×
You've used up your 3 free articles for this month. Subscribe today.
Life-Sentenced California Prisoner Cannot be Convicted Under Both §§ 4500 and 4501
Loaded on Aug. 1, 2025
published in Prison Legal News
August, 2025, page 51
Filed under:
Double Counting.
Location:
California.
While serving a life sentence, Richard Manuel Nava stabbed a fellow California state prisoner multiple times with a sharpened piece of metal. He was charged under Pen. Code § 4502(a) for possessing a weapon in a penal facility; under § 4500 for assault with a deadly weapon and with …
Full article and associated cases available to subscribers.
As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.
Already a subscriber? Login
More from this issue:
- Now Under Federal Receivership, New York City’s Rikers Island Jails Still Have No Plan to Improve, No Firm Date to Close, by Chuck Sharman
- From the Editor, by Paul Wright
- Watchdog Calls Out D.C. for Dragging Feet on Construction of New Jail, by Chuck Sharman
- $75,000 for Transgender Maryland Prisoner Raped by Guard, by Chuck Sharman
- Texas Social Workers Challenge Blanket Denial of State Occupational License Based on Youthful Assault Convictions, by Matthew Clarke
- CDCR Held in Contempt, Fined $112 Million in Longstanding Litigation Over Mental Health Care
- Two Exonerated Illinois Prisoners Win Settlements Totaling $14.5 Million, by Chuck Sharman
- California Prisoners Sue Gynecologist for Sexual Abuse, by Casey Bastian
- Oklahoma Prisoner’s Execution Was Expedited by the Trump Administration
- $2.6 Million Paid for Detoxing Washington Jail Detainee Allowed to Leap to His Death, Additional NaphCare Payout Undisclosed, by Chuck Sharman
- Multiple Prisoner Suits Accuse Guards of Violence at Virginia BOP Lockup, by Chuck Sharman
- Sixth Circuit Holds Dismissal Not Automatic When Plaintiff Simultaneously Files Same Claims in State Court, by Anthony Accurso
- Alabama DOC Attorneys Reprimanded for Filing AI-Written Briefs in Prisoner’s Suit, by Chuck Sharman
- Nebraska Considers Curbing Double-Bunking in Restrictive Housing
- FCC Backtracks on 2024 Order to Cut Prison Phone and Video Rates by Half
- $1.2 Million for New York Prisoner Waterboarded by Guards, by Chuck Sharman
- Former Maine Prison Guard Arrested and Detained by ICE Agents
- $15 Million Settlement Reached in San Diego Jail Detainee’s Untreated Withdrawal Death, by Chuck Sharman
- $6.75 Million Settlement Reached in Suit Accusing Massachusetts Guards of Retaliatory Assaults on Prisoners, by Chuck Sharman
- Missouri Prison Nurse Sentenced to 12 Years for Poisoning Husband
- Fifth Circuit Greenlights Federal Takeover of Mississippi Jail, by David Reutter
- $325,000 Paid to Former Wisconsin Prisoner Whose Cancer Biopsy Was Delayed by Previously Disciplined Doctor, by Chuck Sharman
- SCOTUS Partially Overturns Pavey, Holds PLRA Exhaustion Dispute Must Go to Jury Even If Intertwined with Merits of Michigan Prisoner’s Claim, by Chuck Sharman
- Texas Lawmakers Restrict Bail and Raise Criminal Penalties, Punt on Prison and Jail Conditions, by Chuck Sharman
- PLN Publisher Wins Settlement Records from Centurion in Florida Prisoner’s Wrongful Death, by Chuck Sharman
- Prison Gerrymandering Alive and Well in Oklahoma, by Chuck Sharman
- After Judge’s Letter, at Least 22 Former FCI Dublin Prisoners Granted Compassionate Release, by Matthew Clarke
- Ninth Circuit Revives Prisoner’s Claim Based on Guard’s Thwarting of Administrative Remedies, by David Reutter
- $815,000 Settlement in Nevada Class-Action Suit Over Debit Release Cards
- Review: “Reforming the Shadow Carceral State”
- Fourth Circuit Revives Wrongful Conviction Claim of Exonerated Maryland Prisoner, State Pays Him $3.1 Million, by Chuck Sharman
- HRDC Wins $480,000 in Legal Fees from Centurion for Denied New Mexico Records, by Chuck Sharman
- DOJ Tables Controversial Kentucky Prison to Claw Back $500 Million Budget
- Costs of U.S. Incarceration to Families Pegged at Nearly $350 Billion a Year, by Chuck Sharman
- $3,800 Paid to Ohio Prisoner for Denied Records Request, by Chuck Sharman
- Delaware’s ACLU Files Action on Behalf Of Six Prisoners Assaulted During Midnight Raid, by Anthony Accurso
- DOJ Finds Unconstitutional Conditions in Texas Juvenile Detention, by Chuck Sharman
