Skip navigation
× You have 2 more free articles available this month. Subscribe today.

Federal Court Orders Benchmarks to Meet Remedial Plan in California Jail Class Action

by David M. Reutter

In 2018, Santa Clara County officials agreed to a decree that required reform of medical care and conditions within its two jails. As is typical in jail or prison class actions, the implementation of agreed reform has moved at a snail’s pace. Facing contempt proceedings, county officials stipulated to benchmarks that require the implementation of contempt sanctions if compliance is not achieved.

A class action lawsuit was filed in 2015, alleging unconstitutional conditions in restrictive housing, medical care, mental health care, dental care, non-­mobility disability accommodations and the use of excessive force. Three years later, the County agreed to a settlement that included policy changes as well as $1.6 million in attorney fees and annual payments of $200,000 for compliance monitoring, as PLN reported. [See: PLN, Apr. 2019, p.30.] According to jail staff, however, compliance with the 2018 settlement agreement’s medical provisions was pitted against budget constraints.

“It created this chaotic tornado of issues where people could not meet the needs of our inmate population,” said a longtime jail medical employee who requested anonymity for fear of retaliation. “People were intimidated from doing what was supposed to be done.” External factors from third party vendors significantly affect medical response and exam timelines, the employee said.

County officials blamed industry-­wide staffing issues for its failure to achieve compliance. “You can hire almost anyone if you pay people enough,” said Donald Specter, a class attorney from the Prison Law Office in Berkeley. “They’ve had six, seven years to do this, and they haven’t done it. Part of the broader purpose of the contempt motion was to light a fire, instead of them just complaining they don’t have enough staff.”

The parties stipulated to a court order that established compliance metrics. The district court approved the stipulation on September 1, 2026, establishing quantitative standards. The stipulation requires independent medical and mental health monitors be in place, and for qualitative standards to be agreed upon, by September 30, 2026.

An appendix to the order set quantitative standards for the Remedial Plan. The standards concern medication administration, assessment of and care for people in withdrawal, out of cell time in the acute psychiatric unit, availability of space in special management units, triaging of and response to requests for medical care, timely response to requests for medical care, care for people with chronic conditions, mental health treatment plans and suicide prevention turnaround times.

The failure to meet a standard requires the County to come into compliance within 30 days to meet the target. If the County meets the target within 30 days, it is credited with compliance for that month. Failure to meet the compliance deadline will result in a presumption the County is in contempt. Twelve straight months of meeting or exceeding the compliance target results in termination of the stipulation on that specific standard. Otherwise, the stipulation remains in effect until the County achieves compliance.

The jail medical employee doubted the County will achieve full compliance. “Quantitatively, that target is in range, and it is possible for us to scramble and meet the metrics,” the employee said. “But not qualitatively. The workload is unrealistic.”

The ratio of detainees to medical staff has been at the root of the failure to achieve compliance. Specter suggested a reduction of the jails’ population to improve service ratios. PLN will report developments in this case as they occur. See: Chavez v. County of Santa Clara, USDC, (N.D. Cal.), Case No. 5:15-­cv-­05277.  

 

Additional source: The Mercury News

As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.

Subscribe today

Already a subscriber? Login