What the Government Shutdown Looks Like Inside Federal Prisons
Family visits canceled, guards driving for Uber, rising tensions and more.
The partial U.S. government shutdown is now in its third week [as of January 7, 2019], due largely to President Trump’s insistence that Congress give him more than $5 billion for a border wall he says will keep criminals from entering the country through Mexico.
Meanwhile, the federal employees tasked with keeping the nation safe from people convicted of crimes – prison guards – are laboring without pay.
Because the federal Bureau of Prisons is operating without funding, it has furloughed up to half of its 36,000-person staff, including many who provide therapeutic programs for prisoners and other services considered not to be “essential.” And the agency is asking its remaining employees to keep working unpaid, focusing on maintaining security even if that’s not usually their primary job.
This could remain the state of affairs until the next pay cycle in late January at the earliest – or even for months or years to come, according to Trump, who threatened to declare a national emergency in order to bypass Congress in the funding dispute.
“It’s an absolute disaster,” said John Kostelnik, president of the American Federation of Government Employees chapter in Victorville, California, home to one of the nation’s largest concentrations of federal prison guards. “I have staff that are resorting to getting second employment – like Uber driving.”
Kostelnik points out that many federal corrections officers had already been overwhelmed by the Trump administration’s immigration policies: Victorville, for example, took in about 1,000 immigrant detainees in June.
“It was a mission that was just thrown on us,” Kostelnik said, adding that guards were not provided sufficient training or additional staff to handle the influx of detainees. “And oh by the way, now you’re not getting paid?”
In an email, the Bureau of Prisons did not respond to specific questions about conditions for officers and prisoners but said the lack of funds from Congress means that only those employees whose duties involve “the safety of human life or the protection of property” are permitted to work.
The White House did not respond to a request for comment.
The shutdown is having other consequences inside federal prisons as well. At some facilities, prisoners’ visits with their families were canceled during the holiday season due to the lack of funds, according to interviews with staff and emails with prisoners. Prisoners who are terminally ill and awaiting “compassionate release” to die at home with their families now must wait even longer because their applications are going unread. And in at least one instance, a prison had to stop ordering food and toiletries for prisoners to purchase at commissary, a prisoner said.
“They’re out of most of everything,” Seth Piccolo, a prisoner at the Petersburg correctional facility in Virginia, wrote in an email on CorrLinks, an app used by federal prisoners. “Bad things seem to happen when prisoners don’t get their chips....”
The more urgent problem, said Robert Hood, former warden of the federal supermax penitentiary in Florence, Colorado – where prisoners such as Ted Kaczynski, the Unabomber, are held – is the possibility of mental health staff being furloughed for a significant period of time.
“Most BOP facilities will run without the myriad of programs normally offered” to address the needs of dangerous or mentally ill prisoners, Hood said.
Another developing consequence of the shutdown is that the First Step Act, a celebrated prison-reform bill signed by Trump last December, may now partially be put on hold. According to the new law, the federal prison system has 210 days to develop a risk-assessment tool for evaluating which prisoners can safely be released, which was already a short timeframe for it to be implemented successfully. The BOP is also supposed to be recalculating the earned “good-conduct time” that some prisoners should be getting off their sentences.
That’s now all been sidelined, said Jack Donson, a former employee of the agency for two decades who is now a consultant and regularly communicates with staff and prisoners.
Prisoners are emailing prison administrators saying, “Hey what’s going on with my sentence?” Donson said.
“There are going to be inmates who are past their correct release date,” he said, “and that will manifest in frustration and them acting out.”
The BOP said in a statement that it will continue to work on the law’s implementation, including by identifying prisoners who stand to be affected.
For officers, the pain of missed paychecks is just beginning to set in. Some of those furloughed have seen the shutdown as a vacation, since it’s lasted only a few weeks thus far. But others who live paycheck-to-paycheck or have impending medical, childcare, mortgage or gas bills – given their long drives to remote prisons – are feeling increasingly desperate.
Since federal prison employees can be transferred around the country, some of those most affected are ones not getting reimbursed for travel costs. Others said they are particularly concerned about going into debt; they said that could get them fired in the future, if the agency sees them as susceptible to bribes by prisoners.
Don Drewett, a prison guard in Otisville, New York, who is also the national legislative coordinator for the Council of Prison Locals, said the shutdown will cost the government more in the long run. To avoid further lawsuits like the one already filed by two prison guards on December 31, 2018, the BOP may eventually have to pay extra overtime to everyone who’s been working unpaid.
“Here you are in this terrible setting, this slow psychological grind” of working in a prison, said Drewett, and now you have to watch the news to see if you’ll be getting paid?
“You hear about the politics of, Oh it’s just $5 billion for a border wall, get over it and fund it and then we won’t have a problem.... Well, I find that to be a really crass, insensitive position. That’s not really understanding the human component here.”
This story was originally published on January 7, 2019 by The Marshall Project, a nonprofit news organization covering the U.S. criminal justice system. Sign up for their newsletter, or follow The Marshall Project on Facebook or Twitter. Reprinted with permission, with minor edits. Copyright, The Marshall Project 2019