Department 'of J~~tic,e In~p~cJ:or Gener-~I Que,sti.onnaire Re9.ar,ding ~etain,ee'S
D.OJ.-OI:G ,INVESTIGATIVE QUEsnO'NNAIRE
FOr{ R:EVIEWAND" USE ONLY B¥IND"IVIDUAL FBI RESP.ONOENTS
,,
DO NpT FPRWARD OR. DIS$EMI~ATE -

QUESTIONNAIRE 10: test-O.OOOl286

·As ·of ~he la,st,time this· qu~.ti·d.nnaire.w~s. sa~¢d, s~me require.d fields; hav~ n<?~ !:leen cQmpleted.
PJeas~·.r.ev!e)l\1·yourrespons$..

..

~,
iti.,,~
'....."
.,
~

A.

~

,

.

'

..

'

P~r~~njll'Infprm~tipn

Please provide the·folIQwin~ iJiformatio.n,

6 &.7C PERjU~REEN1ENT
'68. 'rCPERAGREEMENT

1. F-ir.st liam¢:

i .. f'4i~'Hle

In!tl~J:

3: Last name:.

,6 & 7.C PER, AGREEMENT
6 & 7C
~ & 7C
Spedp.l Ag.~nt

4•. Entered on D'uty· Date (EOD):
t~ur.r.eiJt DIvls.fo.nlField Office:
6.. GlttreQt j'pb title;

?:

;'/; Directdial office,.telephone number:
8• .FBI .c~f{ phone' nUril~et:
. 9.. fB): p,ager nutnb'er~
lO....Be~t contact oumber for you.::

6&.7CPER,AGREEMENT
~ &;,7(; PER.AGRJEEiVlENT-

'6~ 7CRERAGREEMENI
6 ~ lCPER.AtiREEMENT

B. B'ackground of specific D.e-ploymel'its Or Assig'nm'ents

11.. At-any time aft.eY;September He 20.01;, aid yeu, s$fVe'.as. a member Qf ttie U.S. Military, or as an
employee .or <::ontractor of the FBI-oT ·any other gpvemment agency", at Guantanamo Bay(, 'Cuba; Iraq;

.

Afg'~<;l!.1J.stcHT; 'orTn areas"q:)tltroll~ ,!Jy-tl!e 1),$: .M'ilitcjry ora U.. ~. In~~lIigen~e·~rN!~.e irrcqnn<;<,:tjon 'V{ith ·the:

.91.90·al Yl!i{r on .tetrt?l1
@·yes

0

No

1:2. !=nter the number :6f time,s you. w¢re,deplpyed o.r·c'is$i,g nea to,each of the f9.11oWing '19:caU,ons:
BaYr Cuba;, Iraq;,Afghanistan; .Or in 'any. areas controlled by the U$. Military:or a US.

.(G(jant~maino

intellig~ll~~ ser;tc~:) :1-

For~each: deployment

Location (selee.t' one~
.

f·...... ~~;

,'. .

_.~

;~rCl,q:

..

~

. '

.

or assi~.nritent .complete the fbllowil'!~ sectiol"!..
D~ill.o)1i1_ept ~r ll.s~!i'j'nrr!illlt~eQim pi(9 r
allou.t
.

,

07/15J20Q4

_

Dep.I~~.e!lt·orcis5i!iril!le'irt e:n.pe~ on.

.Or.ll~O\lt

10/15/20.04

i;?a. W'~~t W8$ Hie :gen,er.a'inatur~ ?hp l?lJrp'q~e. Qf your assigri.m~D't ~'hda!:tivities?
FBI representative In the' HO,stage fusion-Cell.of a u.s, military unit.
12b. Please provide·the names of the..spedfic.camps, basesj or' facilities where you·worked.
The· specific: facilities were classified.
i2~~ NQi~: xi- i~fprm~iipn:'abdut ~:srie.tifi.c·caniP, base,. orfadiitY IS da~~'jffe~ :ab:CI.Ve sEe~E1,
plea$e ch:eck.her~ 0, in~lude in your;answer that you hav.e.-lIaddi~iqnal·ihformatiol)tlp~s.lfiepaQove .
'SECRET"" and, if you know, identify'the,c1assificatlon lev.el, titket,.comparfrhent, programJ .orilther
designation th.at-applles l<?' trye,{nforrnatr~:m, Do not Include th:eaddJtlonar. classified Inf9rl11atf9n In your

OIGQ-005457

questionnaire re:sponse~.
Name

L---_,__, '__ ~ '

I.

_

,

...

.....

-.-

__

,

._

••

: Witl1 what kind?

: D,ttrF

_- _ _-

'

0

._

........

necessary cle,arance will qmtact .yOll to re'cejve it.

Position

,

0

Yes
'W'

_

....

b6

.::~uy~~~~orr §~~!aJt\9~n_t

det~iri~e with' nor:i-F~I

.Did YQ,I,J Jointly in.tervi,ewor int¢rr<;>gate any

~12~.
;""'-

ble personnel with .the

-.

N~

...

..

•

_ _ - ....

;:

,

per$9fll.1el?
_

...

_

.... _ _

~

.....

b7C

-

__

..

-.

..... _ _

....

..... _

... - '

of !lon:-FBI Personnel d.i9 you work joint!y?'
.

:: 0' 'Qther U.S. Military
,: 0 :U,.:s. il1teIligetl!=~ i:!g,~licy

:n foreign military or lntelllfience a'gehcy.
: 0 other

.

:.

-

-

- --

-

-

-

-

~ - -- - - - -- - - - --- " - - ,.. - - - - - .. - - -- ~ - - - - - - -. - - -, - - - - - - - - - -- --- - --.- :~i2i D1d-yoli"jointi" pian-a'fiy.'d~ln~'int~ruieW" eDr~i~t~rrogatlon-strategy; objecti~e;;:-or tactiCs-wft~ n~n--:'

':F~I p'~rsoJlnel?
•

• ..:.

-

-

-

-

__

-

_

......

'
_ _ • _ _ . _ ._ _ •

w

~

_ _ . _ .....

0'Yes
~

~

__

....

ONo
•

'_,..

_

1.0 """'- ...

,..

)

::
- - - ..... -

- . _ . _ _ "'"'l_ - ' -

::
~'-'')o.

" With what kinds of. noh-FBI personnel did 'you ,workjointly?

.:

:DCITF

>:

:: 0' Other U.S. Military
.: 0 -u.S" intelf!gen!=l;:' agency
: 0 Foreig'nmilit~lY' Qr Intelligenc~

'

"
~:
i?,genc;;y

: D\o~h~i

".:

!

.,

::.:: : :'.:: :..::.:::::.::: :::.: =.:::::::: ::.::::::.::: ::.::: :.:::::.: :.: :,: :.:: :.-::::::::.: :!;

.12g. Wer~yol) ~\ier otherwise Involved In detalnee:lntervlew$'orlnterrogatlons with ntm~fBI person'nel? .'
~
.:. __ ,_ ~'
,
,~
,
9_~e3_,_,__.,-~_":!.o_,
~
,~
, ,_ ... _':,

~. Trainin,g Pripr toqv~r~eas OeplQymentor .A~sJgnment

13'. Did you r~~eiv,e any traiFiil)!i, in:sttuctio'o c 6r;gliidarice speCificallY in.prepatatip,n fOr'
'oyerseasdeployme'hts or assignments?
.
.

~iri'i.6fY6Lir

,<!>Yes
bNo
'ODD Not Recall
13a. Who prOVided this tralnln.g, Instruction! or:9.uldanc~I,and where did you receive It?
FBI CIRG,r FBIOGe
13b. beser/lie :th~ subject: btl whlch'you n:;~e1ved' this training, instruction or guidante'.
CIRG pfov,iE1ed,a,.numper of classes p,(Iqr 't9: th~'d~ployment; Inaddit.f<;mr. p~rsoDnel
frQi'n our ~ivision' prQv~ded i'lUmer9US CI~is.seSi gUidance, cine! :inst.t!-!!=tiQO, ,f.Ul1henilcir.e)' ,
fBI O.Gc.disseminated :aii EC {Ref.6:6F-H~;-A125.8990atd May 19th,. 2.005),0.0 fBI p,6licf
on' inferro:gatiol1/i1iterv.iews; ,
'
..

