54,. Bhi:lv,ing:a oe,tai,riee's facial or other hair to .l'!ilibarrass'or,hlifnUiate ii aetainee

(-a:[D]L p~r~nqUy' o,bserved this t:onduct.

OIGQ-005451

c.
d.
~.

r:

0
0
0

Detalnee(s) told me that thiS' conduct had ,occurred.
Others who observed this conduct described it to me.

r have relevi,3!lt infqrmatjon d~ssif\~ i!J?ove I\SECRp-IL.

0" I

nev~r observed thIscQlJc:M:;tnor heard about' it frqm someonaWhb- ~id.

.~5. PI?\Cihg q womat{s Glpthing 9.n:a .oetainee

I pers6nally' obser'v.ed thiscondu.tt..

b.

0
0

c.

q

Detainee(s)·told me that this cendud: had :occurred.

d.

0 Others who 'obserwed this conduct described It tQ me.
0 I, ha,ve releyal1t i'nJorro!:ltiop. c1assrff~ ~bove "'SEGRET"'.

a.

'e.

Lobseived detain~e(sl in a conoitior'dhat led me to believe that this,conduct had .occu'rred.

f. 0" I, nev:er'o.pservec!

56:,

t,~f?'~oQduft nor h~rd ab9uq~ fr()ryJ som~q!1e w~o (:119.

Touching:a d.;tainee or acting

0
b. 0

a;

toward

a :detaili~ 'in a' se){ualli!onner

.

L petsbhally-ooser.ved this :C.O(idU,ct.

I:ebserved detalneet~) in a:.condifion that led 'me' to, believe that.'this condud: had .occurred.,

o

;O.etainee(s)-told me thatlhis conduct had :QCCli"rred.
c.'
d. Cl Others, who observed -thiS conduct·described it to me.

0
f. 0'

e.

I. have relevant information classified above "S.ECREpl..
I neverQQserve~' ~his,'colJdlJct n9rh~rdab.out it frol]1'sorTJeon~who did.

:?':?, ,HQl~jn9

.detaln~($.)' VJhp"'W,~Te: npt offl:c).aILY ClC~)10\AJ!~g~~ or r~ls,tere<;l ~rs s,uch by t.h~'<mency
'9¢taih'iilg, ~h¢. pe(sol'l'.
.
'a'.

0

I personallyn,bserved this coridud_

b. o ![observed detafnee(s) in -a 'eond itionthat led me to l1elieve that this lZonduct had 'occurred.
c. 0 De~aiflee(s) tq!d ,m_~ t~i?t tNs ~0.nd.uct had qC~l,JrreQ..~
c0rrduct" de~c;:ribed It to, rne.

(L 0

Ot~ers' who -obsery!¥.l t~i,s

0
'f: 0
..

I have ,r~l~vant. ip(ormati<?n .classifiec\ .C!b9ve 1~'SECRET'f.

Ie;·

I neVer:o.bsel'\l~.cI, thfs'conp~ct n()r heqrd apolit
..w•....

w.

v •

• 0

....

..

......

.

...

_

~

I

•• w

it from.sQl11eon~who
di~.
.,
.... ......
_

..

,

"0"

.. .

... .
~

..

•.• _n._

....

OIGQ-005452

.58. Sending.a detainee to another Country' for 'niare;agg ressive int¢rr'ogati6.ri
a',

b.

c.
"9.

e.
f.

0 I per~f1ally ob~rved this conduct.
0 ~·Qbser~·~d. de~qfn'ee(s) jn a-cohdifiQn that 1et1 me to belieye th1=lt this cor:rducJ had;occurred.
0' Oetainee(sj tol9 me that this conduct hap occurred ..
0 Others' who obsery~ thl~ ~on911ct desc;:rlbed it ~o' {TIe..
0 I hcNe relevant lriformatioll" :da's'siffed aboV.e, "SE.CRET".
0 I: n'e\?er obS.¢rveg tlii$.. c6nduG.t nprh~rdab9ltt:it frQm~rne~:>n¢ Who dJd.

