Skip navigation

Usdoj Olc Memo for Gen Consel Dod Re Habeas Jurisdiction Guantanamo Bay Dec 28 2001

Download original document:
Brief thumbnail
This text is machine-read, and may contain errors. Check the original document to verify accuracy.
e
" ... .--.- ...
•

•

-t=t:' , _.

-.----2I!ig~ec.::r. -~
n

---

D

Thio

•• •

U.s.nopart_ofJ_

_

.. I!>o q\ltOIioD _

",,_

.... 2.. :lOOt

. _

_.II

cIisIrid ....... .-14 prnporiy

baYe jIIriodlotioo II> ~ • p«itioa for • "';1 0 1 _ """"" died <Xl b<baIf or... aIim
_ _ .. lbo U.s. JlaYaI _
oj o...n.n- Boy. Cubo ("'(i9C."'). ThU 'l"Mlloa bIIII ,.;.,
_
0 ' - , " ... ddalo ol Qo<da""" T>bl>oo
(llIC p<Ildq; _1>10 Iri>J by
mi5I.J
; . If. l«I<nI cliIlria «>UrI ...... ., lokjwildictiocl ....... - . . pctiIiaa, ~
ooaI4 rnIcoo lbo
"btIk4oaIlty 01 .... '
" .... lbo _ 01 • ...m...,. _ ........ 1be
"I'P'k_
~..s
lepI ...... ol.. Q-I& -.I T.libIa
,

or_-,.

""""""_l!lc

w• ......- lbaIlbo *""" """Jhlorl<pl """"""y iMicala 1l1li, ftdlnl _

"1

WUI1

_ootpn>p<riyaoodoobobooojuris<li<tiolo ....... &li<Ddcloiz><d.GBC. t' "
10)' _
- . _ cortoiaIy dlII III)' _
potilioIII woUl bo fi • ! ' " Jd: of
jrirN-&- A
._fri_...-lhol;.;.diclion ................
.................. ill ClBC, .., . . _ _ DO <loci';""" l!IIl dearly ",.".",., 1bc.."
of
_
jw" .... - . Oa. die al!lIO' baDol, it doa DOt ow- tbd""l' l'e<I<nI
hoo
~._ poI!1IaD lD JlRIOOO'IIloul GBC, _ . WbiIo _
bdlo¥o 1lIoI1ho ........ _ _
...... _ _ looo1 jw. 5 r ...... _p<tiIioas&lcdbyolim......
boId<lOllllido
1lIo
IIIriI<Iry oflbo UIIite<I s-, " " " . - _
~ . . _ . cliIlria-.n
mi&bl_dlooppooilo - .
_

C"

_Ill

Tho - . So< ~jwi~' ... ..-.... • ~ ~...:. ·fii.d·~::GlIC.- .... - - ... EX • _ . ) " U.s. 76J CIAAI'). ill _ - . "'" s..p.....
boW
lbaI hknI_ 61 "",_..-icy ..
'WI" ri", fOr _ _ RIid' filed by ...

J

.h.:;';;-; -,'.:

•

_1Iiea wb>1lod _

""*"""" ..

ooim mol bold.. oIlm....t

=-

e-c

_lbotl!rTilalyoflbe Uaited

•

101;. """ ...,,.d
,.....-..._ ,

.~~...
.t"«'~,5. etlJdl$ ' >iIi"'H'lh., .~m
oidlbc~ ;"(:hino.oIIottk<lnaoyhad _.
~..t "AprilI904S.

Tb<y ..... .azed,'lriod
by I>liIitJry
...... io ~ QIilII"'''~.~ ill Ge<nIcIy.
1bort, II>oy filed .. lip>5 . li>r _
_
... tho D\driI:I Coml ro.. Ibo Diolrict of
CoJamlIia, JIBIlin&. i i ' " Ibo $oc:nlaIyofDdtDso. Sea=y oflbc AmIy,.md lbe loiJll.
Ql;ofI or Staf[ JtL" ~. 1b< CoM 00IICl0<\0<l1bol tho _
<tIIltIo
power
.. poal ~ f<liofbecauoO lbo pIooioIifJiI ..... bc)'<IIIII .... urril<lrial"""';8JIlYoIlbc thlitcd
_ _ _ lbc\l:nilDrialj.. "
OhIlI'U.s.«ut. AJlboe-t<>plaiDod:
II

!""'"

..