OIGQ-005458

eVes
ONo
000 Not Recall
14a, Who provided this training, Instructionj',or'guidance"and where did you receive It?
FBl Academ.y 'and FBI HeadquarterS'
14Q. hriefly'describe ,th~ ~liP,stance 9f.lhe ,trainil1g, ins.J:rlJetion r br guJdance p:rovkled to· yo!.!.
FB i Acapen:tY, in~tructi9n ,on ethics, th~ U .,S. Constitu:tioo, etc;; In, apd itidfJ, fBIH QSent'
:O~l!t a :detailed e-mail IisWig.q:>nqlJctap.plrq.lbl~. p'riot to',deplqYnient.
14c, Was ~I}Y Of the' training, 'in~tlJ.letibn~ or .gUidance provid~ in' wri~ing?
0Yes

ONo

0

0,0 Not Retail

:~Y~
O N o . 9 0 b No~'Recall
t~a. Who p.ro\ilg~ 'this ~~inrng, Instrqctlon, qf glJld~nc~j anq wh~re dlg'yol:! rel:;eIV~ It?
u.s. Military Personnel at the.. base in which we'were stationed.
15b. Briefly-describe the sutistanGe of tli.e .training, inStruction,. or gUida'nee provided to,Vou.
MliitarY Commanders in the 'fa~Uity prQYid~d tri;iJnli1g an.d gui,danG¢ .tnt:: hanpl1® ;bf
'
,
d,eta Inee irit~rvie.Ws/lritertb.~Jatlbns,
15<;. Was;any pi the:tralnlng., InstrpctlQn, br guidar:l'c~ 'prQyrdB9 .In'wrl~lng?
'@Yes
'ON6 0 Do: Not Recall
'

on

16:.

rn p,~el?arat.ibn' for anY'9f v.qur :ove'r;Seas' d~pJdYI\1~~.S:o.r .as~rgnme:n~, tifd you re<;:eive:.any ~rainirjg,

inst:'rllct!on,.ar:guida[i'ce ,concerning what y'ou were supposed .to; do if you obser'vea ,0'1' heard :aboLit
tlie treatment/interVieW;,
ihtefrogatioiibf detainees by FBI' personnel,. which' yo'u .belleved
t,l~ i'1approp'riat~; unprofessional, coercivej:CiPusive, 'or unlawful?'
'

or

to

17. In preparation for an,Y",6fy6tir overs~as: deploY.ments of assignments,.did ybu'i:eceive,any traihirig,
irstructi«?n/,or,guidance c.oncerning what -you were::supposed' to: do if you 'obsel¥ed 'or heard about .
1h.e'1:~C(ltrn~nt, interv!~Wr or fnterrQgi3tl'9n qtdet?i!1~~ QY n(jn;.FBI- p~r:~ol'!n~lrWl1tch .yoJl Qel,l~Y~9
to 'b~ inap.pr9prla.t~,vnp.rQfes~fQria'~cjJerd.ve~;cibusiv~~ pr Udlawfur?

0No·
\6:' Train'ing DtJ.ririg ·,Overseas. De'pJoYrnent~ -or Ass~gi1ments'
. tit O~rin£l.'i:::iny9fy()ur p'ver~e~s,d~p'qYli1~f1tsp t ~~si.Qnmetit$~~f.iQ Y.P..4 re~~ivt~

I

Cln.v't@.ining; jnstt!-!~tidl.",
the.standards Qf .conduct :appli~~:j'bl~ t6 the treatment, inter:vfew;,or
ihterrogiftion of detaih:ee'~ by FB.I .Personnel?
'
,-

br,gulda'hCe;.c6n~r.nilJ~

, :0Yes

'ONi:>

:000 Ndt Recall

-l8a, Wh(;)' provided this training,. instruction,. or-guidance?
, FBI perso.l1Oel 'located in I(aq to. ind~d~ the 'Q'r( .Scene; 'Co'rTlI1'iahder and his oeputv.
fab Bri~'y-,c;1.estri.b~ the S,u b::st,an<;:e; ofthe .t.raJn ing, .i n~trugion, Qr g,tJlpante: p'roYid~d' ro YQU;
1

5.~y~~1 ~i$QI:!~sfons wi't}l fB'~ leaper~hip in (racrOD th~'proR~r ~r~atme(1t -pf det?in~e?
While FBJ per:so!ipe[ were 'C9llPuctlng :lnteT1'I~y.J~;
~8'c, Was',911Y .of'the trail1ing, Instruc:::tionL or g~ldaf)ce proyfq!=£! ',n:wrlting?

OIGQ-005459

Dves

¢

ONo

Do'Not RecalJ

19. During any, of your overseas ,deployments or asstg timents r did you receive any·tralning, lilstruCtion,
or guidance:concerning the standards Of'conduct applicable to the treatment! interview, or
lnterrogatlqn 'of det.aln,ees by !lon-FBI perso~nel?'
".

PDt> Not Recall

'$Ves,ONo
.l.~a; Whp provic;leq thIs ~J13inrngr !1]!>tru.ctiQn/·qr 'g(Jid;~mce'?

U.S. military personnel.
19\}. Brl.efIy.dJ~sCrlbe the sUbstante.6fthe training! fnStructlon,. Qr,~uidance. provided
you.
Trp'inirig otr the. tr$.tm~np;jf p'rlsoll~r.s:ali,d gL!ipah~e;on ir'Jtervi~wi~ng and ·int~tr:99q.tign,
190. Was-any of the'.tr~lning, instrLlc;ti.olJ, or glJldi:mc;e Rrovided ,in'writing.?
.
@y~S QNo,
Do Not Recall

to.

0

, '2b. Du rJng ~ny of Y~\J r o:yer~ea~· d~p[oyments. c.r i;ls,s,!9 [lm~nts', d i,d yOl,J -re,te.ive, any tr:aini,m', ·irl.S!:ruetiQJ:T,
Qr gui(f~nc~"cpnC,E~'rriing what Y,ou w~r:e sup·p,Osed.tq ~p if yo.u QQ~rvep or h~ard ,i'lQQ!J~the,
treatment" Intervlew~ Iritettogatl6'n' QfddaJri~es by' FBI pets:onnel, whlch you. b~II,eYed to be·

-or

inappropriate,.unprofessional,, cOerCive,. aliusfve,1

'Of

unl~wful?'

,

J!)Do 'Not· Recall

:OYes,

2"1. During pny 6:f'yoLlr'b.ver~as a~pJoVme'nts or a.:;signm,ents:, Aid YOU' r~c~.iv.~ c)ny. training., insl;rudiQrJ,
or·guldance.cohcerhlhg what '{ou' were· sUpposed 'to do if ~ou ,ob'ser:vel:l or heard abouHhe'
treatment, iflterview(, or intermgation of detainees by non-FBI personnel,. which you believed to
g~ 'in~PP~op'ri,at~J !-r.np(qfe~~r9n.~(,.q<;rerciV,er g,b)J~~ve, Or'l-!nI9.wfl,lJ?
.

Ie•. Ad'eq u'scy :of Training
;2'2. In :y;ur bpinli>'r\,
YbQ rec~iY.e acleqtl'Qte tr~inin9, i~sttuctiori~ 6r,gl1id~nce ~erating to' sta:nda'rds"
.of cb'ndUCt by ·FBI -ana bon-FBI 'personnel relating to 'treatment, :iritervfeW,. 'Of fhterr'ogatlon ,of
.
·d~tail)ees. prior to yOl,.Ir:qep.l9.yrnel}t'Qf <;lssignment[

:a'id"

(!)'Yes

0

No

1:~.JI1 ygur 9pini.op, dic!, YQ!J r~p~Jve apequate tra:i.l1ingf ifl?trl:Jet.iqn',·9rgy~r;!C1l}ce fel.~tin.g t9 stg:nde;trds.

