Skip navigation
× You have 1 more free article available this month. Subscribe today.

New Jersey Prison Ombudsperson Report Raises Slew of Concerns

by David M. Reutter

"Oversight authority is often put in place during times of crisis,” wrote New Jersey Corrections Ombudsperson Terry Schuster in his October 2026 Annual Report.

Following riots at two state prisons in the 1970s, New Jersey law created the Office of Corrections Ombudsperson. In 2020, the Ombudsperson’s powers were expanded after extensive and serious sexual abuse of female prisoners was exposed at Edna Mahan Correctional Facility (EMCF). [See: PLN, Dec. 2020, p.28.]

Yet, oversight should not be limited to times of crisis. “Oversight is necessary even when a prison system has excellent leadership and management, as is the case of New Jersey’s Department of Corrections (DOC), because the simple presence of outside observers can change what happens inside and cue corrections officials to perform to a higher standard,” wrote Schuster.

The report offered examples of positive change from the Ombudsperson over the last five years. In the most recent year, the Ombudsperson worked to prevent a blind prisoner from being exploited by a cellmate. The Ombudsperson’s intervention led to a rule revision that better protects all prisoners. An Assistant Ombudsperson’s work with prisoners in Residential Community Reintegration Programs who were seeking drug treatment allowed them to receive wages commensurate with persons seeking treatment in prison.

The report noted that DOC Commissioner Victoria Kuhn has “provided stable and competent leadership and taken meaningful steps towards more transparency.” In addition to implementing court-­mandated changes at EMCF, Kuhn changed the prison’s culture. Kuhn also took steps to increase prisoner phone calls and made tablets available. Among the changes was the introduction of a Road to Reentry Program, reduction of emergency room trips and disciplinary actions related to drugs, and allowing the Ombudsperson to audit internal investigations.

Between July 1, 2025, and June 30, 2026, the Office of Corrections Ombudsperson received 12,693 contacts from prisoners and their loved ones. More than 9,000 of those contacts came from the three largest prisons. The total contacts in FY 2025-­26 were 3% lower than the previous year, with notable reductions in contacts concerning discipline, safety and healthcare. In FY 2025-­26, the top complaints concerned money and property, classification and property, health and mental health, outside communication and conditions of confinement.

While the report noted “real progress to celebrate this year,” the Ombudsperson detailed ten “interesting and difficult problems for policy makers to turn to next.” The first concern was understaffing, which has been a problem highlighted for several years. It is expected to worsen as guards retire with full pensions. The State Auditor found that despite a steady prison population, the amount of overtime pay increased 59% between 2022 and 2024. If more guards cannot be hired, the Ombudsperson suggested reducing the prisoner population.

Overcrowding is another problem. Cells designed for single occupancy are often used for double occupancy. While New Jersey law requires county jails to provide 25 square feet of floor space per detainee, double cell occupancy in prisons result in 18–20 square feet per prisoner. As double celling increased, so has the suicide rate. Prisoners expressed “concern about loss of personal space and privacy, and fear about cellmates who are sexual predators, violent, engaging in drug use, or experiencing symptoms of mental illness.”

Little out-­of-­cell time for people in close custody is another problem policymakers should grapple with. Reduced movement “can hamper efforts to engage incarcerated people in purposeful activity, programming, school, work, vocational training, and treatment.”

As PLN reported in its October 2026 cover story, the prison population is aging. The DOC held 12,471 prisoners at the beginning of the year, of whom more than 200 are age 70 or older and another 750 are in their 60s. More than 1,700 prisoners are serving a mandatory prison sentence of 30 years or more. With prisoners aging, costs for medical care increase. Additionally, facilities must accommodate prisoners who acquire disabilities as they age. The report recommended planning for these eventualities and consideration of compassionate release policies.

The unnatural deaths of several young people over the last year is a serious concern. Three prisoners died from homicide between January and June 2026. Three more deaths were under investigation, with two suspected homicides and one a suspected suicide. Two deaths occurred at Northern State Prison, three deaths occurred at Garden State Youth Correctional Facility and one death at South Woods State Prison. Four of the six deaths were of prisoners in their 20s.

For over 100 years, “correctional leaders, policy makers, and subject matter elders” have called for the West Compound of New Jersey State Prison to be demolished and replaced. With a $1 billion price tag, this political elephant has been kicked down the road. The prison has four-foot by seven-­foot cells, it lacks hot water, air conditioning, a day room, recreational space and toilets and showers do not provide privacy. The Ombudsperson said lawmakers cannot avoid this problem indefinitely, and urged finding the funds to rebuild the prison.

Next, the Ombudsperson urged lawmakers to make county jail condition laws apply to prisons. Regulations covering cell size, beds, lights, sinks and toilets, mattresses, fire safety, showers and receiving meals in common rooms should also apply to prisons. Additionally, about 1,500 prisoners live in units without air conditioning. With measured temperatures in the 90s with heat indexes 10-­15 degrees hotter, legislators should act to provide air conditioning in all units.

The Ombudsperson also noted that civilly committed people held in the Special Treatment Unit (STU) are subjected to indefinite detention for sex offender treatment without receiving treatment. In addition to providing treatment to those in the STU, the Ombudsperson urged policymakers to take action for prisoners who may land in STU to receive treatment before the expiration of their prison sentence.

Finally, the Ombudsperson noted that it received more than 200 contacts in FY 2025 from persons in county jails. The Ombudsperson has no authority to act upon those contacts. While the DOC inspects county jails, it has no authority to act upon complaints from those held in county jails. It was urged that policymakers explore options to provide more oversight of county jails.  

 

Source: New Jersey Office of the Corrections Ombudsperson

As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.

Subscribe today

Already a subscriber? Login