W. IwYe poialod oat lbot lbo ~.. of 1iIi.... boo beoIo ~ ..
oli-. ...... Inooolly or _
. cmI)'_
~ lboir JI'<S"D'" ill lbc
""""'Y hnp!iod " , _ No I<Idl bail_ be _
b<R, rar lI>ooc ~
.Ill DO rdcnol ri.uo ..... wiIhin ifnI' larilO<}' ..... >o1llcb lbc UIlilOJ _
is

.......ig;:>,- _lbc_ _ .. f..dwi>'T
11'+ -...... 1bcj. !rial p i " " i.
~ ..... 011 boyoft:llbo faritaialJmis4iotioIl of ooy_
of"'" UIlil<d
-

•

0

"

•

'

f

_, _

_

•

-.., "
J4.11.

m_71.'

•
-_..,
' 100 _

_

,
.._10_100_.._06
_.. . . . __ .
... __...

.. 0~

_ .m"'..I.~"'(lO>G)("fo'

_;

' s.. _ _
_
.~,_ _ "'''
e-..
aootu
_ _

1I&

n

... _

[

"

'

_.

..

;.

tAo

:

Jo' I ~l(''''.",",200I~
,.,' " [ of.., _
_

. . _ _ . . - _ _ .. _ _

_C1rn)~_[io......-J

. _",

c...e-..,~
.,C

_ _..._ _ .... ......,.0(..,__

...,..-, -,_.....
-- ..........,...-,.-...f.m!"""ii'ia""._ _.j
:_.. . . ....,
__"'_ _
.. _

•. . """"'

<-1_ _

-

;:W_. ·i·
,':

' IF

WP,
m.-..IlJ!.lkW:II'n)"("I' n - '. ' _ "' ~ _ """" Io
a;.., _ _ . . _ _ v.s.s.-,... · ·l""'IlIoJ~_
_ ... _jri·

•

01'. .
.......

... ,..
0-

" " ' - . ; .,. ,
_

....... ~ ......

.... ........_ _

,

j. . ....

Jald_ ..

~_

'"

-

..,',

,---

~. -

: ..;

.',

•

•
••
I!!~l il nl i~tr 'mll g ~wr lJfJ.' 'ft L~ ·
hl!h SH~ rIHJh~! y fiUnt" 'Ii, lu, L
,

~

,

Vl ' I f m~~th!! f·r1f·fl I.d ~ I(~' to
'1'1"l 11 r" r~. ! ,> [i 'lH ~ rf • ~. l

ihli•1

hi

·[h!ii!!!i!
l~!ld!:
IJi~
i~h
i'
.
w·,d;,t Iii. lti rr!~· ...

~l t
sun
iJ ~" ~.rf l{ff i .~~i
. " . rr ' lf l !., t • h~ i ~
. •d l !l. ·

I

•

II

Jr'

h la "!o ,.
"

I l~ ~ l 'J

li'.;r

'u J "

.;; ilI!H'rH _. hWt'ld It· i';~;' ~I l~.th . f

.,uhd!
..•
~
&
. tl~tdH , 13
'. ' ; U,S
1:I'IrI·U'rH
" " ';' ~"; : :

, It

'.
',,;-

:;".

.

Ihii~
~h[~llH
j
lla rl ll'l ~
,-ul.ll ,. _

I

, '-

u

)

I

•

";:::.' ';;iJ::1~.1:W;":..· '.T= .&"'!m'~UII!IIi 1jil]1lj

_or

~ ......bidI tho IUtlil<d S_'j lcoi<d basa lor &nnudaJ ....... ~ _
Gr<OIl Britain cIid DOl ond ....... Dot iIltoodtd k>
......,..;gmy ova' !he IaoocI . . - _
GrMIBrilaiD ...... lIDiO<d s-.~ 3JS U.s. III 380. ~._fiYojllOli<s - h"'d
__ tho _
0l'OI io _
Ibo .........py ofGtao< am.m ..., lbd it io DOl tcrril<.y .rlb<
tJ.med S_ ill . poli!i<ol sa.-, """ is, . put orilsnm-J domam." /d. .. l~l . 10'1 ........".
"'" ~ opoafioo/ly _ _ "'" !JaILed is.- _ boo
from lbo R<pobIio ofoa
or .. _ III 00..._
Bay b . cuoJinc or I>mlI .....""M
\hal
Ullillld S_ _
a:raotod bylbo ClIboa _ ,, ' . iollJ lbo _ rip a il bas
Jtt ..
383
(quoCioa 1903 I,IS.-()Do"-).

