Skip navigation

Search

472 results
Page 12 of 24. « Previous | 1 2 3 4 ... 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 ... 20 21 22 23 24 | Next »

Summary Judgment on Religious Exercise Affirmed in Part and Reversed in Part by The U.S. Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals has affirmed in part and reversed and remanded in part a grant of summary judgment to Arkansas prison officials in a case involving free exercise of religion. Terry Procter is …
Article • May 15, 2007
Stay of Action Must be Sought to Exhaust Administrative Remedies by The Supreme Court of Missouri has held that a prisoner is allowed to file suit against the Department of Corrections, or its employees, prior to exhaustion of administrative remedies providing the suit is filed within the statute of limitations. …
Delaware Force Suit Dismissed by The plaintiff resisted when staff tried to place chains and a padlock on his cell door, and force was used against him. He filed one grievance about alleged excessive force and resulting medical problems, and a second grievance about the placement of chains on his …
Article • May 15, 2007
Stun Gun Claim Properly Exhausted by Defendants said plaintiff's grievances were rejected because he didn't first file an informal grievance, so he hadn't exhausted. The plaintiff said he did indeed file an informal grievance, and he produced a copy. Also he produced his copy of the second grievance, which showed …
Article • May 15, 2007
Total Exhaustion Required Under PLRA by The plain language of the PLRA exhaustion requirement compels a "total exhaustion" rule--i.e., if one claim is unexhausted, all must be dismissed. General legislative intent and history supports that conclusion, as do policy considerations, since piecemeal litigation is more time-consuming than requiring all claims …
DC Court Lacks Jurisdiction Over Virginia DOC Officials by At 5-6: "Removing any doubt, we now hold, as has every circuit to have considered the matter, that the PLRA's exhaustion requirement simply 'governs the timing of the action' and does not contain the type of "'sweeping and direct'" language that …
Article • May 15, 2007
New Suit Requires PLRA Exhaustion by Plaintiff brought a suit pre-PLRA, tried to add additional claims after the PLRA, and was told to file a new suit. Since his new suit was filed after the enactment of the PLRA, it is governed by the exhaustion requirement. The fact that the …
Article • May 15, 2007
NY Jail Finger Injury Suit Dismissed by The plaintiff had a medical care problem at a City jail. At 308: "New York State [sic] has procedures for filing grievances in each of its correctional facilities." The claim is dismissed for non-exhaustion. A bleeding finger is not a serious medical need. …
Snitch's Assault Claim Dismissed by The plaintiff was assaulted after he was named as an inmate informant in a disciplinary report. The court refuses to reconsider summary judgment for the hearing officer, since plaintiff shows no facts indicating that the hearing officer was aware of a significant risk before including …
Article • May 15, 2007
Administrative Exhaustion Required Despite No Response to Grievance by A plaintiff who merely asserts generally that he has exhausted, not contesting the specific statement of defendants that they have no record of an appeal to the highest level, is subject to dismissal for non-exhaustion. Even though pro se papers are …
Default Denied Where Defendant Ignores Complaint by The plaintiff is not entitled to a default judgment against a defendant who has not answered because he has not exhausted. The court does not explain in its two-sentence reference to this issue why the defendant in question hasn't waived exhaustion, and also …
Article • May 15, 2007
Failure to Exhaust Differs from Failure to State Claim under PLRA by The court rejects the proposition that failure to exhaust administrative remedies is a strike under the PLRA. At 965-66 (footnotes omitted): . . . [T]he PLRA does not use "failure to state a claim" and "failure to exhaust …
Article • May 15, 2007
Non Exhaustion Dismissals without Prejudice by The plaintiff was injured in a Puerto Rico prison and transferred to a federal institution, from which he filed suit. His claim is dismissed for non-exhaustion. The court distinguishes cases that say exhaustion is not required after release, and cites cases saying exhaustion is …
Article • May 15, 2007
Timeliness of Administrative Exhaustion Claim Needs to be Presented in Grievances by Timeliness of Administrative Exhaustion Claim Needs to be Presented in Grievances Plaintiff said he shouldn't have to exhaust because inmate assault is not grievable. Wrong. He said he shouldn't have to exhaust because Porter v. Nussle hadn't been …
Article • May 15, 2007
BOP Detainer Suit Dismissed by The plaintiff federal prisoner complained of a detainer lodged against him by Indiana. He asked for disposition of the Indiana charges as provided in the Interstate Agreement on Detainers, and was taken to Indiana for arraignment, then returned to federal custody, then taken back to …
Article • May 15, 2007
IG Complaints Can Constitute Exhaustion by A plaintiff who didn't exhaust timely can't rely on the Porter v. Nussle change of law, because the earlier decision on which he might have relied, Nussle v. Willette, had not been decided. Porter applies retroactively. (That holding appears to be overruled by Rodriguez …
Administrative Exhaustion Tolls Statute of Limitations by The "prescriptive period" (statute of limitations) is tolled pending administrative exhaustion because the prisoner is barred from bringing the action until exhaustion is finished. Once exhaustion is complete, the prisoner is legally capable of going forward and the statute begins again to run. …
Article • May 15, 2007
Snitch Jacketing Dismissed for Failing to Exhaust by The court acknowledges the "alternative" emergency grievance procedure. Defendants say plaintiff didn't appeal to the Central Office Review Committee, submitting an affidavit to that effect by grievance director Eagen. At 246: However, the record regarding the grievances filed by plaintiff is not …
Article • May 15, 2007
Exhaustion is an Affirmative Defense under PLRA by Plaintiff wrote on the complaint form, where it asked whether he had filed a grievance, that he had not because "I did not know what to do." He never responded to defendants' motion to dismiss. The PLRA exhaustion requirement is not jurisdictional …
Article • May 15, 2007
No Total Exhaustion Rule for Michigan District Court by The author of the opinion in Jenkins v. Toombs adheres to his "no total exhaustion" position, with some acerbity, in a case wherein the magistrate judge adopted the "yes total exhaustion" position of a different judge in the same district who …
Page 12 of 24. « Previous | 1 2 3 4 ... 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 ... 20 21 22 23 24 | Next »