Skip navigation
× You have 2 more free articles available this month. Subscribe today.

Report from the National Academies Reveals that System for Reporting In-Custody Deaths Is Underfunded and Unreliable

by Douglas Ankney

The National Academies of Science, Engineering, and Medicine (“National Academies”) released a report (“Report”) in 2025 that revealed the medicolegal death investigation system (MLDI) responsible for the investigations of deaths while in custody in the United States is underfunded, understaffed, unprofessional and unreliable.

The National Academies wrote that “[t]he MLDI system plays a critical role in justice and public health, providing important information to the public about deaths. Those who investigate deaths are relied upon to make accurate determinations of cause and manner of death by providing data on individual deaths and evaluating aggregate data collected in local communities and states from across the nation.” However, the MLDI system “faces significant challenges” because “a lack of uniformity creates inadequacies and inconsistencies.”

The Report cited as problems: outdated facilities (many of which are not accredited); many field practitioners—including medical examiners and coroners—remaining uncertified; and a shortage of forensic pathologists. According to the Report, “[t]he current state of the MLDI system undermines the credibility of death investigations and limits opportunities for practitioners to connect with the broader medical and public health communities. Without adequate resources and standards, MLDI professionals struggle to provide the accurate information needed to protect communities and ensure justice. Further, medical examiners and coroners face pressure from the public, law enforcement, the media, and others when making determinations of cause and manner of death. Incorrect or biased conclusions undermine confidence in medical systems, can misdirect public health outcomes, and may result in a lack of accountability or culpability.”

The Report acknowledged that progress had been made since the release in 2009 of a separate report by the National Research Council entitled Strengthening Forensic Science in the United States: A Path Forward. The organizations spearheading this progress included the National Association of Medical Examiners, the International Association of Coroners & Medical Examiners, the National Institute of Justice Bureau of Justice Assistance (BJA), Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS) of the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ), the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). But several areas remained deficient and continued to jeopardize the MLDI’s efficacy.

The National Academies made several recommendations. Some of the more prominent recommendations are discussed below. First, the National Academies recommended that the offices of the medical examiners and coroners “meet basic equipment, training, and staffing [standards].” This may be accomplished by U.S. Congressional allocation of funds to enable states “to improve physical infrastructure for those entities that are accredited or are seeking accreditation of their facilities and certification of their practitioners; increase coordination among federal, state, and local MLDI systems; and develop experimental programs and pilot studies to identify novel ways to increase coroner access to medical examiner and forensic pathologist expertise and services (e.g., by enabling small medical examiner and coroner offices to pool resources to improve regional operations and efficiency).”

Another recommendation called for the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education and the American Board of Pathology to “integrate additional requirements into forensic pathology fellowship programs.” One such recommended requirement is “the review of disputed cases or cases that have previously undergone formal review (e.g., adjudicated exoneration cases or case reports from audits).”

Significantly, the National Academies recommended a program that included “education about how forensic pathologists may become involved in legal proceedings and how their work may be used in legal proceedings” and instruction “on the health risks of incarceration.” In the Report it was also recommended that, in order to maintain the quality of forensic pathology services, “all medical examiner and coroner offices should arrange for rigorous, meaningful peer review of no less than 10 percent of cases at least annually.” These reviews would include “special case types, such as infant fatality cases, maternal fatality cases, death-in-custody cases, homicide cases, and cases where manner of death was listed as undetermined.”

One recommendation is disturbing in that it should have been a requirement long ago: “States should require licensure of all medicolegal death investigators. Licensure should be granted by an appropriate regulatory body, such as a state department of health or licensing board. As a condition of licensure, licensees should meet prescribed training and educational requirements and pass a nationally recognized certification examination (e.g., the exam administered by the American Board of Medicolegal Death Investigators). To maintain their license, licensees should meet continuing education requirements. Reciprocity provisions should be developed to recognize licenses from other states.”

One recommendation of particular interest to PLN readers is: “State or local public health departments should conduct mortality reviews of deaths in custody. These reviews should be conducted by multidisciplinary review committees operating under state or local jurisdiction.”

The National Academies further recommended annual summary reports of these reviews be submitted to state attorneys general offices and state health departments to indicate the prevalence of particular types of deaths.