;" i.,~:•

, ')llc

"'Ibo_ ......·

" a.s

SimiImy, lI>o diss<III _ _ lbIl "Bermuda IIIld Iik< baa ..., DOl
....
_j ,, " U:.I)9l.Q-,J.di wnriq). ~_Il&Jc.... • Ic Il._ia
C»IIo. • • . boo _ 1'Olod b)' lbO """"~ ."ir,
i11iii IIti \ii:dl1iii6ii liji
1I>e StaI10 Xl", _
.......... _ ._~JPV<JIIia& lCriIofi<o"...... tho AdnI/aloIralcr,otjbc ....,.. Ad bolOrIoo. ""'_ i1_lout~
.
" Jd: al<lOS { J - " I . c!j= " .:) •• •
t!
I.. omiIt<d). Tho diaiJ"""'"'" in "'" cue ... DOl ...t><thoIlbo UIliIOd Sto!oo ..cn:iaolI '
. . - . .. .1)' ova' GilC - aII " - d>IIt .... tIrillOd: St>teo dOl DOl _ but _wb<Ibc:r .... PUlA
~ u o_ ,ik>l;,Dy '" i0oi040 U.s. miIiImy _ _ .. """" .. Bonn........ GBC. 11>0
..' It ",. -¥o lIIrDI,orcounc, ... wb<lbc:rlbo UDitod S - _ _ plly _
• . _" ,

_ .P

,

portiaIlortariloo7.

.

-

-

.'

ill o/IaIp _ _ '" Ibo _
et .... PloiIippiDo "!oDds ill
GmmIl Yoma!dlo ... rdod"l10 PbiIippiacoo by . U.s.
11111itaIy
. . toea 0cIcber 10 Xl aJ I of 19U, """ lbo
e:.-t -_
10
aCIdot II""- J' . Ii.. ill ~ tho ..... mjgjon'. d«:ilioL " S- JW'~' ti _ - '"
U.s. I.' (1946). AI. ... Ii-. bowowo".IboPIdlippillo lobm\l . . . . . . . .
r
. ol""' Uoiral-'_ DOl . _ U,S.'
ioII. .....i See fl
= ;.'39
U.s. .7IO ("By_!'f_~.lboI
l
, Y..-b/la
1IlDod _
• cIi<I Qoiria - . . AmcrioIn _
YIlIlWbila'. 0 _ ..... ........allr:d 00_

_

Tho pooiDoa. at GBC _

orl""a out ofWarId W.. Do

s.-

,=".... m

t

•

..

." ,.

•

, .

-,

"

'-

..

-. ., . "
. ',

.

•

.ra;;I:iI1.'So";..'t1rd"HlM-J& _IlNI ~"' . ! , _ .,. ,db, Ii: aliti!';",
tIIriIoIJ'ot ... \.IIIil<ol - . , . Tlw ~ s- ......... =, u~ _ "'" f'IIIIiliwi_'E """..
I~_,
..,.. u.s.c. elL S(I_~ . __ lIlo 'H"ood' il"""-'<_
1
• I . , '. n. ..- s - _ • ..-,.
_
_
:'
_ _ Ik I'D """1)0. _
'=-' , col to _
... (ill(;, s."~
- - - . i l l u.s. • 31oI .t. d . no e-n .
' of!lot , ....; , ' _ """ .. ,""'-_

....._ '
r

.......

_""'~S_

... , .;

• __ .

io GIIC _,. Ir. - tdy ~

...

""to""' 4, IMll

"", " " ' , ;,

G8C . _ _ ....... .101 joo ' :'

0I

"''' _

..-_~

_ .,"U..$.7'1I. n........,.ot-,_-a_io
""_ s.
IaG l l l oo.ICl, . Il:I-I Dli(lMol). 0-:.
__

fi
l:I U.s-C.H'I-l1I

.,-_. ...-if""''' __
.-..........,._ ...

-...._/olaIoI_IloI_

(I~ d

. . . . . _ _ e-.
1orptJ
(....... III& DioIrid oillPtooii .. _ _ ....
. J' :
l-f;- .... - -~.

W-- ,.

. 7 ""

.