,

'of torjduet; .l:>.y.FBBilid npn.,FeI per.$.pnnel rel,atlng to'tre.a~m~nt, 'Interview, or Ir)terrog~tlqn::of
'dJ~~taitiees',durifig your- deployinebt:or:assignmerit?' "
.

·""nat

'24.·1n y,6iwopinion, 'did you receive ,adeqUate tra'iriihg, inStru6tlohr :Of,guiClanGe concerning
you
wer:e sq pposed 'to ·do if you ~bserv~d or h~rd flhout. the treab:nel'!t~ interview, 'Or lnterrogati()n .of
·d.e~a.ifle'esi Q'l H\Iqf non":F~l p'ef?Ormel, '~h~t Y9u f;l:e,l!eyed ~e;tS il")appropriaJe~ ynprofes~f9nal,
cQ~rCiv~, .:abusi\i~, qr !.mtawful?
.

'0 Yes

0

No

OIGQ-005460

25. (Optional) :tn what .ways ~n the' FBI improv.e training
~~signm~nt's7

I_D_,_c_o_rn_m_e_n_t_s_,

.

on this subject for future:depJoym'el1ts'or

--,

.

.

---,-

1

z'~, please provide any add'iti(~mal inform9~io.n 'con<;ernll1g' tra,ining fqr 9versea'S 'peplgymerits:qr

p:,Ssfg nm~n~ of F~I p~rspnnel

yO,u

b~lreve i~ re.l~v~nt.

Tffi'lning for R9~atjqn 9. of ~he 111l.q D-eplp'Ym¢nt wa'!? adequat~, Tlie,;pnly' a:dd,itiQnaJ ;t.r~lning (eq'uj'r~rti~.nt
m'ay be to, .Instr(rct F,Bl'perstmnel,on exact proced ures t6 r.eiJort a perceived 'InapprQprrate~ abu'slve" ao.d
. '
unlawful event by U.S. personnel.

Introduction 10 Part III: In this:section, .we:are:seeking information regardinR awide range of

in.tervl.ew VI' interrQgatrc;Jn. te~h.nig~!,!s arid ;otrer ty.pes or:geJ;ainee ·,tr~a~rT;I~r;it C!lle.9~ W have .0cG\.j rr~.
YOI,l ~ho!Jld ·nQt~a.s,suli)e, JL!sl: ~$u§.~ we:a,r.¢~as·liih!:!. c1I:lQl,lt?i ,paf,t~.l=f.J.lar tecbri;qu.e:br prpctl~, ,tt:r~t W~ ha~e'
:c9n91ud¢!:!: theft it. in fact oCGurre'd> Werf;!co9.hize th.~t some of th~$.e "t~i:hI)iqt1.~J5 ,oJpra:mices: \TIW'<;lt~ime.s
be. l)ee~sS:ary. for safety and seed FltY, In a '(fetentlon set.trng" In..a'dcfitl0 t)r .we .reeogrilZe thatjsOn:i~ of" ttiese
techniGJues :01'- pr-actices' may, have been authorized for use by military'or other' g,o~emment personnel~
Witti (~~P':eq; tQ: ¢~th 'ig~.ntifieQ t¢~hi\iqu'~! prag:tc~.rrQr":1~Yii¢ pf:tp.nQ\.!~,t-q~~:rlb~ Qerqw,. w.e 'a(~ ,s.ee'l~ing.
ili'fQiTTiatiQrl ,about it'S- p,~cutreflce during or 'inc.Qlinecti6n With' the i rit~ryiew. or Jnterr.ogation of .a'
detainee{ .<>f during' the d~tentio'n,of'a aetai nee beyond w,hat is: needed for safety. all'd security.
{Ii ~J1a~:<;o''!te~~j wl{< ~.ill ~sJ< Y0\:l'tl? t~!1 u,? ~h~t~er 'qI)~ W" ~or~ ?f·~~e:'f?lIqVl!I.ng 'S!?t~m~flts are true:~
1,. 1. p~rS;9nal!y'ob~el"'Ze~ tlji~:t.q/1{.1u~tr
,
·Z.· I o.Qserv~ .~etaln~(s) In: a .c<mdJtI9.n ifici:t l¢d me:'to-belieV~ that >thl~..tblJdt!et bad pC;currep.•

3',. Det'ciihe'e(s) told me 'that this condLiCf.. Md -Oceurred.

'". O~,bers who ob,sel:Ved thl?:conduct d~ql~ed·I~,'~£l·..':ne.,
.5.. r Iiay~ [ef~vant informatIon c1qs.~if!!=!d a"lmv.e: "$~€;RET~,
..
6.. rne.v¢p·9DS,g,rv.¢rt thi,S. cpn<!!-JGt I1Qr h'eard,:~l;lol!~jt from ~prheQne,*hQJjia.

27... Depriving :8 ·detainee' of ~ood 'or water
a.

0 r p'er~nally o.bserve~. tli'is i;;on~uci,

b; D !r9b,s,~rved~cfetainee{s). in a:cond iti.on that,l~ me to' b~lieye tha:,fthis eonp,l,ltt ha:d oq:,urr~d;
c.

0

be.taine~(s) toll1 me that thj~ q}nd.l;I~~ ha~ 'O¢curr:~,

e. 0 r have re,le'lant information' C1a'S:Sifj~d above' "S,ECRETn•

OIGQ-005461

28. Depriving a detainee Of.clothing
·a~

b,
C;.

<;I~
~.

D I personally observed this .conduct.
D lr.:observed detainee(s) In a ,condition that led me to believe that this conduct had ·occurred.
D D'~tainee(s) told 'me that this' cenduct had ·oc::curred.
D IOthers who observ~ this c0ndu<:~t'desGri.~eQ i~ to !TIe..
D 1. ha'Ve.relev~mt information classifle.d <;lQ'9v~ "SE¢RIT'-.

T. 0

I ~ever opservep thfs'copduct nor'hecml apol,lt it from sqmeqne who did.

·a. D r personally observed this .conduct.
b.

c.

-

d~

d.
d

I observed detainee'(s) in a condition that led me to believe thaUhis conduct had occurred'.
Detalnee(s) told me that this conduct had ·o.ccurraL

[]10ttrel;> who o,bserved this con:duct des~rjbed

jt to. m~ ..

D. t ~pve,releY<mt tQf9rm;::l~iol') c.la'!?silt~(t Cjboye ·~·$EtRET'f .
t 0.I never'observed this coridli.lct.nor h-eard .about-It-from someone:w.ho did.

e.

0,

I

• • • /~.

.'

<

,,"

•

•

.'"

._

' .

.,

•

•

..'

:. •

.'

.~"'

.:

s.o. Beating a. detainee
a.

C!

l' persPnally observed this.conduct. ,

·b'. [j II.observed detaihee(s) in a;coridit}on that led me fo. believe that 'this coha.i.fet: had ,ocCUrred,

c-

.D iDetainee(s) told

d:

0

I

me that this conduct had .occurred.

Ot.hers' who observed this rond uct- d~scribed [t~.o me..

relevarit
classified
above
:e.· D r.hav.e
,
. ..... information
"
. '.
,.
. "SECREt''',
.
f. 0' r. n~y~r :op~rv~g thfs '~QI1i:JlJq~':r9f .~ear~ :abput it. .from $9.r:n~on~ Who gi9· ..

,31. U$1rig

~ateJ' Jd prev~ril bt.eathing bY-a .d~ta!rie¢. or ~b,'tr:eatet.h~ ~~o.saiioiTqf drowning

a. D r persOnal!y observed this,condUct.
b.
c,
d.

D
D
D

I observed detainee(s;) in a:.condition that led me to belie1e thaUhis cOnduct had .occurred.
!Detainee(s) told me that this cenduct had occurred.
others. who observed this conduct described it to me.

