Fifty Percent Reduction in Women’s Prison Sentences in Illinois and North Carolina Would Yield Tremendous Cost Savings with Only a Negligible Increase in Violent Crime
by Douglas Ankney
A study from the Council on Criminal Justice (CCJ) by researchers Avinash S. Bhati, PhD., and John K. Roman, PhD. found that reducing the prison sentences of women in Illinois and North Carolina by 50% could yield tremendous cost savings while at the same see a negligible rise in violent crime.
CCJ policy director Dr. Stephanie Kennedy said “[i]ncarceration for women is very expensive, and we are using this very expensive tool, prison, on what is, on average, a relatively low-risk group compared to men.” The CCJ found that the annual cost of imprisoning women is about $87,000 to $122,000 per person compared with around $70,000 for men. These substantial cost increases for women are attributed to the specialized healthcare needs (including pregnancy care) and smaller prisoner populations that translate to higher per-person costs. And studies show that the costs associated with incarcerating women may rise to as much as $34 billion by 2035.
The CCJ Study analyzed the public safety, prison population and cost implications of reducing the amount of time women serve in prison. The CCJ study’s focus on women came about as the result of the organization’s previous examination of the public safety implications of shortening lengthy prison terms in Illinois, which revealed that such reductions in prison sentences were “associated with relatively few additional arrests and substantial reductions in the average daily population (“ADP”).”
The Women’s Justice Commission then asked: “Would similar patterns emerge for women?” The population of women in prison has exploded by 600% since 1980 and the differences between incarcerating women and men go beyond monetary costs. A significant number of women “enter prison with histories of trauma and domestic abuse, and disproportionately experience mental health and substance use disorders, economic instability, and caregiving responsibilities.”
The CCJ Study used the releases of approximately 12,000 women who were released from prison between 2018 and 2021—with 6,419 of them released in Illinois and 5,552 released in North Carolina. The “[i]ndividual-level correctional records were linked to criminal history records to examine arrest patterns before incarceration and after release.” This data was then “used to create simulation models that project how arrest patterns would change under reductions in time served ranging from 10% to 50%.”
Besides the estimated changes to arrests, “the models generate projections of changes in ADP and associated costs.” While the cost estimates included the savings that would result from lower ADPs due to earlier releases, the researchers also accounted for the additional expenses associated with early releases: supervision costs, costs associated with additional arrests, and costs associated with victimization. One caveat that needs to be mentioned here is that the CCJ study did not include the additional societal costs of incarcerating women. For example, women tend to be the primary caregivers of children and the elderly and when a woman is incarcerated, someone else must be hired or “volunteered” to fulfill those duties. As more than one person has recognized: “While mommy is in prison, little noses still need to be wiped.”
Some findings of the CCJ Study include:
- Reducing time served is associated with modest increases in arrests; the report notes, “Under a 50% reduction in time served applied to all women, the model estimates roughly 100 additional arrests per year in each state during the three-year follow-up period, or about a 7% to 9% increase above the modeled baseline arrest.” Significantly, it must be understood that the 7% to 9% increases are measured against what the model baseline levels were before any sentence reductions were applied and not increases to current, real-world numbers. That is, the models estimated about 105 additional arrests per year in Illinois and 96 in North Carolina. Those numbers represent an increase of 0.3% of all female arrests annually in Illinois and 0.2% in North Carolina. When compared with all arrests for a year, the increase reflects less than one-tenth of one percent for both states (about 0.08% of all arrests in Illinois and 0.04% in North Carolina).
- Nine of every ten additional arrests would be for nonviolent offenses. With a 50% reduction in time served applied to all women, about nine out of ten arrests would be for nonviolent offenses. These offenses would include property, drug, and supervision-related offenses. Estimating offense type is central to the public safety implications of early release and the CCJ Study applied “observed post-release arrest patterns to additional arrests projected under each scenario.”
- The additional arrests would be concentrated among a small share of women. When a 50% reduction in time served is applied to all of the women, the resulting increase in arrests is not evenly distributed. In fact, about 25% of the women would be responsible for about 60% of the additional arrests. Based on these numbers, the researchers opined: “This concentration helps explain why policy design matters. Broader reductions include women across the full distribution of model-estimated arrest increases, producing larger reductions in ADP and costs but also more additional arrests. More targeted reductions produce smaller increases in arrests, but also smaller reductions in ADP and costs. Translating this finding into policy would require states to identify appropriate eligibility criteria using information available before release.”
- Lower ADPs result from sentence reductions. In the CCJ study, application of a 50% sentence reduction resulted in a drop of the ADP by 950 women in each state—or 41% in North Carolina and 51% in Illinois—when the sentence reduction is applied to all women. However, if policy makers applied the sentence reduction to 75% of women responsible for the least number of increased arrests, the ADP dropped by 373 women in Illinois and 361 women in North Carolina (21% and 15%, respectively).
- Lower ADPs reduces overall costs. When a 50% reduction in time served is applied to all women, the lower ADP results in an estimated annual cost savings between $61.8 million to $94.1 million in Illinois and between $68.3 million to $102.7 million in North Carolina.
As noted above, these figures were arrived at by estimating the savings resulting from a decrease in the population of women in prison and offsetting that amount by the additional costs associated with supervision, new arrests and victimization. While the annual incarceration costs would be reduced by $77,000 to $112,000 per woman, there would be an increase of about $10,600 per woman per year for supervision. However, if policy makers applied the sentence reduction to 75% of the women responsible for the least number of increased arrests, the estimated annual cost savings on the lower end is $24.8 million to a high of $37.8 million.
Importantly, these cost-savings estimates do not equate to immediate budget savings. Correctional costs are not strictly linear. That is, a reduction in the ADP does not equate to an actual reduction in operating costs of a facility until the ADP reaches a certain level. For example, it costs the same amount to employ a guard to supervise 25 prisoners as it does to supervise five prisoners.
While a decrease in ADP of 20 prisoners would reflect an annual cost savings of $1.5 million (at an estimated $75,000 per prisoner), the amount still needed to pay the guard would not decrease accordingly. Broadly speaking, cost savings translate to decreases in budgetary spending when carceral facilities are closed.
Source: Council on Criminal Justice
As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.
Already a subscriber? Login

