×
You've used up your 3 free articles for this month. Subscribe today.
Ninth Circuit: California Prisoner Need Not Appeal from Satisfactory Grievance Response in Order to Exhaust Administrative Remedies
Loaded on Nov. 15, 2011
by Michael Brodheim
published in Prison Legal News
November, 2011, page 26
Clarifying “the boundaries of proper exhaustion” within the context of California’s prison system, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals held that a prisoner “has no obligation to appeal from a grant of relief, or a partial grant that satisfies him, in order to exhaust administrative remedies.”
Filed under:
Disciplinary Hearings,
Disciplinary Litigation,
Disciplinary Appeals,
Prompt Hearings,
Administrative Exhaustion (PLRA).
Location:
California.
In July 2004, Quillie …
Full article and associated cases available to subscribers.
As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.
Already a subscriber? Login
More from this issue:
- New York’s Sex Offender Civil Commitment Program Proves Expensive, Problematic, by Matthew Clarke
- Eleventh Circuit Reverses Dismissal of BOP Failure to Protect Suit
- From the Editor, by Paul Wright
- Texas Jail Guards Smuggle Contraband in Tacos, Ramen Noodles
- $725,000 Award in Negligent Medical Care Suit Involving Poisoned New York Prisoner
- Oregon Jail Suicides Lead Grand Juries to Fault Prevention Efforts, Staff Training, by Mark Wilson
- Alabama Sheriff Capitulates to ACLU in Challenge to Denial of Attorney Visits
- Incapacitation Good Cause for Untimely Exhaustion Under PLRA
- Federal Court Rules on Exhaustion Issues for Joined Plaintiffs in Lawsuit Against CCA
- California Appellate Ruling Holds Court Fee Inapplicable to Pre-2009 Convictions
- Ninth Circuit Holds Serious Risk to Prisoner’s Health Posed by Year-Long Denial of Outdoor Exercise “Obvious” as a Matter of Law, by Michael Brodheim
- PLN Files Censorship Suit Against NYDOCS
- U.S. Supreme Court Holds Civil Contemptor Facing Incarceration Requires Procedural Safeguards Absent Counsel
- Former Judges in “Cash for Kids” Scandal Sentenced, by Derek Gilna
- $370,000 in Annual Phone Revenue at Ohio Jail
- PLN Sues Jails in Louisiana, Washington State Over No-Publication Policies
- Ninth Circuit Holds That Absconding Tolls Supervised Release for Federal Parolees
- Settlement Reverses Virginia DOC’s Ban on Jailhouse Lawyers Handbook, by David Reutter
- Summary Judgment for CCA Reversed in Filthy Jail Conditions Case, by David Reutter
- Hawaii Ex-prisoner Awarded $83,000 for Being Held 83 Days Past Release Date
- Requests for Hawaiian Prisoner Workers Soar Due to Poor Economy, by David Reutter
- Boulder, Colorado Jail’s Postcard-Only Correspondence Policy Ends with Settlement
- Ninth Circuit Rules Right to Court Access Violated When Lockdown Prevents Prisoner from Researching Issues Related to Direct Appeal, by Michael Rigby
- Nevada DOC’s Ban on Male Supervisors at Women’s Prison Invalidated
- No Qualified Immunity for Guard Who Transported Prisoner in Dog Cage
- Ninth Circuit Rules California’s Proposition 115 Not Unconstitutional
- Ninth Circuit: California Prisoner Need Not Appeal from Satisfactory Grievance Response in Order to Exhaust Administrative Remedies, by Michael Brodheim
- Report Blasts Sex Party at New York Juvenile Facility
- Ninth Circuit Holds California Prison Officials Responsible for Providing Reasonable Accommodations to Disabled Prisoners and Parolees Held in County Jails
- New York Court Sentences Rabbi to Four Years in Prison
- Iowa Supreme Court Rules That Sex Offender Treatment Program Requires Due Process Protections
- Colorado Prison Culinary Program Caters to Local Community
- Conditions at New York Juvenile Facilities Deficient; State and Federal Officials Settle Lawsuit
- Ten Years of Sham Segregation Reviews Result in $4,846 Damage Award for Arkansas Prisoner
- Courts Cannot Order Federal Prisoners to Participate in IFRP
- Ohio Prisoner Escape and Hostage-Taking Results in Lawsuit Against CCA, Settlement
- Tenth Circuit Rules Denial of Halal Diet May Violate RLUIPA, by Michael Brodheim
- Tenth Circuit Rules Oklahoma Prisoner Exhausted Administrative Remedies
- Eighth Circuit Upholds Denial of Qualified Immunity on Medical Claims Against CMS
- Florida Jail Offers Video Visits to Profiteer More From Prisoner Families
- ICE, CCA Settle ACLU Lawsuit Regarding Health Care for Immigration Detainees, by Derek Gilna
- California: New Postsentence Rehabilitation Credits Inapplicable to Sentences of Convicted Murderers
- “Public Concern” Test Does Not Apply to Prisoner Retaliation Claims; Speech Must be Consistent with Status as a Prisoner, by Brandon Sample
- Pennsylvania Councilman Takes Private Prison Company’s Donation, then Opposes Detention Center
- Prospect of Prison Rape Used to Deter DUIs in South Africa, by Brandon Sample
- Washington Community Custody Violators Entitled to Time Served
- Second Circuit Holds BOP Correct in Not Granting Good Conduct Credits for Time Spent in State Custody, by Brandon Sample
- Incarceration Alone Insufficient to Terminate Parental Rights in Michigan
- Does Less Punishment Mean Less Crime?