OIGQ-005462

e.

0

f.

IiI I never observed this;conduct nor heard about it from someone who did.

I have relevant Information classIfied :above' ·'SECRET".

j'2., Using hands, r<me/·or.anything 'else to.choke Of strangJ~ a d~tainee

0

I p~rscinally (jb~lVed this.conduct.

Qthers: wbo obserited this conduct described it to me.

e,

D
0

f,

~, I never'observed thls:conduet nor heard about It from someone-who did.

a.
b.

c;
d.

o Iooserved detainee(s). in ac6.nditio.r') th'at led me tb· believe thatlhis conduct. had o.c.curred.'
o 'Oetainee(s}told me that ttlis,cond'utt had ,occUrred.
L have relevan't informatfon dassffied a'bove' "SECRET" ,

:.3"3. Threatening Qther aC):iem to qlUS~' p.hy,s(cq.l pain" (njury, disfigJjrernent; or'd~ath

c;

0
0
0

d.

o IOthers'who obser.'ved-tliis cGiiduct'oesGribed it tb me"

e.

D

f:

I~r I never observed this,.conduct nor heard about-it from'someone,who did.

a',
b.

I persPJiaJIy'observet1 ibis,conduct.
I"observed:detaine~(s) ill a <;ondition that led

me to belieVe that this. conduCt had,o~c(jfreCl.

petal,nee.(s) told me that this cdnd'utt had :6,ccurred.
I have rele~ant infofmation arassified a'bove '~SECRET".

'-34. -.qth,ertrea~ment or act,itm ca.u~ing significant p"lY,~icai p.ain
-.,dea,th

I

or jl)j~rY" or l;:ausing disfigJ1~ern.E;lnt or

D II personally-obserVed this ;cb ndi,g:t.
D'. 0' I;observed detainee{s} in 'a.coild itiofHhat led me to believe thaUhis dmduct had ,occurred. I
D loetainee(s) tala hie that this Gondutt h'a'd .occurred.
d. D o.thers who 'ob'serv:ed this conduct described it to me:
-e,., 0 I, ~av~ re1eV:cm't !nforrn-?tti9tl ~!~s?i.tI~c! a,bove "'5.EGB-Sf''';

'a.

€~

nor heard-. alJout-lt
who did.
t. 0 I never'obseroed
.
, . thlsmnduct
'
:"..
-.-" 'from someone
- -. ....-".
~

~

;

'.

~"

OIGQ-005463

35. Placing

e'. D I
b.
c;:.
d1
.e,

o

a detal./iee on a hot ,suJf<jce or burnin

-

personally observed this"conduct.

ILubserved detainee(s) in a condition that led me to believe that thIs conduct had occurred ..

I

D Detainee(s) told me that this'conduGt had 'occu rred .
D !o.t~ers v.,flo o~ser:vet! ~Qis c.o,nduct descri bed it to me..

o l~. have relevant- information classified at;>'ove "S.'ECRET" (

1': 01r nev~rop~rve.d thfs'cQnpm;:t.!lQr heard 8pout it frqm sqrneof)e who did.

36....lJ$i~g ;$hackle.s:qr ~~her' re!?traintsJii ~. prqlqo
8'.

b.
'c,
d.
e,

1

0
0
0
0
0

persenally'observed this .conduct.

I observed detafnee(s) in'a cond ition that led me to believe that this Gonduct had occurred.
Oetalnee(s) told me that this. conduct had :occu rred. '
Qt~'ers' who observed ~h~ c~)fJduGt'd'escribed jt. to. m~ ..

--------

I have r~le.vcrrit i.Qj9rmi3tiqn c.fassifi~ .ab.·0ve '~$ECRET\

o it nev~r'Q,b~~rve'p

t!iI~.'C<?nc1lJ~t.r9.r: h~n:l:

I

did.

3.1. Requirh:iQ.:a :d¢ta)nre;to'mainta'i!'1,. Qr re.straln ing a detainee in, a s.tre'ss.fu i :~t 'painful Po:s'itiQI1
a. 0 r persOnally' observed thls,conduct.
b. D'- i~;obserVed detalhee(s) ina:conoltion 'tha't led
·c.

d.

m~H"6.

lielieve that thiS", cZond.u'.ct had .od:ikred.

o 10etainee(s) told me thatthis conduct had occurred.
o lathers' v.,ho o.~$erlle9 .this cQ.ndPl;:t des~rl qed It to m~.,

Mil ~av,e ,relevant i[lform~tfon.dasslfie.~ .ab.ove "SECREt'''.
f; 0 J, n.ever·Q.b?erved thrs·G9nd\.l~t npf .h~r4.

'e,.

Ple'as~ proVide .fh~· app.rpxirr'ia~ time ftq.ni~.dudng Which thiS torr(lupt
Frorri"'(M/DjYYVY format or t->1/yyyy) to :(M/D jYYYY.' format .or M/YYYY)

g.

;

qid.

QC'PJrred.

gO.o Not Recall

.h. 'T~e :!ie.tainE?~(~) tr¢at¢4 'in 'this way w.¢r¢: Ipc"q't~ ,qt the tjm~ i,n:

10 GuantanClmo.
2 Rf Iraq
3'DAfghanistan'
Other t.oeation
..
.. .

40

..

.

.

".

m

..

.

...

.. .

--

...

.
OIGQ-005464

50 Do Not Re.<;all

t. ple,ase identify the detainee(s) by name and number:
Do npt re~II.'

.

J. 'p.leas,e identify the' pe'rsotl(sYWho tr'.eatetl the detainee(s). jn this manner,

including their

name(s) and governmentagency(ies)':
D9P personne.l. Dqnot recall n~mes.

k. Please il:Ientify any,other FBI personnel or non-FBI personnel who obserued detainee,(s) treated
j'o th:i~ rnal1nefr ' ili~Judl0g thefr m;lIn~($) 'gnd qg~ncy(~s):
.
RoJa.tipn 9 Agents

in ,connection with:
'One tletainee
2,0 Several detainees (2-4,)

.1. This.con.dod .occurred

,.t 0
B.

0

Many detainees frl)ore: than

40 1;>0 Not Recall

4}

m. (Optional) Please describe- the relevant circumstance& in more~detail:

a'. 0 r personalfy observed this conduct.
h. q r observed,deta'inee'(s) ina'coriditioh that lea "me to· believe that ttiis G:onduct
c: 0 Detalnee(s):tdld me that this' conduct had :O'ccurred.

0

Others who observed this conduct descrfbed it to me.

e~

o if, ~ave re'l~varit inrorm?tion dassi(i~d abov~ "SECR!=T"'.

t:

0

L never o~serv~~ t,hi.~ "cQJ:1puct -nor:heard qb.ou~.lt from:sor:neonewho did:

d.

had "occu'rred·.

g. ~le9's~ p'rdvid¢ .,h~ qp'prp~irh'a~~ tjrh~ :rrallieqQrhig W&i<ih .thJ$: ~QI.i([l:fct g~l;::Urr~:t
From ;(M/DtfYYY format bt MjYYYY) to (M/P/Y¥YY foci-'mat or. MtfYYY)
l~bo Not. Recall
. h.. The ~etahl~e($) treqte<l '10 ~his way w.ere: lq:c~te9 :at th,~ tim-e tn:
, ~ 0 Gu~n~an~n:tq

2,0'lraq'
3 D .Afghahist~m

.if 0 Other L~Gatiotl
5 0 Do. ~ot Recall
I. F.lease-:rd~i1tlfy:the··,aetalnee(s)
Do not- recall. '

by name arid. number:
,

OIGQ-005465

j. Please identify the person(s) who treated the detainee(s) in this manner, including their
name(s)' and gover"nment ag,encoy.(ies).:
.
DoD personnel. Do no~ recall nam~.

k. Please id'entify'any'other F8I personnel'or han-FBI personnel wlio observed detainee(s) treated
in this, man,nef, Including tnelr namt;!(s) anp a,gency(ies);
Rbtati6'il 9 p~rsohnel"

I. This'.conduct.occurred in connection with~

1 () One detainee
~:o Several det~inees (2-4)

~ 0 Many getalne~s (mor~ than 4)

40 Po

Not Recall

'

':39, lI.slng .el~ctrl~' shoCk ',o,n,a $l.etalnee

0, I p'ersonally observed' this.conduct.
o iI, o!?s~J've,c! det,a'(nt;!e(s) I,n ,a'cot)d ItiOf) t~c;lt Ied. .me, .....to believe
. ..
.' that'thls
... , .. ' , . c0.nduct
'.
. . had 'occurred.
.
.' .
c; o IDetain,el';(~) tqlp !Jl~ ~h<;lt thiS,'cond,uq. bpd q.cco rret! "
d, 0 Oth~rs who' observ~ thi~ c.o.l1dud des!=ribe~ it to me;
t¥! 0 ( Ija,\,¢ rele'.lCint l.nform:~~,iotf ~lassjfl~d 'ab9ye
f. 0' r never 9bs~rved ~hls,q;m.duct nor' hear.d;ab DUl. it from Sdmeon,,:I',vihQ -cJ'id.
a~

b,

".