Another recommendation of particular interest to PLN readers offered that the U.S. Congress “allocate funding to the National Institute of Justice (NIJ) to support research on methods to reduce deaths in custody.” The NIJ, in collaboration with the National Institutes of Health (NIH), the CDC, and the NIST, “should provide enhanced training programs for law enforcement and corrections officers to make them aware of” any new approaches developed that reduce in-custody deaths.

Additionally, “standards should be incorporated into training materials that require law enforcement and corrections officers to follow proven evidence-based practices to reduce deaths in custody.” The National Academies recommended that the U.S. Congress direct the NIH and CDC, in consultation with the NIJ and NIST, to “convene a panel to define the characteristics of a death in custody that should require an autopsy.”

The National Academies observed that, as a result of a provision of the Death in Custody Reporting Act of 2013 (DCRA), the responsibility for collecting data on deaths in custody was shifted to the BJA from the BJS. This had led to a decrease in the reporting of in-custody deaths which, in turn, had “adversely affected our nation’s ability to understand the scope and causes of deaths in custody.” (The BJS, partly due to its established infrastructure and relationships, was better suited to this task). Compounding the problem was the fact that there are currently no incentives or sanctions “to motivate accurate, complete, and timely reporting of deaths occurring in local, state, or federal custody.” Nor do all jurisdictions perform autopsies on persons who die while in custody.

The National Academies observed that in-custody deaths “are generally understood as occurring at any point from the time of a first encounter with law enforcement through pretrial processing and incarceration, to the point of release from prison, jail, or other detention.” But “deaths may occur in a hospital or in a community after release from custody, where the condition leading to hospitalization began or was exacerbated during incarceration” and “such deaths are not classified as ‘deaths in custody’ by DCRA.” These deaths, many of which are preventable, result from “a range of natural and unnatural causes including disease, suicide, drug overdose, conditions at detention facilities, medical neglect and incompetence, accident, excessive force, and homicide.”

PLN readers are aware that persons in custody in local city or county facilities and on the brink of death are sometimes discharged from custody prior to transport to a hospital so that these facilities may evade paying the ensuing medical bills as well as evade the reporting requirements when the person dies either enroute, or after admittance, to a hospital.

To remedy these problems, the National Academies recommended that the U.S. Congress amend the DCRA to return to the BJS the “responsibility for collecting state and local death-in-custody data” and “require states to collect and report data on all deaths in custody to the BJS; expand the definition of a reportable in-custody death to include deaths that occur in a hospital or community after release from custody, where the condition leading to hospitalization began or was exacerbated during incarceration; and mandate that all deaths that occur while in custody be certified by a medical examiner or coroner.”

The National Academies further recommended that the U.S. Congress oversee the development of effective incentives and enforceable penalties to ensure that in-custody deaths are reported.

To further ensure that in-custody deaths are reported, it was recommended that the U.S. Standard Certificate of Death be upgraded with the addition of a checkbox to indicate whether the death occurred while in custody, with appropriate space added to provide sufficient background/context. The National Academies also sought to increase transparency and understanding of the nature of in-custody deaths by recommending that federal and state law “mandate that all death-in-custody cases be referred to an independent (i.e., unaffiliated with law enforcement or the institution where the death occurred) certified pathologist to undertake a postmortem examination of appropriate scope. In some cases, autopsies may be required and may need to be conducted by certified forensic pathologists outside the jurisdiction of the death. In such cases, the postmortem examination report should be filed with the U.S. Department of Justice.”

It is perplexing that in a nation that collects data on almost all deaths, facts surrounding the deaths of people in custody were ignored—and in most jurisdictions, the deaths were not even reported. While perplexing, it is not surprising since the underlying viewpoint of America’s criminal legal system is that prisoners are slaves, as the Constitution’s 13th Amendment makes clear. And the death of slave was never a newsworthy event unless tied to an uprising.

Perhaps the National Academies’ findings and recommendations will have a measurable impact. But given that the U.S. President and those he appointed to power view fundamental scientific truths regarding climate change as a “hoax,” and that, in spite of overwhelming evidence to the contrary, they insist the 2020 election was “stolen,” the power of truth to persuade is greatly diminished.  

 

Source: National Academies

As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.

Subscribe today

Already a subscriber? Login