- BOP Evidence-Handling “Grave Miscarriage of Justice”; Charges Dismissed by Federal Judge
- PLN Wins Partial Victory, Attorneys Fees in FOIA Video Tape Suit Against U.S. Attorneys’ Office, by Brandon Sample
- Ninth Circuit: PLRA Precludes Award of Attorney Fees Where Violation of Prisoner’s Rights is Not Affirmatively Established
- News In Brief:
More from Michael Brodheim:
- California: Prisoner Not Entitled to Points Reduction in Classification Score Unless Actually Participating in Programs, Aug. 24, 2016
- CDCR Adopts New Contraband Rules on Obscene, Gang-related Materials, July 7, 2015
- Arizona Department of Corrections Adopts Same-Sex Marriage Policy, July 7, 2015
- California Prison Officials Ordered to Provide Qualified Sign Language Interpreters for All Deaf Prisoners, July 7, 2015
- Plata Court Authorizes Force-Feeding of Hunger-Striking California Prisoners, July 2, 2015
- June, 2013 Proves To Be Deadly Month for California Prisoners, June 12, 2015
- California: Commission Recommends Reforms for Jail Overcrowding, Sentencing, June 12, 2015
- Nevada Jail Charges Prisoners for Meals, Medical Care to Defray Costs, June 3, 2015
- Pennsylvania Jail Guard Who Assaulted Prisoner Gets Home Confinement, Probation, June 3, 2015
- California Pays $585,000 to Settle Suit by Prisoner Who Lost Eye Due to Poor Medical Care, May 6, 2015
More from these topics:
- Sixth Circuit Revives Pro Se Prisoner’s § 1983 Lawsuit for Second Time, Nov. 1, 2026. Administrative Exhaustion (PLRA), Summary Judgment, Grievances, Publications/Books, Burden of Proof.
- Fourth Circuit Holds Exhaustion Completed After Initial Filing but Before Filing Amended Complaint Sufficient for Claims Raised for First Time in Amended Complaint, Nov. 1, 2026. Retaliation for Filing Grievances, Administrative Exhaustion (PLRA), Complaints, Grievances.
- BOP Prisoner’s Claim Over Denied Medical Care Ruled Impermissible Bivens Extension, Oct. 1, 2026. OB/GYN, Failure to Treat, Administrative Exhaustion (PLRA), Grievances, Adequacy of Remedy.
- California Appeals Court Holds Defendant Cannot Be Penalized for Failing to Appear at Sentencing When He Was Being Held in Another County’s Jail on Preexisting Charges, July 1, 2026. Disciplinary Hearings, Due Process, Procedural Default/Error, Evidence - Admissibility, Plea Agreements/Guilty Pleas.
- BOP Ordered to Restart Gender Affirming Care for Trans Prisoners, July 1, 2026. Medical, Conditions of Confinement, Administrative Exhaustion (PLRA), Transgender.
- Seventh Circuit Reinstates Illinois Prisoner’s Lawsuit Against Prison Dental Staff, June 1, 2026. Dental Care, Administrative Exhaustion (PLRA), Summary Judgment, Class Certification, Deliberate Indifference.
- Texas Officials Testify That Cost to Air Condition Prisons Tops $1.5 Billion, May 1, 2026. Eighth Amendment, Exposure to Heat, Administrative Exhaustion (PLRA), Deliberate Indifference, Prison Litigation Reform Act (PLRA).
- Ohio Supreme Court Awards Prisoner $1,000 for Denied Records Request, April 1, 2026. Administrative Exhaustion (PLRA), Damages, Public Records, Public Records Act.
- Alaska Prisoner’s Discipline for Violating Invalidated Rule Tossed, March 1, 2026. Disciplinary Hearings, Access to Media, Statutory Construction/Interpretation, Authority and Jurisdiction, Administrative Detention/Segregation.
- Eleventh Circuit: District Court Erred in Dismissing BOP Prisoner’s Medical Claim, Finds Prison Officials Made Administrative Remedies Unavailable, March 1, 2026. Systemic Medical Neglect, OB/GYN, Failure to Treat, Administrative Exhaustion (PLRA), Deliberate Indifference.