40. thre<;ltening to .useel~ctric~Hsh9¢kon

,~

a C1~tain ee, '

0 I personalty. observed this..conduct.
lh 0, (ol;l,sery.e(h:J.etaIn,~~{$lin ,a: <;:9,l1d itlon t~?t I
'~"
0 Detal[le~(s) told m~ that t!lls c0nduc~ h,ad '0
'0
others who 'ob~rvec! ,this cpnduct Qescribe:
C!.
e. ,0 I haye,reievarit: inrqrm;3tion c1assifiep a90ve "S,ECRET"'.
a~

f.

0 r n~'iler,obs~rve~ thii 'c9nr;IuC,t nor hear.d ~b out It from'so.meqrie whp did.

,41. Interitii::mally' del?lyjn,g 'or denying det9ine~:med

OIGQ-005466

..

,

0 I personally observed this conduct.
I
b. 0 I observeddetainee(s) in a"condition that led me to believe that this conduct had occurred.
c. 0 'D~ta!nee(s) told me that thiscondl}ct baq 9c;P;lITeQ.
d. 0 Oth~~ who ob'served this cond1Jd,des~Jlbed It to me:
e., 0 I hc:~~ relevant i~~!?rma!ion daSSifie9}b'~e:":SEC,~J_'.
__
----f. 0' rnev~ro.bseryedthis,tqnduct nc>r h~rd'aQP4t it from someone'who did.

'a;

"

42:. Hooping or blindfolding a ,detainee-other than during 'trah~portatlon

b.

0 I, personally ,observed this, conduct.
0 I 'observed 'detalnee(s) Ina c0nd ltlon that led me to

€.

o jDeta\nee(s'j. tQld me tDat this, conduct hpd '(jccurred.~

a~

belle:ve that this conduct had ,occurred.

d.: 0 9t l}erp Wr9 'op~e~c! t,hfs ,cQnd,u~t cr~!?cr,!bed jt ~9 IDe.,
e. 0' I h~ve,releva'rit InformC!tIQ,n,,~la?,~Jfi~ Cjbove "SECRET't.
t 0 I neverQb.p,erv~.cl this/c;oneM;t Mf l1~r~,qb90t it frorn:SOrne9rt~'whodid.
,~. p'fease; prOVide the apprQ~lmat~ tlme,Tta:r:ne,:dl;lrlng, yvnlcl) this, c;~ntfu~t occ;urred.

,(MfD'/YYYY format or M/YYYY) to :(M/D{YY'ff format or M/YY¥Y)
h. Toe 'det,airf!=~'(s) tr:t$ted in 'tnis W,ay were, IQcat~ 'ciJ th~ j:iiTl'e 'iir:
i 0 'G'uantan?lr11QFrom

0D'o Not R.ecall

20 Iraq
3D Afghcfnlstan
4- 0 !Other Location
~d

Do N9t Recall

i. PJease,identify,the:detainee(s}
Q9 not recaH·

by narTie and number:

,j. Plea se i,d entif'l thE;! pel:po:ri (s)'whd t f:ea~e~ th~ detai l'ie~r~) in this, rnaDner~ ir'i<;l uding their
mn'ne(s) 'and ,go.vernment agehcy:(les}:
D,o[) personnel.
"

~. Please id.entif.y' aliY other FBI. petsonnel br non-FBI personnel Who -ob'seM'd aetalnee(s) treated
!n this manner, including their name(s) and 'q9~ncy(ies)~
,
Rotation, 9 per;s6hn~J.

" This, conduct ol:c!Jrr~d
1 0 One, CI etaIne,e
2
3

a

in ~bnneetlO:ri wIth:'

Se\f~t.al detairi~es (4-4)

0 Many detainees (rrior~ than 4)

OIGQ-005467

-

4,0 Do Not Re,q31l

lTi· (pptfol1a.J) Please describe'the releva.nt c;:Ir:C;lJmstances fn more 'detail:'

43. subrecting a'detaine¢ to,extremeiy cbid or hdtrdom temperatures forex.lerided petioils

a. 0 I. pel'50naHy, observed this 'conduct.
b. [j Lobserved'detainee(s) ina condition that led me to believe that this ~onduct had occurred.
~.

d.
'e.
f.

D 'Detaipee(s) told m~ that this, condl,lcth 9,d :o~curr!=l:L
O· qtbers WhQ opserved this. conduct d~criqed itl9 JTle.
0 r hcW~ re~va'nt ilJformatign dC!ssjfi.e~ i=11?t>ve, "SECRI;T'! ~
0 r. nf=Yer'o_b~erved this· <;onQuct npf .h~rd :abqut it ,from·,SOlTje9.ne '¥po r:Jid..

·44, $Ubjec.tin'g' Fl.de~~ine;e'to

tQ.u,d mLi~i~

_-_ _-_._

a.
perSonally observed this conduct.
0 I,.-----....
.. -----_._- ..
.....
__n ...

b.

D

_._-

~

..-, ...--~--~..

_._-- ..-_ -- -..---_.--._
...

....

-..... --'--"--

I-observed detainee(s) in a cond ition that led me to, believe that-this conduct had occurred.

c. [j petalnee(s.) told me thaUhis conduct had occurred.

r:J. 0 O~f1ers wh,Q obserye.d this cC!!'.Iduq:gesqjbeil It {p' rfI~,
e; 0 I. hi?ve re~ya,nt i.(lforma~fon ~la~.~ifie9 ,~I;>'9ve' "~.ECREJ'\
f.

0

,

I never'observed th;s,COilduGt'nor'heard'ab'out it'from'.some·one-who· dld.
o

'

';.

•

•

",_

~

•

••••

'

,

•• ~

~

~

>

~

•

.,

".

•

•• ~ . ' .

,'.

•

•

,

,

-go' Pleas~ jjroyide, .the Qppni)xim:at~ lime rrame during

which lhis cqndu~t Qcturrep.

