×
You've used up your 3 free articles for this month. Subscribe today.
Idaho Free Speech Claim Reinstated, Voluntary Dismissal Clarified
Loaded on April 15, 2003
published in Prison Legal News
April, 2003, page 25
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals held that factual issues precluded summary judgment on a prisoner's free speech claim and that dismissal with prejudice of his remaining claims was an abuse of discretion.
Filed under:
Retaliation for Litigating,
Nervous System,
Disciplinary Hearings,
Legality of Rules,
Retaliatory Discipline,
Grooming Rules,
Complaints.
Location:
Idaho.
Idaho prison regulations require prisoners to shave daily. A guard ordered prisoner Christopher Hargis to shave. But …
Full article and associated cases available to subscribers.
As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.
Already a subscriber? Login
More from this issue:
- Statutes Affecting Disabled Prisoners, by Daniel E. Manville
- Florida Jury Awards $390,000 Over Defective Prison-Produced Chair
- Florida PLN Writer Settles Retaliation Suit for $3,000, by David Reutter
- Prison Labor Losing Popularity in Oregon, by Gary Hunter
- From the Editor, by Paul Wright
- Pro Se Tips and Tactics, by John Midgley
- PLN Settles Oregon Censorship Suit for $55,414.31
- Interest on Washington Restitution Cannot Be Suspended
- Texas Grants Prisoners Right to Forensic DNA Testing
- Sole Washington Woman Civil Commitment Taxes System, by Lonnie Burton
- Wyoming Jail Must Disclose Suicide Prevention Critique
- Rehabilitation Act, Title II of ADA, Held Unconstitutional
- Delay in MAP Implementation Violates Washington Law
- PI Issued in Arizona Internet Communications Ban, by John E Dannenberg
- California Approves Forced DNA Extractions
- Forced DNA Sampling of California Prisoners Upheld
- Murder, Mayhem, Corruption and Snitches: BOP Florence Exposed, by Bob Williams
- Arizona Guards Continue to Rape Prisoners, by Michael Rigby
- New Jersey Jail Guards Awarded $1.2 Million Following Retaliation for Protesting Jail Conditions
- California Guards Convicted of Arranging Prison Beatings, New Conspiracy Accusations Leveled
- Georgia Parole Board's "90% Policy" Ruled Ex Post Facto
- $400,000 Jury Award in Illinois Ruptured Appendix Suit
- PLRA Requires More Than De Minimus Physical Injury
- Property Use Versus Non-Use Texas Tort Claim Standard Explained in Medical Death Claim
- Idaho Free Speech Claim Reinstated, Voluntary Dismissal Clarified
- State Tolling Statute Applied in § 1983 Action, by John E Dannenberg
- Warden, Security Director Liable for Iowa Guard's Sexual Assault of Prisoner, $45K Verdict Upheld
- Vermont DOC Must Comply with APA for Rule Changes in Furlough Program
- Book Review: Law and the Rise of Capitalism, by Peter Wagner
- $4.47 Million in Washington Negligent Supervision Settlements and Verdicts
- Failure to Allege Imminent Threat Precludes Justification Defenses in BOP Weapons Prosecution
- News in Brief
More from these topics:
- Fourth Circuit Holds Exhaustion Completed After Initial Filing but Before Filing Amended Complaint Sufficient for Claims Raised for First Time in Amended Complaint, Nov. 1, 2026. Retaliation for Filing Grievances, Administrative Exhaustion (PLRA), Complaints, Grievances.
- Ohio Federal Court Dismisses Claim Against CoreCivic for Failure to Protect Prisoner Who Fatally Overdosed, Nov. 1, 2026. Corrections Corporation of America/CoreCivic, Drug Overdose, Complaints, Failure to Protect (Wrongful Death), Deliberate Indifference.
- Eleventh Circuit Revives Pro Se Litigant’s § 1983 Lawsuit Despite His Three Strike Status Under the PLRA, Oct. 1, 2026. Filing Fees (PLRA), Frivolous Litigation (PLRA), Complaints, Abuse of Discretion Standard, Pro Se Issues.
- California Appeals Court Holds Defendant Cannot Be Penalized for Failing to Appear at Sentencing When He Was Being Held in Another County’s Jail on Preexisting Charges, July 1, 2026. Disciplinary Hearings, Due Process, Procedural Default/Error, Evidence - Admissibility, Plea Agreements/Guilty Pleas.
- Nevada Non-Profit Founder Under Investigation for Misconduct, May 1, 2026. Staff-Prisoner Assault, Staff-Prisoner Harassment, Contractor Misconduct, Complaints, Restrictions, discrimination.
- Arkansas Board of Corrections Settles Sunshine Law Charges, Caving to Governor’s Power Grab, May 1, 2026. Retaliation for Litigating, State Legislation, Public Records Act, Constitution, state, Community Confinement/Home Detention.
- Alaska Prisoner’s Discipline for Violating Invalidated Rule Tossed, March 1, 2026. Disciplinary Hearings, Access to Media, Statutory Construction/Interpretation, Authority and Jurisdiction, Administrative Detention/Segregation.
- Fifth Circuit Upholds Dismissal of Suit by Civilly Committed Texan, Dec. 1, 2025. Sex Offenders (Discrimination), Conditions of Confinement, Complaints, Grievances, Civil Commitment.
- Eighth Circuit: Former Prisoner’s Amended Complaint Filed After Release Not Subject to PLRA Exhaustion Requirement, Dec. 1, 2025. Failure to Treat, Administrative Exhaustion (PLRA), Complaints, Cruel and Unusual Punishment, Deliberate Indifference.
- Arkansas “Jailhouse Attorney” Secures Return from Retaliatory Transfer Out of State, Dec. 1, 2025. Out of State Transfers, Retaliation for Litigating, Prisoner Legal Assistance, Religious Practices, Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA).