- HRDC Collaborates on Prison Telecom Cost Report to Washington Lawmakers, by Chuck Sharman
- Suit Filed Over Fatal Beating of New York Prisoner That Sparked Massive Guard Strike, by Chuck Sharman
- Over Eight Years in Prison for iCare Founder Who Ran Prisoner Gift Basket Scam, by Chuck Sharman
- Life Sentences, by the Numbers
- Former California Prison Guard Pleads Guilty to Planting Contraband He Pretended to Discover
- Sixth Circuit Upholds $45 Million Verdict for Wrongfully Convicted Former Ohio Prisoner, by Chuck Sharman
- Tenth Circuit Ruling Paves Way for $2.7 Million Settlement for Intellectually Disabled Jail Detainee Raped by Sheriff, by David Reutter
- SCOTUS Clamps Down on Bivens Extension to Prisoner Beaten by BOP Guards at Virginia Lockup, by Chuck Sharman
- Ninth Circuit Agrees That Former Guantanamo Detainee Lacks Grounds to Sue for Waterboarding, by David Reutter
- $1.875 Million Partial Settlement for Colorado Detainee’s Death from Untreated Alcohol Withdrawal; Claims Against Wellpath Pending Bankruptcy, by Chuck Sharman
- $95,000 Paid to Nevada Prisoner Denied Muslim Prayer; Pending Cases Allege Continued Discrimination Against Non-Protestants, by Chuck Sharman
- Life-Sentenced California Prisoner Cannot be Convicted Under Both §§ 4500 and 4501
- On Remand, Eleventh Circuit Clarifies, Affirms Grant of Habeas Relief to Death Row Prisoner
- Qualified Immunity Denied for Iowa Prison Doctor’s MRI Delay for Non-Medical Reasons, by David Reutter
- California Attorney Disbarred for Deceiving Prisoners Seeking Resentencing, by Chuck Sharman
- HRDC Wins Consent Decree, $350,000 in Jail Censorship Suit against California’s Sonoma County, by Chuck Sharman
- DOJ Inspects BOP Food Service Operations, Finds Troubling Issues at Multiple Facilities, by Anthony Accurso
- Tennessee Legislature Passes Bill to Penalize Private Prisons for High Mortality Rates
- Ninth Circuit: Continuing-Violations Doctrine Applies for PLRA Administrative Exhaustion Purposes, by David Reutter
- Nebraska Supreme Court Clarifies Award of Time Served Credit for Non-Citizen Awaiting Extradition, by Matthew Clarke
- Third Circuit Upholds Award of $265,000 to Prisoner Who Was Sexually Assaulted Twice by the Same Guard, by Douglas Ankney
- Shady Firm Awarded $78 Million Contract for Services at Florida’s “Alligator Alcatraz”
- Trump’s “Big Beautiful Bill” Gave Massive Handouts to ICE and Private Prison Industry
- Guaranteed Basic Income Programs for Prisoners Reduce Food Insecurity and Homelessness, by Anthony Accurso
- Sixth Circuit Order Sealing Records in Private Prison Shareholder Suit Vacated, Remanded
- Former Oregon Prison Guard Sergeant Sentenced for Sexually Abusing Imprisoned Women, by Matthew Clarke
- News in Brief
More from these topics:
- North Carolina Supreme Court: Defendant Can’t Be Convicted of Both Habitual Misdemeanor Assault and Felony Assault for Same Act, Sept. 15, 2020. Double Counting.
- U.S. v. Reyes, No. 06-3699-cr (2nd Cir.) (557 F.3d 84) (February 19, 2009) (Per Curiam), March 1, 2009. Punch And Jurists, Double Counting.
- U.S. v. Schmeilski, No. 04-2014 (7th Cir.) (408 F.3d 917) (May 25, 2005) (Judge Ann Claire Williams), June 1, 2005. Punch And Jurists, Double Counting.
- U.S. v. Howard, No. 02-1024 (7th Cir.) (352 F.3d 332) (December 12, 2003) (Judge Kenneth F. Ripple), Jan. 1, 2004. Punch And Jurists, Double Counting.
- U.S. v. Alcala, No. 02-2283 (7th Cir.) (352 F.3d 1153) (December 9, 2003) (Judge Kenneth F. Ripple), Jan. 1, 2004. Punch And Jurists, Double Counting.
- U.S. v. Brown, No. 01-16881 (11th Cir.) (332 F.3d 1341) (June 5, 2003) (Judge Stanley F. Jr. Birch), July 1, 2003. Punch And Jurists, Double Counting.
- U.S. v. John, No. 01-60721 (5th Cir.) (309 F.3d 298) (October 7, 2002) (Judge Jerry E. Smith), Nov. 1, 2002. Punch And Jurists, Double Counting.
- U.S. v. Jackson, No. 01-10396 (11th Cir.) (276 F.3d 1231) (December 21, 2001) (Judge Phyllis A. Kravitch), Feb. 1, 2002. Punch And Jurists, Double Counting.
- U.S. v. Humber, No. 00-11054 (11th Cir.) (255 F.3d 1308) (July 5, 2001) (Judge James C. Hill), Aug. 1, 2001. Punch And Jurists, Double Counting.
- U.S. v. Levy, No. 00-3170 (6th Cir.) (250 F.3d 1015) (May 22, 2001) (Judge Eugene E. Jr. Siler), June 1, 2001. Punch And Jurists, Double Counting.