From (M1D'/YYYY furmat.or M/YYYY-) to .(M/.D/YYYY fot'mat .or M/YYYY)

mao Not.Recall'

:h. roe ~<fetaim;e(~).t(~~eg .in this way were'Ip:,C!~e~ C!t th~ time tn:
J, 0 (;Uantal19rrl,O

2 Rf,Iraq
.3

D ,Afghanistan

-4 0 'Other Location
50 Do ~ot Rec;:all
i.-:Please identify the detainee(s) byname arid JiUmber~
Dcr ,neit recaJt.

j, pj!=!ase I~en~jfy tbe p!:!rson($) who .treqte'd' th~ p~.t.ainE;e(s) in tl1~ rtIann'e1~, including th'eir

name(s) .andgo.vernmerit 'agehcY(ies):

'

OIGQ-005468
"

DoD. Do. not r€4l11 names.

k. PI~ase identify ariy:dttf~r FBI per$onn'el ~r non-FBI personnel who ob,served d'¢tain~e(s) treated
in ,this, manner, Illchiding th'elr nanie(s) and a'gericy(l~S)~
Rotation 9 p~rsonn~I.·
'..,

I.. Th.i~qmductqcC\meq
,1

9

i!l con-"~~ion with:,

On~ detah::te~

2 ~ :SeV,era" detainees (2-"4)
3 0 Many d,eta,inees ,(m'ore: ttii:'ln 4)'t 0 Do, Not Recall
'
111. <O'PJJon'al)

Please; d~rl be. the :r~i.ey~ ht ?:itqirfistances' in more'detall:

·,45. S,ubjeding

a ,detainee to bright flashing

lights or da[kness

0 I persqn~lIy,'observed thIs 'cqnduct.
b, 0 i' ob,$~rved detain'e~(s) in ',8 :condftjon that, i~, In¢' to beli.eve th~t thi.s contl,uct had :oc;qurred,
t: 0 lDe.t~ine~-(s)tj)ld m~ d'l~t :thiin::~i'!idlJtt. hgq Qt~llrre9.
}d,ID Others Wh'O 'p~servS!,d :thiS; G,Qi1d,Utt de~cribeQ it tP: ni~.
9,:'

e. 10
f.

I' hav.e'rel~vantinformation das.sified 'Qbov:~ i'SECRET".

0 I never obse'rVEid this ,coT\ti uCt norhea r.d 'ab'ciu:t it from ,,sOmeone; Wht)' did.

g. Please' provide the approXimale time frame-during, whic::h this tondLieLocco'rred.
Fr0m .<I'VDjYYYv'format or MjYYYV~ to (MJD{YYYY format or 'M/YYYY)0I!,O ,Not R:e~H
Ii. The 'detainee(5:1 treated in this waY.wer.e located'at tne time in:

10

GUantllnamo

'

,

2 ~IraQ

a[j Afghq,nistan
,4' q ,o~b~r Lp-c;atIQn
S 0 Db Npt Re:ca II
i,. Flea,;se identiTy,th~

Oefain~(s).

py

nalJ1e ~;rn9 nu.mQ,~r;,

Do rto,t ret;;l)l.

J. Please iOEmtifY the persdn(s):'Who treated, the, Cletainee($')

Iii this marmer, Indudlng their

I'!am,e(s) and government agel1cy,(i~s)::
, DqD .personnel:.

~. Please identffy ~ny,ot~er F.~I per~nneJ.or n0ll-fBI personnel '\:Vho'observ~d detaihee(s) .treat~d
'
Rotation 9 personnel.

i'1J :thi's m,ailn,erj in~I,ud.itlgtheir narn.¢(s) a'net :a,gen,cy(ies) :
,I. This ,conduct occurred in connection with:

OIGQ-005469

0
2·0

1

On¢ detainee

Sev~ral detainees (2-4)
3 0 Many' detainees ,(more than 4)
,40 Do Not Recall

m. (Optional)

Please

describ.e the. relevant clrcLimstances In more detail:

46. Isolating a getainee f<;>r an extended period

0

a,.

I pe.rsqrlally qbserved thIs cqndl.!ct,

D. 0

I oDseiY:ed detainee(s), ina corid itibn t'hat.led

c,

0
0

Detainee{s)·to.ldme that this condu.ct hcid6ccurred.

e.

o Ir hav,e"'elev~llit iliforniaticm Classified .iHjo:v.e '!S'ECREr'.

f.

0'

I never observed this .conthid nor heara 'aboufit from,Someone:Whb·did.

.d .

ine: to belie.vethat:this condod had :otcurred.

otherS. who ,obrenled :this conduct described Ifto me.

'47~ .Using duc~ tap~ to,restra(n, gag,

or punish a :de~ail1ee

i p:E\rsqnallY 9,p~~fved thts ~Qncju¢t.

a. O.

i'observed' d~taine~(5).lti ;a.cbncl itibn that led me: to beil~ve thauhl$ conduct ha.d 'occurr(:tl.
\n~tain~($) told rile .tlipt this. qoiiduct had .Q:ccurre(l:.

'po. 0
.e.

o
o lathers' wflo -observed this fulid uct d e-s~:riJjeCi itt6'rne.
o II haVe relevant iiifon:nation classified 'a b.ove ".sECREr" .

f.

0' h never observed this conduct nor heard ;aboutdt from,someone wli6 did.

(;;,

d.

'4~,

USing rapid re~ponse t,eams ~ndtor forced cell e){traetlon's-

o iI: p~rSQn-ally o!.>%erVed .thiS :cQ,ri.(juct.
11. o fr,qbse'rved det<Hnee(s) Ina cond'ltlon'th..at led .m¢ tq b'¢llev.e,thCl~,thlsGQnc!uq: held 'Qq:;urre'd.
c. o ~oetainee(s) told /i)~ that this coNduct h13d ~citcurtec:f.
d. o IOth~rs' who .obsetveq'this tdndud-Q.e$cr.ibed it t6, me.
.e. o II have,rele.vant iof6rrl)'ation classIfied above '~SECREr" .
f. 0' II never observed. this'mnduct nor heard 'abbLit it -from someone'wha clid.
_.
.
...
... .....
- --";:t,

,

.

.

..

-.

.

,

,-

.

,

...

OIGQ-005470

'49. Using

.a military working ,d.oQ on Qr tiear a ,defainee:other than during detainee transportation

0 I perspnally observ~d this :cond'ucL
b. 0 t 'obser'Y'ed. d~!CJin'eets) in t;l'cohd itjon that "led me to bel1eye thqt this <.:ond~Q:
c; D Deta'inee:(sj tol~ m~ thatthi,s condu~t hap occurred.
tI· 0 Qthers Who observe,d thl$ ~onduct desc;rlbed It to' me.,
e. 0 1'h!:'lY.e relevant Information' :das-Sified aboVe. "S,ECREf".
r- 0' I' n'e~er Rb~rve~'this.:q).ndu~t nor:h~rQ:abdL),t i~ from ~m¢~me,Who- eltc!.
a.

~ad q'cGurred.

.50. THreatening to :use'militarY working dogs"o.h Qr near' a detainee
.a. 0, r p.er:soDqHY·~.l?~ry~d this·conduct.
b; 0 1,ol?'~erve<! ,det~inee(s) iJ;la'C!:9f1d iljon th?it.led lJle to qe.lie:ve,lh~t this cgnduq: hac! 'qC$~orre!=1.
c.

4,
e:

f.

o 'Defain~,(s) t9!ft,me tn<':lt tnis' c,ohd:Uc.~ h~p :a,~curr:ep,.
o t~iher'S wh'p 'Qb$erY~d't,hiS, eQn~uc;t d:es·trib~,d it t9- rn,¢'.
0' r Iii?ve r~le'Vani:: informCltion J:;la~sifjedgl;)'(j~e ·~S;E¢~"·.
o [I ne\(er,6.pserv;ed. this::cQndutJ: nQr'h~rd _about it fromson\eone'whQ dId.
.

,

'

51. U.slrt9. spiders, 'scorpions', :shakes,..o'r:b,ther' arUmals on or hear a.delaJnee
a,.

b',

0 r p,ersqnaJIy'o.bserveq (his :conduct.
o II. obs~rve-q detail)ee.<sJ In ta:COI;xHtIl;m thqt- led me to' believe tr~t t!1ls conduct had oC,cwred.

,c. 0 _ De~~'l.i.nee(sj, told

4· 0

rn~ th?lt thjS'~Cl!Jdud: ~ad oq:iJrre<;!.

Qt~e~ who observeq t~is !=.onc;luct 9:e~criQ~

it t9' me.

O. r have rel~vant IlJformation·'l;:lasslrled. 'aboye' u;$.ECRET'l.
f.! 0 t Iit=ver d,b;;erved' this ,cdriBuct npr ti$rd abQi:J~~h from Som-eon¢. who: did.

e~

52. Thr:eate:ning to uS€1,spide.r.sl pcbrpfo'ns/ :snakes, or either animals, on'a, detaih~e­

lil 0 II personally observed this;conduct.

