×
You've used up your 3 free articles for this month. Subscribe today.
Eighth Circuit: Arkansas Prisoner Who Had Consensual Sex With Guard Cannot Sustain Eighth Amendment Claim
Loaded on April 1, 2025
by Matthew Clarke
published in Prison Legal News
April, 2025, page 58
Filed under:
Eighth Amendment.
Location:
Arkansas.
by Matt Clarke
On September 20, 2024, the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit held that a prisoner’s consensual sexual encounters with a guard cannot, as a matter of law, constitute the pain required to sustain a claim under the Eighth Amendment. Though a blow …
Full article and associated cases available to subscribers.
As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.
Already a subscriber? Login
More from this issue:
- Deaths, Deplorable Conditions, Staff Misconduct Plague Memphis Jail
- From the Editor, by Paul Wright
- New Jersey Guard Sacked for Mocking George Floyd Killing Loses Appeal
- New York Suspends Solitary Ban to Woo Back Striking Prison Guards
- Porn Produced by Georgia Prisoners
- $7.15 Million for Oklahoma Prisoner Exonerated After Nearly 50 Years, by Anthony Accurso
- North Carolina Reimburses Prisoner $2,500 for Law Books Destroyed by Guards, by Anthony Accurso
- No State Oversight of Overcrowded, Understaffed, and Non-Compliant Idaho Jails
- No Sunshine on In-Custody Deaths in Sunshine State
- Little-Known Law Allows Some Texas Prisoners to Vote
- $1.35 Million in Settlements for One-Legged San Francisco Detainee Forced to Hop—Twice
- Ohio Pauses Executions, Louisiana and Arizona Race Ahead
- Self-Harming Wisconsin Prisoner Settles Failure-to-Protect Suit for $7,000, by Sam Rutherford
- Biden Clemency Recipients Included Virginians Sentenced for “Acquitted Conduct”
- 14 Overdoses in Two Weeks Leave One Dead at Phoenix Jail
- “Swing or Kick Rocks”: BOP Guard Alleges Conspiracy to Brutalize Prisoners at Kentucky Lockup
- Tucson Program Slashes Pretrial Misdemeanor Incarceration
- $1 Million Partial Settlement for Washington Jail Detainee’s Leg Amputation
- Tenth Circuit Stretches PLRA to Deny Claim of Colorado Prisoner Shot by Guard While Shackled, by Douglas Ankney
- $42 Million Jury Award for Detainees Tortured by U.S. Military at Abu Ghraib Prison
- Pardoned Insurrectionists Brought to D.C. Jail Demanded Others’ Immediate Release
- Houston Jail Cited for State-Law Violations Twice in a Month
- A Song for Condemned Alabama Prisoner
- Three Former Virginia Jailers Charged After Detainee Dies in “WRAP” Restraint
- Ninth Circuit: No Exception to Due Diligence in Discovery Even for “Conclusive Evidence”, by Anthony Accurso
- Sixth Circuit: Dismissals of Mixed-Claim Complaints Not Strikes Under PLRA
- Former Indiana Jailer Walks from Charges Over “Night of Terror”
- National Class Certified in Washington Jail Debit-Release Card Suit
- CoreCivic Will Cage Migrant Families in Texas Lockup
- Three More Prisoners Die, Three More Staffers Fired at Wisconsin Prison
- Jailing the Homeless: New Data Shed Light on Unhoused People in Local Jails, by Leah Wang
- GTL, Co-Defendant Agree to $21.3 Million Settlement in Price-Fixing Lawsuit
- No Opened Envelopes: Hawai’i Prisons Get New Mail Scanning Technology
- GEO Group Gets $1 Billion ICE Contract at New Jersey Lockup
- DOJ Finds “Horrific” Unconstitutional Conditions at Atlanta Jail
- Alabama Governor Commutes Death Sentence
- California Stops Raiding Released Prisoners’ Gate Money
- $4 Million Settlement Approved in HRDC’s Oregon Debit-Release Card Suit
- Nurse Charged, $2.6 Million Settlement Reached in Minnesota Jail Death
- Tenth Alabama Jail Employee Pleads Guilty in Detainee’s Freezing Death
- Muslim Prisoners Face Price-Gouging
- $250,000 Settlement But No Charges After Alabama Guards Beat Prisoner To Death, by Anthony Accurso
- GOP Washington Lawmaker Trolls Felon Enfranchisement Proponents
- Ninth Circuit: Posting Jail Mugshots on Arizona County’s Website Violates Substantive Due Process
- Georgia Fights Liability for Strip-Searching Prison Visitor, Nevada Pays $126,500
- Half of Hawai’i Prisoners Released With No ID
- Peters Fights Dismissal from BOP, Guards Lose Bonus Pay
- Southern Health Partners Settles Suit Over Kentucky Jail Meth Death
- Federal Watchdog Calls Out BOP for Spiking Suicide Risk at Pennsylvania Lockup, by Matthew Clarke
- Wisconsin DOC Agrees to Improve Services for Hearing-Impaired Prisoners