........,. _ Jooo. ~21 U.s-c. i ~ l
Wab..-. S " ' - IslU,'"
~.
- -'

,

9

boo -..,lIy _
tboposili<oD
_
OJIC 10 "';!b« port
\.IIIilCd $ _
; . "", ... 1aTiay of "'" 1.hdIod _
For
...-pie, thd 0flI00 b>o 0piD0:I_ Gel: 10
pori of lbc "l1rlit<ll
ror _
oftbo
lIIlmi
N _ Acl. s.., Iol..-melum for "'" ~ " ' - GcDcnoL
_
Lony L S
D<puIy _ _ AIIom<7 o-nl, 0lIiaI otLcpl c:o-.l, k $orIIls <f
Go . ...
..,. (Ott. 21. 1911). Sial>lIrI)r. 10. 1m , .... A......,. o.-.J opiDo4 !hoi GOC
........ . j:
' m" of
UooiIed _
. . . . 1bc
of _ _ ,.;tt..",. sDw- _ G>.>o!t
_ u..- . 0
, IIq.
J S ~ NI",
$J6 (1929). CDC _
U
' . . . . . ..,.., _ ~
.................. ""'_
j '
"'_ol""'~-'~_Mzs '"
U.oIS'I. , . .........
lr.oiIo<zlJ _ ,...
fOooII1.~-"' -

.r..

•

s....

........u.

"* .....Nt-l.-.

ea.-

ewe.

_ol
_
.
.
.
, ......l-.I_... ;.,_..

eot_.. .......,.
-.

.. _olGIIC _

. ..,- : - - , : ' ...

...,.

Jl'I'IIiIIi-_G8C.....- ......

~_..,....us...

'i

' "'

•

- ~

...

-"'100"'_ _ " _ _f

. . _..."--"""-""'-"
__ .... . . ._GI(;_.__
-. .._ _

,

A

; , . - -1 , . . .
~

-

_

_

-

_

IW

-

-

$

_ ... _ _

_

l,U. _

· _ _

e-._ .... _ ..._ .... _

-.

a ll.l.l:.l l "" (loX11

'_ _

..._

"_F I ).

_

. ~ _

_

_ft

__
-,.
_
..··

. .... ee-.- .. <i

~

.._._'C

~ " " ' O I C _" _

•. . -_ _ • _

011I;

_

_

..

_

•

._
. - _.. _ . _ _ io.,or-,.. _
'..-_ _
..
."......._ 0
....

""-_
_

_ . _..

~

-

._._.IIot<!p_
. _.. . ._..,._

•

$

.

_

_ _ " . . _ _ ,., ...
~
I
'Ac1

" UlICio _ _ .,.. _ _ .. .

.,..... _. lJ.s.j;

,

"

$ •• ••

-

..

,,

$'"

.

_

'-' •••

:

.

••

-'

.

•.

.
i!·wmiH-f

'rill I
til inn t:~l! 1~ •:it l:~ j

~rli~IH

U(i II if

I~ Hrmul=!iH
. IUlh'[~ifh~11
H!?m~
IH,
~I:l
I' hjif~U 1
I~~ r , II ! e,l . 5i f)~' 'f "l '

rr""t'i ~lIIW~
} -Ilf I[~r . H'('I;~
o
.
lel
~ Ii ~n~ ,-:§ ,,''r!"
'h
,
[
Y,1
e,
'<:1
i
rf I ~q~h. lUI
0 "l

.Hfl

'"

,15:

[1'1;'11

ILl

li'~t'
,
~~I'lit}Xl!
'
I
if tEeth l' .
l ., .' :~i
II
a; r<S

i~ .

hldhi .!!, If'!'l ,I.rr I

r[ ~,
, II < Ii f'! 1
f .
i~jl i~v l~,~t
., ,*, 1 ~Fl '15f
~

If

·~n~

I~I ~ . l~'hlh

.
h,~' ~~!. ~r[l.f" n
,I
Ij, 1,'I"!
'h;;ll!".ilm ~ni .d I .' ItJ ~dlf.l..f"

it;;·1

>

io' II . I ~ '

Ihi

.........,. I

,

.;

_

!I
,

I

-

I

I
I

"

•

•

. ,_ . . I" =
s..c-..-.._
_
-e. no.fad

.;:....'"Gc~ !!
...... GIIC.

__ _

Io

....,. .. u.;..d _

.: -of_' ! t !

0?!¢' ii ll '

;-.lF
_

_ ~_

.................. _

r.

'.