59. Th.reaJ:eiiing to .send a detainee

la~ 0
b..
c,.
£I"
~.

f,

t. p.e~~nC!IJY·9pserved·

to another .country, for t1etention or'moreagg ressiife interrogation

,h~s:cQnd(J~t.

t9 Q~ne'(Te.lhgt" ~hi~ cc;mdu~t .~ad ·qGcwreq..·
0
0 !Detajl1~(s) ~9.I~ me thqt tbis. t:o.ncj"!J.cJ hq.d 'Oc;:cur[~,
0 OtherS> Whp Qb$ery~d thi~..GRnQ uc:~ .d.¢~"crihed i~ tl): m~:,
D. l' 11:;J~e rele'iant iD.formcttion tlassified aboYe: ''$:.EC,R!:J"'.
0 I tiev.~r·QPSer)[~d this:cQildu:tt il,pr heard ~ab(tu~ it frQI'nSOr'iJeone;whQ djd.
~~9Pserv~q det.ainee(~} in .q :c:pnd it.iontha~ led me

'00. Thre:atening to take actibn.ag,<ilnsta C1.etalnee'S·fa'mlly

0
bi 0
c. 0
Q. 0
g~

. e'.
f.

I p~rsonany O'pserved this :cqnduct.
r'obs~rved det9'll1ee{S) II1.arCOJ1dlt~l;)[fthqt

red lJl~to' benev~ th~~ t~is condu,ct

nad 'oGcqrre'd,'

Q~t~jnee(s)'WJ~ m!';; thElt tois conduct ~a-o :oq:urr:ed,
Qtners. w.ho 'O~s~ry~.d tl:!is. ~~:H:rdl1ct d:~$,criQ~

i! t~)' m~

CI [thave relevant Ir:iformat.ion l;:1,:i,ssifleCf 'abtj\l~' "\$:ECRE:f'~.
0' i n~v€r q.bJ5~r\(ed' this t(j~d uct nor h$ ~d abbuj ft frOm SQm:ebni:!- whp: plp.

81. Q.th~rtreatm.ent bradiOri tclus,in9, severe:erb6.ti6nal or J)sy~h'(;)logjtal traumata a 'detainee,

~r per.sonally observed

this ·conduct.

OIGQ-005453

,

"

..

b. 0 L observed detalnee(s) In acond Itlon that led me to believe that this conduct had :occurred.

0 Oetainee(s) told me that this: conduct had ;occurred.
d. 0 Q~hers' whC? observed thi$ cond u~t dE;scri~ed it to m~.
:e. 0 r hav~ reJ~vant inf,ormaticm classified, Abov~, "SEc;RET".
f~ 0 ~ never'observe,d this '(;pnquGt nQr heard 'about it from someone Who did.
c.

'g'. Plec;l~e. provide th'e. Mpr~~im9te time Tr~'me 'during whi!=h this conU,u~t oCGutred.
000 Not Recall
,From (M/D/YYYY format or MjYYYY) to (MfDfYYYY format or Mf{YYY)

h. The getafnee($) treqted in this way were. Jo.C'Cltefi at the time in;
1 0 Guantang'mb

20'lra;q

3.D :Afghan'ls,tan
4 0 Other Location
~ ,0 00, ~Qt R,~J!
I: :Ple.ase,identlfYthe,derainee(s) by nam~ arid: niJmber::
M9st <IE?t~ine~s

j, Plea$~ identify .the, p~r:sQri(s) Wlt0 tr¢at~'d'Jh'e.q~tain~~(s) in ~h'j~ m:anh~r~ InGludjng their

'riar.ile(s):~i1id,govemment'agelie;yCleS}, '

All .

, . '

k, Please id.ehtlfy' ariY othe'r FBI p'erson'tiel or non"FBI ,p~ts6nnel Wtioobserv.ed detalnee{~). treateCl
in this:manner, rncluding their name(s) and agency(ies) ~

: I~ TI1,is"coQdue:t 'Qccurr.ed in c<?nnectio]1 \A(itn:·

10

cOne detainee

:2 :0 ·.$~v,~ri;ll,detaifl~f;.s'(2-4J
30 fVlany detainees. {more, than 4)
·40 Db NOt Recall

m.

