Skip navigation

Articles by Mark Wilson

Ninth Circuit: Merits Decision Excuses Procedurally Flawed Exhaustion

by Mark Wilson

The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit held that a prisoner who fails to comply with prison grievance procedural requirements nevertheless exhausts administrative remedies if prison officials deny the grievances on the merits.

In January 2011, California prison physician Wesley Hashimoto recommended morphine and ...

Montana Refuses to Pay Judge’s $744,371 Sexual Harassment Settlement

by Mark Wilson

The Montana Supreme Court held that the state was not required to indemnify a judge on sexual harassment claims that he settled with his court reporter.

Charlene Berdahl worked as the primary court reporter for Montana district court judge George W. Huss. In February, 2014, Berdahl filed ...

California Attorney Invoices Not Categorically Exempt from PRA Disclosure

by Mark Wilson

The California Supreme Court held that legal billing statements in closed cases are not categorically exempt from disclosure under California’s Public Records Act (PRA).

Modeled after the federal Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), the California PRA allows broad public access to government information. In 2004, California voters ...

Michigan Juveniles Entitled Miller Montgomery Resentencing

by Mark Wilson

The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit remanded a suit challenging Michigan juvenile life without parole (LWOP) statutes, to address the issues under the legal landscape established by the United States Supreme Court. On remand, the district court declared that the juveniles are entitled ...

Failing to Report on Hawaii Furlough Is Not Escape

by Mark Wilson

The Hawaii Supreme Court reversed an escape conviction, finding that failing to report to a caseworker while on extended furlough is not escape.

In June 2011, Hawaii prisoner Eugene Paris Jr. was released on an extended furlough. His parents' home was listed as his furlough site. The ...

Third Circuit Vacates Dismissal of Grievance Threat Retaliation Claim

by Mark Wilson

The United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit held that a reasonable fact finder could conclude that a prisoner was issued a misconduct report in retaliation for threatening to file a grievance.

Pennsylvania prisoner Joseph Watson's radio was broken while guard Kline was inspecting it ...

Ninth Circuit: Incarceration Costs Subject to Bankruptcy Discharge

by Mark Wilson

"Seeking to obtain…revenue by unremittingly pursuing legal actions against disadvantaged individuals--the counterproductive practice at issue here--can have damaging effects on the community," the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit recently declared. "Not only does such a policy unfairly conscript the poorest members of society ...

Arkansas Supreme Court: Accident Report Information Not Exempt from FOIA Disclosure

by Mark Wilson

The Arkansas Supreme Court held that the federal Driver's Privacy Protection Act (DPPA) does not prohibit public disclosure of information contained in vehicle accident reports from being released under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA).

Attorney Daniel Wren sent a FOIA request to the Arkansas State Police ...

Oregon Victim Must Allow In Camera Inspection of Computer

by Mark Wilson

The Oregon Court of Appeals held that an alleged rape victim was required to turn over her computer for in camera inspection of her internet searches. That is, a criminal defendant's right to access "important and exculpatory" evidence trumps the victim's privacy rights.

In 2011, Bend, Oregon, ...

Oregon Probation Improperly Revoked for "Action Plan" Violations

by Mark Wilson

The Oregon Court of Appeals vacated a probation revocation judgment, finding that the court improperly revoked for the violation of a special condition that was not imposed by the court.

Valora Rivera-Waddle pleaded guilty to assaulting a public safety officer and was sentenced to 60 days in ...