OIGQ-005471

b. 0 I observed detainee(s) In a condition that led me to believe that this conduct had 'occurred.
c.
d.

e..
f.

o (Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had occurred.
0
,0

O~hers

whf? observed this con_duct d~scriqed it to m~

I hav~ relE}yant )llformatlon classified abov~ "SECRET".

0 I

n~yer oh$erved this q:>nduct,nor hearq abQut it from someolle. who did.

S~. Ulsre,spectfUl $tat~rnel1t$, handlin9. r or':Cictions' .involving the Koran

D I personally obserVed this cor'icjud.
hi D 1lobseived ,detainee(s) in a'condition that led me to believe that this conduct
,C; 0 Detainee(s)'told me that this conduct nad m::curred,
(j. D Others Who observed this conduct d'e~cri~ed it t9 m.e:
~. D t f1?ly.~ rel~v~fjt rnforQ1:at!on c1a~~fIT~~ ?~9Y~, ",S:J;G!{~"'.
a.

'f. 0

had -occurred.,

r n~ver'o.~?er:ve~ thl$,:COfl9u,ct ngr' h~r.9 .a,p.9l!~ It from~rne'91:)~who 41d.

54. SnaVin:g a detaine~'!d:adal or'Qth~r'iha'ir"to erti.b~irrass,:drhu(fliHate,a det~iiJ)ee

'a. D , I p.ersonally" ebServed this .conduCt.

Cl !t obserVed detainee{S} in 'a',coooitiontnat led me to' believe thaHhis eO,hdlict had :occUrred.

0,
c,

o lQetainee(s) told me that ,this conduct; had ~occurr.ed.

d.

D

e,

o lr. have relevant !nfqrmation c1a~siffec! ~~ove '~SECREfJ"..

f.

011 never observ~d ~hjscondl:lGtnor heard':l~Pl!t it from ~1l),eon,e'liYho ~ld.

lathers who observed this ct:mduct described it to rna

.
:

.
55.< P1~tihg, a wqrna'h'S dothi,ng

qn '0 det:~linee

o II. personal\y observed this ~o.ndutt:.
b', o .Lobserved defafnee(s)' iri ,a'coliaition that led me to; believe that this c0nduCt had .oG:curred.
c', o !Detaihee(s}f6fi:l me that fhis c0ndud had ,0cGurrecL
d. o 1iJthers who observed .thls conductd'escrlbea It to me.
a.

~:

f.

0

;

I, have relevant rnrorrn?lth;>n dassjfi~g above I\SECro::T:"',

o iI-Devero.bse.rved ~hi~ eondu<;~ no.r heq,rd ~bput i! rrom.~omeo.nellJfno

did.

"

OIGQ-005472

56. Touthiny
a.

b.
c.

4.
e.
f.

a detainee or actin'!) toward, a detainee .in a sexual

I
0 I perso~ally Qbserveq this,cQnd'uct.
0 I:o!:Jserved d_eteine~(s) in. a'cohd itjon thqt le<i' ,me, to beneye tha,t thi~ 'COrrduc;t trt;ld occurred.
D' O~talne~(sj tol~ m~ .that this condu~t hap "occClrred.
0 ,Others: who'observe9 thl? cpnd'!Jct described It to me.
0 I haVe relevant Informatioli' :cIas-Sified abo\f.e. "SECRIT" .
0 I'ne~er ob?~rv~~fthi's concfu~t n9r'h!=9r~:ab(;)U,t:i~ frdm'.sornepne who' dirl.

I

.5:7,. 'Hold il'lg defainee(s)
defaining the person. .

a'.
b.

manlier

wnd were nbt officiaIlYiil::kh0w!edg~dor registered as such ,by thea~enGy
,

,

o II pe(~nt;llly:o.bselVe'd this ~()f!!iuct.
o ir 9Q.s~rved ,d~,talne~(s) in','a qoncfitlQrl' that, I~ n'I~. to l?elie:Y~ that thiS: cond.u,j:t ha.:,d Q<;:~!Jtred.

tc: o ID~taln~e(s} t:Ol.d m~ ,t,hat this' cQndut~ oa:d 'O'q:urred.
'd. o JOtners' who bb:setved this' collducj: d'est'iibed it to'me.
e.
f.

D

II have relevant iJiformation' classified 'aboVe, "SECRET".

o iI never obserVed, this,coridu:Ct nor heard -about itJrblii sbmeone who did.

58. Sending

cr. . D

1

a detaihee to another country, for more"aggressive 'interrogation

Ir: per"sonal!y' 09serv~9 ~his ,'!=9Dgud.

b.

o irobserved-d~talfiee(s} in a"cQnd.it'ion that ted rp~ to bel1e\!!= Ulqt this. ~o,nd!Jd had m;:curred.

~:

G IbE!tairee.(s) told me tbat tliis:cbriduc,~h,a'q ocq"mefj.

tI.

o IQthE~'rs Who bl;J'serv!'=d this. c;,dn:dlJt~ d'~s:crlbeq It!9 m~..

e. 0. II' have relev:ant i1'lformation' dassifi\:ci alioVe "SEcm"'.
f. ~

II hev:erob$erv~d

thi,s:~oliau'c,t nor li~r9 abOu~ it from soineon~,who·di~.

I

5.9. Threatening'to send a detainee to another',"ountry'for detention odnoTe ag.wessive, ihterrogation

OIGQ-005473

,.

a: 0 L personally observed this,conduct.
b. 0 I observed detainee(s) In a'cond ition that led me to believe that this conduct had occurred.
c. o p~tainee(s) told !TIe that ~f1i~ condl,lct ~ad !occl;Jrr~.

-

0 bthe~ who 'ob'served this c;:ondLfcrd'e~~r1bed It to me:
I hav.e reievant iOformatiQIJ c1assifiep pbove. ".SECRET"'.
0 i---'-'---~-----..- - - - - , - - - - - - . - - - - . - - . - - -

60.

ThT:eat~nlng to take

<;I.
e.

f:

.

__._-----_ _._--...

I~r ,1 n~ver obs'ef\ied, this c9npl.!.et ndr h~~d 'aQout it from;sqmeone who ~id.

action: against

a detainee's family·

a.

0 r. p.ersonally observed

b.

0

I observed detalnee(s) In 'a'cond Iti9n- that, led' me to believe that this Gonduet had ·occurred.

..

o

pet~inee(s) ~Qld JTl~ that this ~onduct hpd ·occurred.

~

0
0
f. 0'

<!~
eo'

0
b. 0
c. 0

a'.

this 'conduct.

otlJer§ Wb9 -ob~er::v~d this !=~nd.lJqt(f~~cr!b.ed it to

I,

hav~ :rel~va:rit

me..;

!1J(Qrma:tlon cla?,sJfled C!.b9V~ "~EGp.Ef'J

l~ t1~ver' Q'p~erv.eq. thjs '<;Orid.u,¢t

r

n6r· he~ml :ab'put it frolTr$Om~9n~'W~b did.

-I pei';sonaflY-'observed thisE:oliduet.

I

Iobserveddetainee(s). in .a·coAdition that led me to believe that this eon'duct had ·occurred.
Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had ;occun:ed.

d,

o 'others' who oQserved t,his condu~t'9~Scribed

'e'.

0 L have rel~v~nt jrd'orm~ti<?fl.c1assifi~d a,~ove "S:EGRE]""',.

f.

itt9 me:·

o II: neyero,Qs~rv~4 t~.i.s'C;Qndu~t'nor.heaq:l'abQut it :from sqmeolle who did.

.6'2. OJ:heneHgiQu~·or;sE%ual. nat:cf~Sin~.nt

I

or hum'i1jatiqn .Qf a detainee

b,

o II personallyabseriLed this.colidLlct.
o lIobser.Ved detainee{s) in a .cond itf0h.that led me to- believe Jhatthis conducf had ocdkrea.

c.

ct. IOetalnee(s) told me that this conduct had occurred.

a.