PleaSe destribeth'e'natlife and ti.rtumsta·nte~ of the treatmeht

Qr:a:ctiori,

~n my op'i,n(on,:a maj9r1W' of .th~ pet9 ine~? /1a'X~:experi~nced~ver~ ~9tfona' "91'" psy~holog i~ I
traurn,a ·Qqe lQ their inq3rt;~P:ltidn n'9~ unllk~ other inmates excep.1: dlJ.e:~~ the ~ul~u~l.pifferen~s
aJid Jack of but,~iQ¢ ¢ntaet this, t(auma is proba.blY more SE;vere,

o iI perS0naJly observed. thfs.conduct.
II >.observed·detaihe.e(s) ina ,cond ition that led me to believe that this' conduct had ~ccurred<.
-b.Co o
o 10etainee(s)
told me that this conduct had occurred.
...
a.

-.

..

"

OIGQ-005454

..

o IOthers who observed this conduct described It to me.

d.

0 I have relevant information classified above "SECRET".
f. 0 r never obsE1rv~d thi.s 'cooduc! nor heard about it from ·sam eone wh9 qic\.

e.

Other treatment of.a: tlei:dinee that in yq!Jf qpinipn' wa~:qJnprQn
cOercive/ abusive, or unlawful

'63.

0 r: personally observed this ;conduct.
b'. 0 Lobserved detainee(s) In a .cond jfion that led

ra~

me to believe that this conduct 'had occurred.

o IDetajnee(s) tOI.d me that t~isCOl1ducthaddq;:urrec!.•

C;:.

(t 0 Ot~ers who ;0~seryeq ~~is Gqn.ductdescri~ed !t to m€:,
e. 0 I haVe r~l~vcmt i.nforrn.a~iQn !;I<;l~slfied .above "$:EC'REf" i

t .0

I never"o.bsJ~rv~,d. this;GOndu~t.nor heqrd apout it frpm'··Mm ebne Whp- Qid·.

_-rtiti.'~~@@ _
0
•
.I.

.
•

l]

,64" bid. YQu '9!J~rve any imper.s~nation of FBI personnel QY pnY9ne.dudng:~n interview or int~rrog,atio'n of
'a"detainee?'

. .
0No

.0 Yes·

he or she had wi
'per'soh:nel iii connection with:a..detcHnee.·jntefV(ew or' jriterr.6:gatioh?

,65.. .old. any ·detairie:e: Q(QtherpersQn ,t¢1I 'You tbat

OY.es·

o No·

o Yes

'0'No

~66.. Ar~ Y9u aware of:anYC"sIH'lm" or Us~aged·.detaj.n~e:l!1t~rviews
of'th~ LJ.;S,; CQ('Igr~s.s 0.)" their staff?
.
.

67--•. To Y01,Jr kqo1Nledg~~.did <:loy milit<:lry pr J'1te!.Iige.J;l.ce. persot\Qel.eyer d~n.y p~ d.el~y 'FB.I '?lC:c~ss ~o<a­
~et;qlrtee ~he FBI wan1:\=d. to q!Je'stloh becau$e tl1e detainee had ,5\.1'$talned Inj!J rle'$ :after' he wa'? !=a'WJred?
OY~s.
.. .

.

~

~

.- ...

....

...

.-

~N9
..

