Skip navigation
× You have 1 more free article available this month. Subscribe today.

Ohio Federal Court Dismisses Claim Against CoreCivic for Failure to Protect Prisoner Who Fatally Overdosed

by Matt Clarke

On August 20, 2026, the United States District Court for the Northern District of Ohio dismissed the federal claims in a lawsuit brought by Bonnie Billings, the mother of Montel A. Williams, a prisoner who fatally overdosed while incarcerated at the Northeast Ohio Correction Center (NOCC), a private prison in Youngstown, Ohio operated by CoreCivic under a contract with the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction (DRC).

Billings’ claim alleged CoreCivic and NOCC Warden Douglas Fender violated the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition of cruel and unusual punishment by failing to protect him from the harm caused by fentanyl smuggled into the prison. The court remanded to state court a pendent state claim for wrongful death.

The complaint alleged Williams “intentionally or accidentally ingested fentanyl, or some other dangerous drug,” at NOCC, overdosed and died. It also alleged CoreCivic deliberately understaffed its prisons to minimize costs and maximize profits, that this had a “negative impact” on “security, emergency response, and contraband control” at various out-­of-­state prisons and that similar practices could be imputed to NOCC. It further claimed there was a “Wall of Shame” display at NOCC featuring photos and descriptions of former employees who were caught smuggling contraband into the prison and fired. However, the Court noted that this last claim could as easily be construed as NOCC making efforts to catch and punish drug smugglers as it being evidence of a smuggling problem at NOCC. The Court also decried the unspecific and unsupported nature of the complaint’s allegations.

The lawsuit was originally filed in state court. Defendants had it removed to federal court. Following the filing of an amended complaint, they moved to dismiss. Billings was represented by Youngstown attorney Rhys B. Cartwright-­Jones.

The Court noted that a plaintiff raising a failure-­to-­protect claim premised on a prison overdose must prove more than simple exposure to drugs. See: Zakora v. Chrisman, 44 F.4th 452 (6th Cir. 2022). “Instead,” the Court argued, citing Caraway v. CoreCivic of Tennessee, LLC, 98 F.4th 679 (6th Cir. 2024), “she must show ‘that there was unfettered access to deadly drugs.’”

The Court added, “[the] Plaintiff can make that showing by plausibly alleging there was ‘a widespread presence of drugs at the facility, there were prior overdoses, and [prison] officials failed to investigate the overdoses.” See: Cole v. Ashtabula Cty., Ohio, 2026 U.S. App. LEXIS 18790 (6th Cir.).

Billings failed to plead that there was unfettered access to drugs or prior overdoses at NOCC. As the court noted, she did “not provide any details as to how widely present drugs were” or “whether other inmates overdosed” or whether NOCC officials knew of other overdoses and failed to investigate them. This was fatal to her federal claim under the precedents of Caraway, Cole and Zakora.

The court held that Plaintiff already had ample time to correct these deficiencies, which were pointed out in the motion to dismiss, so leave to amend to correct them was inappropriate. Therefore, it dismissed the Eighth Amendment claim.

The Court ruled that remand of the state wrongful death claim to state court was appropriate. It declined jurisdiction over that claim and remanded it. See: Billings v. CoreCivic, Inc. 2026 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 187165 (N.D. Ohio).  

As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.

Subscribe today

Already a subscriber? Login

Related legal case

Billings v. CoreCivic, Inc.