Q.: 0, fathers who !>bser:ved tl]is Gonduct'ge!'?Gr.i.~e9 it.to !TIe..
have relevant IlJformation c1a'ssified abov~· "SECRET"'.
~.

o !I'

OIGQ-005474

[!J Itflr never observed this 'conduct nor heard about-It from 'someone who did.

·,t?S. -Gth¢r tre~~ment pf a, d~~ainee

that in your opinion was uhprofE;lsSion,?I, .unduly hpf$h or ~ggres,siv~,

cp,er,clve, -abusive, 'O,f Urilawful

0 r personalty obserV~'cI this conauct.
b. 0 Lbbserved .detalnee:Cs) In .a,oo,hd Itlon. that led me to believe that this conduct had .occurred.
c. 0 Detainee(s) told me that this, conduct had ~occurred.
d. 0 Others who 'observed this conduct described it to me.
e. 0 r have relevant. inf<>.rmation c1ass\ffeg '<:j~o\7e "SECRET"',
a'.

1'. [i:l' I. never observed this 'G:onpuct nor hea,rg :about it {rom som~one'wh~ dJd.

_Th'ili·'MFl~@jl~jfj.@.tHKmm::

",'

'64. Did, yo~, qbsery,e' ~,ny Imp'er~nl'l~t1pn pf F~r per$·o.nlJel.b't,anYQn~jdurlngel,n interyle1N
a·.detain~,? ,

o y~

;',.'

II-

gr IntE!rroga~icm: 'Qf'
'

0 N't>

;65.; DiA any·i;!(3tainee' O,'r'9lh'E::r:pet'$'9.n ~ell YP4lhat ,l)'e.O,f she hqd, ¥{itnl=SS~ t./)~irtlp~r:s:onatioh~f FBI
personhelih c6hnediq'ti with 'a'd:etaiii~ interView of interrogaticin?

() Yes

'

. <9 No:

66: Are;you'awareor any ".sham'! .or ·staged" det~i~ee inte~iews or 'interrogations C0nducted for Members
,ofth,e:·4.'~' 'tongre~~:orJ~eirS~~IT?
.
(pYes· ,~No
,6-,"'1\ To yot;Jr kfl~)VJledge,.dld a,ny n:iil!ti:)ry ori!1tenlg~nq~ persot1n~1 'eyer den~ ~r.delay FBI acce'$s. tp:',a

.
"detainee' the F~I wanted. -to -qU~tiori be$:aLJs~,the.det9,inee had :~ustciined injuries :afte't·· tie. w.as· {:;aptured?
:OY~s0No'

'68~ Did you 'eVer end your par'tidpatio'n iii or observation of a detainee iiiterVieW;or ihterrog.atio.n
becau,se Qf the interv~w:Qr ibterrogt;lt)ol) met.boqs, being use:di
'

0. Yes.

d' No

p.!3a. Briefly' de~~rlbe' th'e;lnterviewor Intemig.atlpn 'met.hOds b~lng IJ.sed I and wHen
and wherethis 'Occurred, including. the names of FBI andlor ron-FBI personnel

OIGQ-005475

inv~lv.ecl.
·At times :during the rotation. Do not. recall exact
dg1::e~.

..

. . ..

.',. .

At the I:ocatlon we ~ere
cpnd.ud;ing InJervj¢ws.

Other Personnel Involved

69: W~re'you eved61dihatano:$er FBI employee ·en.dedhis :oiJier p~i~ipaiion:in or ob:serya:ti9n of; a
detainee-interview.or interrogation because· ofthe- interview or·inferrogationme1h.ods being used?
~ Yes,
9 NoGSa. B.rie'fly' desGribe.'the rl)terv]ew~or iritEmo9ation methods being used f and when

'and where this occurred;, includihg the' names'.of FBI andfor non-FBi personnel'
Ln"qlv~d,:

. .

.

See ·68:

See;68

Other persortne.lIn\r,olv¢d.

L~on-F~:L BeJ:SQ~

S:ee.68

70:. DlIring ahY· ofYo.ur p.v.¢rseas deJ5Joy.tne.nt:~ PI' a·~s.ighmeM:S,.

'did you reIJ.Q!t any t6.nC~.rn's r¢gar~lIng
iriteri:ogatiO,n 'praCtice's, :or uther tyP.e's ;of det8iriee:Ueatmerjf,. tQ'ari FBI
supervisor?·'
.
.
0 Yes: (!). N'o .
7i. O.urint}!C!ny,gf YQ!,Jr p'i(.ef~g$.q~pJoYment~ PJ a$~ig m:nent~,. :di~ Y!:!1.f r,ep:Q.r.t 90Y c.Qn~t;rr)$..r~!l~rd·ing
.allY ~etaln~~·oirit.~tvI~W,Qr-iOt.l'!f(o;gatlQn practlce~ or ot.her;ty'pes· oHi¢talne.eLtfeatni!§nt y'oQ
.
6.liserVed or heard abolit, to,'a noil-FBI supervisor or' other noh-FBI. per~otll'iel?

:any ~d¢taTriee'ilite:r;;iew',6r

,

Q-yes.

0

QY~s

.~ No

No,
.
7:2··1:!9V~'Y9.U :eve.r q~e_n: qrg§Tep 9r;9ir~tep IJqt'tg r~P.9rj:, 'qr q!§'c~!:!raR~g in qf.lY'·Wg.~i froql rep'qM:ing,
.qps!=tv!'!tiQn.s. pi" ~1f.~g,aJiOl1a reJa.ted tQ detainee ,treatment, or interylE!w' Qr interrqg<:t1ion 'qc;:tIQns qr
p.rattice.s?,
.
·73.~ Have:you ~experl.~nced ,a.!'IY ~0yC!1 or threatened ret?liatlQn fOF rep~rtin!!J, ~o~s~llfC!tions or .al.l~g~ti0ns
·of(h:~tai.rreetr~tlJ)~nt.Qfint~~iew.c;>finterrQga~l9n'acj:jon~ pr p.J'?lctic~sJ
QYe~ @ No

74, (Optional) Please provide any additional comments. reg.ar.ding the r.eporting 'of concerns related to.
In~ervl~~. Or ln1;e(rdgatiQn:te~hnl,ql!e~,.de~~ntlon prq~i~~~, 9r'0.tb$r·.de~h:le~·tr~trn·e~t;.

_~_:~~•. :~

D.~~i":'~·::"·'~·f"·':;.,.:.': ·~~>~;~.;.i.·:~:.... i ··,1

75. Were you' i1ebdeted, otiierthan 'the.standard d.e'Qrlefln FD..,;i72; ~Qn~erning YQ\H oyerseas,
~sEiig.llment(~)'Dr:tf~pIOYl1'teht(sJFifl;er yqu'(:QITJP!i:!te-d tbe aepI9Yrh~ht(s,)'dr'assi~ riment(s)?'
~, Y~'s;.
Q I\I.Q
7-Sa. Who debriefed you?
The commana~r of tti~: rriill~ry unit .that we:wer~ .attach~ .debrrefed us;
75b. Wh~n' an.dwhere:dfd the"~ebril=fjng(s) pc::c:;ur?
01) base·;a,t pur locatio!!.'
,
7St Were you asked abOi:Jt:detail'iee'detention ,ofinterview or .int.erroQatio·n pYactices,Qufing the
. • debriefin9.(s)?
'. . . .
.
...
..
..

OIGQ-005476

eyes,

OJ\lq

75d; What other- sUbj~s were cpvere'd during :yo!.lc'd~briefing<s)?
Transition from a mllitaJY environment to.a- civilian environment.
ne. Was anY: doeumeht prepared to memorialize thedebr'lEifing,?

o 'Yes'

0. No

ODo Not KnQW

76., Additional Comments:and Recommendations:
.,None.
.
~ ~-

OIGQ-005477