Skip navigation

Search

35 results
Washington Court of Appeals: PLRA Dismissal of Prisoner’s Federal Suit Is Not Res Judicata Barring State Tort Claims by On March 19, 2024, the Court of Appeals of Washington, Division II, held that a state prisoner’s tort claims are not barred in state court even if federal claims arising from …
Article • July 28, 2017 • from PLN August, 2017
Fourth Circuit Rules Lawsuit over Inadequate Prison Food Not Barred by Res Judicata by Lonnie Burton by Lonnie Burton On April 25, 2016, the Fourth Circuit overturned a district court’s order dismissing a lawsuit filed by a South Carolina prisoner who alleged that the food served at a state prison …
Article • October 26, 2015 • from PLN November, 2015
Filed under: Appeals, Res Judicata
Ninth Circuit: Damages Suit Not Heck-barred by Retrial by Mark Wilson Ninth Circuit: Damages Suit Not Heck-barred by Retrial by Mark Wilson In “an unusual case,” the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals held that a California murder conviction on retrial did not bar a damages suit for the first conviction, …
Article • August 29, 2015 • from PLN September, 2015
Alabama: Settlement to Integrate HIV-Positive Prisoners Finalized by David Reutter Alabama: Settlement to Integrate HIV-Positive Prisoners Finalized by David M. Reutter An Alabama federal district court has approved a settlement that integrates HIV-positive prisoners into the state prison system’s general population, finding it “fair, adequate, and reasonable.” The change in …
Article • January 15, 2014 • from PLN January, 2014
Res Judicata Doesn't Bar Ohio Post-release Control Challenge by The Ohio Supreme Court has held that “when a criminal defendant is improperly sentenced to post-release control, res judicata does not bar the defendant from collaterally attacking his conviction for escape due to an earlier post-release-control sentencing error.” In 1998, Donald …
Article • August 15, 2013
Rooker-Feldman Doctrine Bars Review of State Court Order by District Courts by The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed a Michigan federal district court’s order that dismissed an action challenging state court orders that allowed confiscation of a prisoner’s pension benefits for incarceration costs. Three Michigan prisoners filed this putative …
Washington: Failure-to-Protect Suit against King County Allowed to Proceed by The Washington Court of Appeals has reversed a superior court ruling dismissing on res judicata grounds a "Complaint for Damages" filed by a prisoner against King County, alleging that he was raped by other prisoners in the tenth floor shower …
Article • April 15, 2013
US Court of Appeals Dismisses Freed Prisoner's §1983 Claim by US Court of Appeals Dismisses Freed Prisoner's §1983 Claim The United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit affirmed in December 2011 the district court’s dismissal of an Illinois prisoner’s civil rights claim against three police officers and three …
Article • April 15, 2011
Ohio Parole Challenge Not Barred by Res Judicata by by Mark Wilson The Ohio Court of Appeals reversed a lower court’s dismissal of a prisoner’s parole challenge, holding that res judicata did not bar the action. In 1977, Michael Swihart was convicted of aggravated murder, murder and arson related to …
LCS Granted Writ of Mandamus on the Basis of Res Judicata by The Supreme Court of Alabama ruled on December 19, 2008 that res judicata was established in a prisoner’s First Amendment case that was previously adjudicated by a Louisiana court of competent jurisdiction. On October 3, 2006, Carl Braxton …
N.Y. Affirms Multiple Accumulating DOC Disciplinary Proceedings For Same Incident by New York State prisoner Derek Josey sought review of an intermediate appellate court ruling allowing the Department of Correctional Services (DOCS) to punish him multiple times for the same incident. New York’s highest court ruled that res judicata did …
Article • August 15, 2008
D.C. Circuit Reverses Res Judicata Dismissal; Failure to Treat HCV Constitutes “Imminent Danger” by The United States Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit reversed a lower court’s dismissal of a pro se prisoner’s suit, on res judicata grounds. The court also granted the prisoner leave to appeal in forma …
Sheriff May be Liable for Jail Suicide by The decedent was arrested while drunk and promptly hanged himself in a police holding cell. The plaintiffs settled with the city defendants for $11000, leaving the state defendants in the case. The district court did not abuse its discretion in refusing to …
Administrative Exhaustion Required in Alabama HIV/AIDS Class Action Suit by The plaintiffs sued on behalf of themselves and all present and future HIV-positive prisoners in the state prison system, complaining both of their segregation from the general prison population and their exclusion from most programming, and of inadequate medical care. …
Fired California Guard’s Termination Suit Reinstated by Fired California Guard's Termination Suit Reinstated The plaintiff jailer was terminated for excessive force and mistreatment of women and minority prisoners without being allowed to see the documents on which the decision was based. He was reinstated by a state court with back …
Article • December 15, 2007
Citizen Who Triggered Investigation Against Baltimore Police Refused Access To Report's Findings by Maryland citizen Kevin Briscoe appealed a 1993 court ruling denying the disclosure of investigative records initiated by his complaint against Baltimore police. The court affirmed nondisclosure because Briscoe was not the subject of the investigation. Briscoe and …
Court Rules On JJDPA Suit Issues, State Compliance Plan Ordered by The United States District Court for the Northern District of Idaho ordered Idaho state officials to devise a plan to put the state in compliance with the Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Act (JJDPA) and denied state's motions on …
7th Circuit Reversed Directed Verdict on First Amendment Claims by The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit reversed a district court's directed verdict, entered against an Indiana prisoner's claims of discipline without minimal due process protections and interference with his free exercise of religion and access to the …
Montana Supreme Court Reverses Dismissal of Injunctive Action by The Montana Supreme Court reversed a lower court's dismissal of a prisoner's action, finding that his claims were not barred by res judicata. Anthel Brown was sentenced to the Montana State Prison (MSP) on November 8, 1976. He was confined to …
Article • May 15, 2007
Retaliation Claim Legitimate, Res Judicata Claim Not by A New York state prisoner brought a § 1983 action against prison authorities alleging retaliation for previous legal action. Prison officials introduced motion for summary judgment asserting principle of res judicata. The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York …
Page 1 of 2. | 1 2 | Next »