~Wi;~:~t~l.i@_~h'
··o'~

~~~~"l

I]

1.

:~~

<: ....••...

..

::', . :..... :'...;-:'.

6lf. Did you .ev.erend your participation in or observation of ad etainee interview:or interrogation
• .beq~I,l~~.qf t~e inf~rvfew c;>r ihterrQggtiQIJ m~thod$ pefng u ~Jl?'

OIGQ-005455

.0 Yes

~ No

69, Were. y.oo ever lqlg that'f1m~th~r Ff~I :empl<;>v;ee ended hi~ ~:>r h.er p2i'rtk;lpatibri in dr' obs~rva.tibl1 o.f, a
.detainee interyiew'or inj:erro.gatiol) pe~use'Qf the. interview 01" interr.ogation .n'i¢tl)o.QS beirig us.~d.?'
O~ 0~'
'>",.

-

70'. Qu~jng any, 9fY9ur:oy~r$eps ·c!epIQyrne·nt? qr as.sig,nl1lent~. die! YO\J -r~portan.Y'.co.nce(ns r.egprding
any _detaJn~¢'In,ervlew 41" Int~rr~9'qtIPI1 p-f9:.C!lces, .01" pther tYR~ {:>f <;Iet;:finee. treqtm~t, tp' ~n FB.!
$up:~l.Vis9Y(

o Yes. 0· No.
71. During "any:of your ov:~rseas'qepl()Yrnentsor ~ss[gnmentsrdid Y9u

repor1; al)y,.con~er.l'!sregar.d~ng .
c;l.ny·~·e~ajn~ interview .or interro.ggtJo(l prpq:ice'J) or Q~her tYP!3' ofd~tC!in~:tr~a.tJT!en~ Y9U
Qb$.~rv..e9 i:?.f h~td a:bQut, tQ.~ ri.pn.-fa.l ~uR.~ryi~Qr pr gJh~r riqn-FB·I p.el'sp.npt=1( .

Q Ye~' 0 N.o
7Z. Have y.~u . ev.er been ordered or.directed not to report,or'discouraged Tn ,!nx-way from reporting,.
o.bservations or allegations related to detainee treatment or interview or interrogatiQn actions 'or
practic;~~f'
.." . ,. . . . . . . .
.
.
'.
'.
'.

o Yfts' '0· No'
7~. Haye 'yon .experiehcea 'a hy 'actlJ~1. or thfeateh¢d :r~t~ii'~:tIOil: for reporting ~bse-rV~(idi1s\or:all.eg~tloris
of.detaineelreatment or intel¥iewor in'terrClgationactions or pracfices1

0.1e51

.

.0 No

tP'

74~ (Qp.tlonal} P.f~9:se prov!de ~nY' ~d.dlt19lJal ~omrnent~ regarding t~e reporting 'of q;)ll<';ern,s. [e!at~'
i!Jt.~rv·iew 9.1' Iht.errl:i 99 t jql) t¢~J1nietL.Je~i· ~H~j:gn~ql) Pf:!il'C~rg~s,: Qf 9t.t'Jer :q~tajn~~ ~t.r;$?t.m~m,t;:
There were many.dISCUSsI0·nS..eton'ci~rliln9, aI>pro'aches and roles of organlzatlons.dlirihg botn
~9\:1r~ at GTMi:;l,
-

mx

FBI 'impersonation :.. I neard discussion that :7:60 .was fed to believe. he was dealing with my
~1·HJ~r\fisQr fo.lJow.in,g nw (Jep51.rt!Jre:.

~~ ... ~.~.~

.

',-'~

$".

~

,7:5. Were'vqll de~i;!ef6:d r 9t.her·~h?!1 the
~a~signn'f~ht.cS)

stemd~rQ de~rl~f in FD-i.12j: conc~rnlng you r qver§§tas
or,pep!pyme,n1;(s)' .i=lfter you completed, .the ,depIQyment(s.) Qi' a·ss,ignment(s).?·

o Yes'

..

<

.~

"

~

'

NO:.

76'.1l.dtlitional. Coniments·aifd RelidmmendatiQns,:

I was- a 150. involved in'a pro.g ram whiCh· is- classified' bYl the'orig inating agency, (not FBI), a~ TS, -and 'is
:~rth~r;GolTlpa'1mente4tc?
.!e~el·that tan I1Qt be disclq~d. in thi~;f9[f)1~t:

a

OIGQ-005456