- $2.5 Million Settlement After South Carolina Jail Detainee Lost 2 Lbs.Per Day and Died, by Anthony Accurso
- More New York Guards Suspended After Another Prisoner’s Fatal Beating
- Fourth Circuit Excuses Maryland Prisoner From Exhaustion Requirement in PREA Claim, by Douglas Ankney
- Eighth Circuit: Arkansas Prisoner Who Had Consensual Sex With Guard Cannot Sustain Eighth Amendment Claim, by Matthew Clarke
- Illinois Pretrial Incarceration Becomes Less Random A Year After Elimination of Cash Bail, by David Reutter
- D.C. Circuit Reverses Dismissal of Federal Prisoner’s Complaint Due to PLRA Three-Strikes Rule
- TDCJ to Run Out of Beds in 2025, by Matthew Clarke
- News in Brief
- Shrewd Federal Prisoner Salvages $5,000 from Suit Against Arkansas Jail Where He Was Held Pre-Trial, by Anthony Accurso
More from Matthew Clarke:
- Eighth Circuit Affirms Denial of Qualified Immunity to Missouri Jail Guards in Suit Over Detainees’ Excessive Force Claims, Nov. 1, 2026
- Seventh Circuit Reverses Summary Judgment Favoring Prison Transport Guard Sued Over Dangerous Medical Transport, Nov. 1, 2026
- Texas Reacts to Prison Overdose Crisis with Increased Criminal Punishment and Peer-Led Recovery Groups, Nov. 1, 2026
- Sixth Circuit Dismisses Interlocutory Appeal by Ohio Jailers Sued for Unjustifiably Beating Detainee, Nov. 1, 2026
- Fourth Circuit Holds Exhaustion Completed After Initial Filing but Before Filing Amended Complaint Sufficient for Claims Raised for First Time in Amended Complaint, Nov. 1, 2026
- Ohio Federal Court Dismisses Claim Against CoreCivic for Failure to Protect Prisoner Who Fatally Overdosed, Nov. 1, 2026
- Eleventh Circuit Reinstates Alabama Prisoner’s Excessive Prison Violence Claim, Oct. 1, 2026
- Eleventh Circuit Upholds Most of Relief Ordered in Class-Action Lawsuit Challenging Unconstitutionally Inadequate Mental Health Care in Alabama Prisons, Oct. 1, 2026
- Fourth Circuit Upholds Denial of Qualified Immunity to Jail Supervisors Who Ignored Detainee’s Cranial Abscesses, Oct. 1, 2026
- Eighth Circuit Reverses District Court’s Denial of Motion to Dismiss Some Defendants from Lawsuit Over Missouri Prisoner’s Suicide, Oct. 1, 2026
More from these topics:
- Alabama Supreme Court Rules Guard Entitled to State-Agent Immunity in the Stabbing of a Prisoner, Nov. 1, 2026. Failure to Protect (General), Eighth Amendment, Summary Judgment, Immunity/Liability.
- Eleventh Circuit Upholds Most of Relief Ordered in Class-Action Lawsuit Challenging Unconstitutionally Inadequate Mental Health Care in Alabama Prisons, Oct. 1, 2026. Eighth Amendment, Staffing, Injunctions (PLRA), Failure to Treat (Mental Illness), Suicides.
- Second Circuit Rules Eighth Amendment Governs Claims of Excessive Force Brought by Parole Violator, Oct. 1, 2026. Eighth Amendment, Excessive Force, Qualified Immunity, 42 U.S. Code § 1983, civil action for deprivation of rights, Probation, Parole & Supervised Release.
- Eleventh Circuit Affirms Refusal to Expand Bivens to Claim Alleging Federal Prisoner Died from Denial of Treatment for Hepatitis C, Oct. 1, 2026. Medical, Eighth Amendment, Administrative Exhaustion, Civil Rights Actions or Offenses/Bivens Actions, Deliberate Indifference.
- “Nothing Short of Disgraceful”: New York Prisoner Wins Injunction Ordering Cancer Treatment Delayed Seven Years, Sept. 1, 2026. Cancer, Failure to Treat, Eighth Amendment, Injunctions, Deliberate Indifference.
- Fourth Circuit Revives Disabled Prisoner’s Claim for Denial of Out-of-Cell Exercise Time, Aug. 1, 2026. Totality of Conditions, Eighth Amendment, Exercise, Summary Judgment, Qualified Immunity.
- Nevada Prisons Are Facing a Medical Crisis Due to Understaffing, Aug. 1, 2026. Systemic Medical Neglect, Failure to Treat, Eighth Amendment, Staffing, Medical Neglect/Malpractice.
- Oregon Reaches $49 Million Settlement with State Prisoners in COVID-19 Class-Action, Aug. 1, 2026. COVID-19, Eighth Amendment, Settlements, Class Certification, Qualified Immunity.
- Eighth Circuit Revives § 1983 Complaint Alleging Jail Detainees’ Death from Stroke was Due to Deliberate Indifference and Failure to Train, July 1, 2026. Systemic Medical Neglect, Failure to Treat, Eighth Amendment, Failure to Train/Supervise, Deliberate Indifference.
- Alabama Barred from Executing Prisoner by Nitrogen Hypoxia, July 1, 2026. Totality of Conditions, Eighth Amendment, Death Penalty, Cruel and Unusual Punishment, Wrongful Use of Force.