'1 ' \
GBC...-Ibo

· f q - a1

-'1sioioe

_ _ ' - .. , - - o l

otolo,. '

_. "

-.;IIrIy_
'P
~ _ -.,,lIIo I
"
• ~ .. 1iOtII _
dl<...
« or....... Nay ....... . " " - '
""""" do< "PP" .. io~' , _
boW.. 'TlIol, _
.
e-\'. oul)oiL
5

•

......

10"

•
QoaOI . . . ' 4 1; i ; r
too _
- , . . io
... ' I taC. I 7"""'. GIll:. - . . .
CIIaoIl" _ _ . . _
_ . _
iwiol
s. ~ _
~
2 16 Ud 201, 21. (2od CL 21m). AM
"". ,,_ • lII.itooioi W i
1Ir ...

10 - - . "'" _
~ _
,. I; _

7

.- .......... a-e-t_
?

•

n,o_"'_t

•

• ......... . _

~

_ _ .c

Uo/lIoIIsa--

r

_ _ _ _ 10 - , _

...,..";"

.. s..-

.,5 '

_

' JiL .. :l14

..,:.."...• ..;.;.

• _ , " _ _ 11

IlI.,_.=
C._ .a; _ ..._ :;
_~' -·· ;,:

ClmOI _IIolj . . , llJ.$.C.f1_ . .

.,

a.,.

-, , .'
: ,I

_ "·" " 1 •.,,-'
•

~

<. ... ~ •••

...

-~.

~

~" .

...., ~

•

'.

•

.....

r-.lr, ' " p<DofIo _
_ _ - ' f '- "GIIC,

_ _ __

n

.

... _fll .. ~

C

'
C '

.

..

• _

_ . . ; . . ..

-'Y.-

r

b y - . If .... .. _

vI ","

r_

..

· r

;

"

,..-. .,.... 73 ..

: .... C C =
-,, -,-,'I d ' ilk:s _

of!>irJ ,......,.. - - _ . _
IOGIC, .
.. IIc "

r

.

... _

.,.,.,.

er p

__

(:lIid _

,.-

be..- ..

•

m

•

•
--..-"'-_._._---,...,..

....,. •

;

,,_

Jr'

t

a

. _

j'

_

•

~ .. _

.......,. _

•

_

.

:

.

•

-

..

:

.. _ _ ... _

_Joo '

....... - . _

.

:

. ,_

'

,

...........

..

_

'

;-;;.-~ . ,

.

•

~

b_

_

,,~

.

..,A"''
'
'
:
'
'
_
...
_..

_ 1I \U.C:,1 7

_0IC.

•__ •

,

_ -. :

. .•,,"'....,",
..

a u = l llUl(oJ(2}

...

' ..

u.a.

p .. 08C _
.
... · '
'
._
oIu.&. k ..._ - " , _

b

.

-

t _

f

. _ _ ~ ....... _ _ a

..........

J
....

w

5

1

•• ~ . _ _

_,r
"',.".. _. e -1ooo
' <_'oJ_:
........

.. _ onu.p,.,,U

:

_

~i

IIIl.S.C."._ ..........

....... _

.. _ _ ....c-= _ _

.. -

.....

_ _ .. . . , . _ _ ;._

,", '

", " q. QI..I;. no~

.. l*;, _

-

.. _ - .

.... _ .. _ _
_

.

.,.. ~

•....11' ....'1_

_

_

.,

, .•

~ ' '-~ ~

... _

' jooIaol
'"

'r .

..,..0;

" ' :.. ,,~ _,

" ~'.:' '' ';':,:; . !' '"
, :~;~ir' ,-, ,;~;",,; ,.<;; ~:

, ~ .,..." .
'.: f'·:c;
.u:

•

j'-

,

.- f li" .1j

f<Ir Il>e rorqo;., JaOOl>O, ~ con<lode lhaI • _
""'" COIIIlOI _ l y 0IIIaUiD ..
.opp6<otion l<><. wril ofbobcd ""JlIlI by IZl c>omy olicn d<\>.il>oll at G_ _ Boy Novo! .'

.' ~"

',.'"

a--"" .... bHoo>Iyelb<a><lcfmilivdy.....-hy 1be _ - , ~ . ~ i ;j
....Ii... thlII. _10.....,. _1>iIily 1bol. <Ii<tricI oourl....,.ddcntmoio m::h m.oppljeoll....
\ ,
_

Cob&.

• ,',.

•

.",,,
,

,

."

....

... . ..
"

•
"

"

•

,
, TDT<a. P , IQ