Sixth Circuit Dismisses Interlocutory Appeal by Ohio Jailers Sued for Unjustifiably Beating Detainee
by Matt Clarke
On August 4, 2026, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit dismissed an interlocutory appeal by six jailers employed by Ohio’s Clermont County Sheriff’s Department. The appeal was dismissed for want of jurisdiction because of the jailers’ “insistence on fighting the facts.”
Mark Lovell was extremely drunk when Williamsburg police officers brought him to the jail to be booked for disorderly conduct, resisting arrest and aggravated menacing. Police had radioed ahead for assistance due to Lovell’s resistive behavior. Jailers Joseph Bailey, Dylan Pemberton, Eric Mullenix, Terra Shouse and Corporal Gregory Paff were waiting to assist. The ensuing events were largely video recorded by surveillance cameras and a handheld video camera.
Although Lovell complained about Bailey holding his right arm too tightly during booking, the Sixth Circuit found that “[a]t no time during booking did the officers appear to have difficulty restraining or controlling Lovell.” Nonetheless, after booking, jailers started shouting for Lovell to “loosen” his hand even though video showed his hand was open. Confusion among the jailers was also caused by some of the guards pushing Lovell forward at the same time that others pulled him backwards. Each of the five jailers dwarfed Lovell and the difficulty of five people surrounding him while trying to move him down the hallway was apparent in the video.
A few steps from a restraint chair, Paff intentionally tripped Lovell and the jailers took him down. While he was on the floor, jailers started yelling “stop resisting,” beat him repeatedly with closed fists, pepper sprayed him directly in the face and then rubbed it into his face, and then beat him some more for a total of a dozen blows. They then put a spit hood on him and placed him in the restraint chair but did not offer treatment for the pepper spray that was burning his eyes.
Two hours later, Bailey and Paff tried to rouse Lovell, who did not respond until Bailey used a sternum rub. All of the jailers but Shouse took the minimally responsive Lovell to the shower room where a second beating and pepper spraying occurred with at least 26 closed-fist blows and six kneeings. During this time, jailers repeatedly ordered Lovell to place his hands behind his back while other jailers held his arms, preventing him from doing so.
Several hours later, X-rays ordered by a jail nurse showed multiple fractured ribs, flailed chest, and a pneumothorax which were later confirmed by a hospital CT scan.
Lovell filed a federal civil rights action against the county and the six jailers alleging excessive use of force in violation of his Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment rights. The jailers filed a motion for summary judgment and it was denied for the most part. The jailers then filed an interlocutory appeal. Aided by Cincinnati attorney James Griffin O’Brien, Lovell moved to dismiss the appeal.
The Sixth Circuit noted that its jurisdiction on interlocutory appeal is “sharply circumscribed” and appellants may not challenge the district court’s determination of the facts. See: Kilnapp v. City of Cleveland, 167 F.4th 909 (6th Cir. 2026). This ensures that the review “remains confined to the denials of qualified immunity and does not bleed over into a review of the district court’s evaluation of genuine dispute of material fact.” See: Brown v. Chapman, 814 F.3d 436 (6th Cir. 2016).
However, the jailers repeatedly argued against the district’s determination that a genuine issue of a material fact existed regarding whether their conduct violated Lovell’s constitutional rights, which is prohibited unless the determination is blatantly contradicted by the record. The Court held that the video evidence did not blatantly contradict the determination. Therefore, it lacked jurisdiction over the appeal, which it dismissed. See: Lovell v. Bailey, 184 F.4th 809 (6th Cir. 2026).
As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.
Already a subscriber? Login
Related legal case
Lovell v. Bailey
| Year | 2026 |
|---|---|
| Cite | 184 F.4th 809 (6th Cir. 2026) |
| Level | District Court |

