Florida Jails Help ICE Violate Federal Detention Rules Through Rebookings, Report Finds
by Sagi Schwartzberg
As part of Republican Pres. Donald Trump’s aggressive immigration policies, Florida state law requires every jail in the state to sign collaboration agreements with the Department of Homeland Security’s (DHS) Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency (ICE). This authorizes Florida’s jails to detain immigrants through an ICE Detainer—a written request from the federal government asking a local jail to hold someone for up to 48 hours after they’d otherwise been released—to give ICE time to pick up the immigrant and begin deportation proceedings.
Some counties in Florida—such as Pinellas County and Orange County—had, through June 2026, special contracts with ICE that allowed them to hold immigrants for up to 72 hours, which designated them as “under 72” facilities in ICE’s database. This time limit exists to prevent immigrants detained on civil charges from spending too long in jails meant for people detained on criminal charges.
Emily Ryo, a professor at Duke University School of Law who studies ICE detentions, said that immigrants in ICE custody should be guaranteed comprehensive medical screenings, space for confidential legal consultations or even outdoor access, which are things that local county jails often cannot provide. Moreover, as Soumia Bensalah recently found out, local jails are violating the detention times using questionable tactics.
Bensalah, a French Moroccan with a pending green card application, landed in a Polk County, Florida, jail after her husband, who is a U.S. citizen, allegedly assaulted her. According to the police report, Bensalah called the police, who arrived and saw cuts on both her and her husband and booked them both on battery charges (the charges were later dropped).
Shortly after her arrest, Bensalah posted bond, but she was not released because of an ICE detainer lodged against her. Instead of sending her to a longer-term immigration facility in the days after she posted bond, ICE moved her two counties over to the Pinellas County Jail, where she was then held for 72 hours. Bensalah was then released and rebooked at regular, 72-hour, intervals multiple times, until she was eventually transferred to an ICE detention facility approximately 15 days later.
This practice of release and readmission, known as “rebooking,” typically happens in secret and circumvents federal rules and regulations, and stems from the fact that the federal government often does not have enough detention space to jail all of the immigrants ICE and cooperating local authorities are rounding up. Such shortage is more pronounced in states like Florida, where the majority of local law enforcement agencies have signed collaborative agreements with ICE.
ProPublica recently reported that rebookings in two Florida counties—Pinellas and Orange—dwarfed other jails across the country, where no more than 10 immigrants were rebooked two or more times during the timeframe of its investigation. From July 2025 to February 2026 (where the data showed the practice ceased), Orange County jail in Orlando rebooked 559 immigrants two or more times; Pinellas County jail rebooked 174 immigrants two or more times between July 2025 and July 2026 (where zero rebookings appeared in the data).
All people rebooked at least twice in these counties ended up behind bars for more than 72 hours; one woman from Mexico who was rebooked into the Pinellas County jail 10 times spent a cumulative 26 days in jail. Two former DHS officials who spoke with ProPublica described the repeated bookings as an attempt to evade the detention standards. “What it shows is that they were aware they were breaking a rule,” said Michelle Brane, a former DHS immigration detention ombudsperson. Paul Chavez, litigation director for Americans for Immigration Justice, a legal nonprofit that litigates for immigrant’s rights, said repeated bookings like Bensalah’s are clear examples of unconstitutional detentions.
In response to ProPublica’s questions about the repeated rebookings, a DHS spokesperson wrote: “ICE is NOT breaking any laws by making custody determinations based on bed space and ensuring detainees’ presence for immigration proceedings or removal from the United States.” When ProPublica shared details of Bensalah’s case, the Department responded that “she received due process.” DHS wrote: “Under President Trump and Secretary [Markwayne] Mullin, if you break the law, you will face the consequences. Criminal illegal aliens are not welcome in the U.S.”
Interestingly, ProPublica found that out of the 423 immigrants rebooked at least twice in Pinellas and Orange County jails through December 2025, 115, or 27%, had no criminal charges or convictions except for traffic-related offenses. That is consistent with recent data released showing that an increasing percentage of all ICE detentions involve people with no criminal charges.
Legal experts say that the only real recourse for immigrants repeatedly rebooked or held for prolonged period in local jails is to file an emergency petition in federal court seeking relief for illegal detainment; a petition for writ of habeas corpus. One woman, a Brazilian immigrant who had not been charged with a crime, challenged her nine-day detention in the Pinellas County Jail in federal court through such petition.
In response, the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office claimed that she was in federal custody and it did not have the power to release her. Federal appeals courts, however, have found the exact opposite: jails have the power to release ICE detainees after a hold expires and can be held liable if they don’t.
In fact, last November, a federal jury found Suffolk County liable for wrongfully detaining more than 600 immigrants and awarded them $112 Million in damages, a verdict Suffolk County is currently appealing. [See: PLN, Jan. 2026, p.16.] After ICE released the Brazilian woman, it called her jail stay a “procedural error.”
“All her claims will be heard by an immigration judge, and she will receive due process,” DHS wrote in response to questions about the woman’s case. “This administration will not ignore the rule of law,” DHS said.
Orlando federal judge Paul Byron begs to differ. “If the government is pulling a detainee out of jail to artificially set the clock, that is highly inappropriate,” he told Assistant U.S. Attorney Phillip Ragler during a hearing. “What allows that?” Byron asked. Ragler didn’t have an answer, and Judge Byron ordered the immigrant freed.
“Being forced to defend ICE’s actions in a professional capacity caused significant moral and ethical conflicts for me personally,” Ragler wrote in a statement to ProPublica, adding that ICE gave the U.S. Attorneys no reasoning or justification for detaining people, many of whom had no criminal records. He further told ProPublica he resigned from the position shortly after the hearing with Judge Byron, following nearly a decade in the office.
ProPublica’s analysis showed that, ultimately, Orange County renegotiated its contract with ICE so that immigrants could be held only for two days. Soon thereafter, the number of immigrants in ICE custody booked into the jail plummeted. At around the same time Orange County stopped repeat bookings of immigrants, the number of rebookings in Pinellas started declining. But unlike Orange County, Pinellas then began holding more immigrants for longer than three days in a single stay.
After ProPublica released its report, Pinellas County provided ProPublica with an internal ICE memorandum dated December 11, 2025 that redesignated Pinellas as “an over-72 facility, effective immediately.” While this memo sheds light on why the data no longer showed rebookings in Pinellas County, one must wonder: did the conditions in the jail change, and why was its status changed to an “over-72” facility?
Source: ProPublica
As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.
Already a subscriber? Login

