Federal District Court Adopts Magistrate’s Report Certifying Class in Suit Alleging Faulty Plumbing at Washington Jail
by Douglas Ankney
On June 23, 2026, the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington adopted Magistrate Judge S. Kate Vaughan’s Report and Recommendation (“R & R”) certifying a class in a lawsuit challenging the unsanitary conditions stemming from faulty plumbing that have persisted for decades inside Pierce County’s Main Jail (“Jail”) in Tacoma, Washington.
Plaintiffs Echota Wolfclan and Zakery Bonds, on behalf of themselves and a proposed class of pretrial detainees held at the Jail, filed a Third Amended Complaint (“TAC”) naming several defendants, including: Pierce County; the Pierce County Council; Pierce County Sheriff Edward Troyer; and Pierce County Chief of Correction Patti Jackson (collectively “Defendants”).
The Plaintiffs alleged that the “Defendants are deliberately indifferent to plumbing conditions at the Jail that cause raw sewage to ‘ping-pong’ between adjoining cells’ toilets, regularly flooding cells with sewage, and allow noxious sewer gases to permeate cell blocks.” The Plaintiffs brought three claims under: (1) 42 U.S.C. § 1983 for violations of their rights under the Fourteenth Amendment to the federal constitution; (2) the Washington Constitution’s Due Process Clause; and (3) Washington law for tortious failure to keep health and safety.
Wolfclan, who suffers from mental illness, has been a defendant in 18 Pierce County criminal cases since 2004, which resulted in several periods of pretrial confinement at the Jail—including from April 6, 2023, to August 15, 2023. During that period of detention, Wolfclan was assigned to the mental health unit in cell block 3 North A. Upon entering his cell, Wolfclan “observed that the toilet was filled with raw sewage emitting noxious gases that gave him an immediate headache. The following morning, Wolfclan awoke to find his cell toilet had overflowed, covering the floor in raw sewage. He was forced to eat his breakfast in his cell in those conditions. He also noticed the cell floors were covered in black grime, which he attributed to the raw sewage floods. The grime stuck to detainees’ socks, causing the substance to transfer to their beds and blankets.”
Wolfclan also alleged that during a prior period of detention in 2020, he observed “raw sewage backing up in his cell’s toilet, causing sewage to spill on to the floor ten to fifteen times per day and a noxious smell. His requests for personal protective equipment and cleaning supplies were only granted twice in seven months. When denied cleaning supplies, he was forced to clean his cell with his shirt and water from the cell sink. He was served breakfast in his cell despite the conditions, which often prevented him from eating. He complained about the conditions during formal inspections performed approximately every three weeks and filed numerous grievances.”
Wolfclan asserted that the design of the Jail’s plumbing operated in a manner that when one toilet flushed, the toilet in the adjoining cell backflushed with raw sewage. Jail maintenance personnel once told him that “the ongoing sanitation conditions resulted from a thirty-year old plumbing mistake.” While detained in cell block 3 North A, Wolfclan had to take medications for numerous ailments brought about by the noxious sewer fumes permeating the cells and dayroom, including: headaches, allergies, coughing, mucus, upset stomach, and respiratory problems. He witnessed his cellmate “vomiting, suffering diarrhea, and being unable to eat for up to four days.”
Wolfclan also “observed other residents whose eye swelled shut, reported suicidal thoughts due to the conditions, and were placed on IVs due to being unable to eat.” Horribly, on at least four occasions, “backflushes occurred while Wolfclan was seated on the toilet, resulting in his anus and genitals coming into contact with raw sewage [which] caused an open sore to develop.”
Wolfclan also asserted that “he was repeatedly denied opportunity to submit grievances regarding the conditions and denials of access to cleaning supplies” and was “informed by officers that they no longer handed out grievances for plumbing related conditions.” Bond’s allegations were similar. He was assigned to cell block 3 South E from March 19 to April 7, 2022.
Upon entering his cell, “Bonds observed the toilet brimming with raw sewage, which rose and fell every time someone in a nearby cell flushed their toilet. The toilet seat and sink handles were covered in raw sewage. He continually experienced sewage back flushing into his toilet and overflowing onto the floor when neighboring detainees flushed their toilets. He had to use his clothing to clean up sewage overflows multiple times. On several occasions, a back flush occurred when he was sitting on the toilet, resulting in raw sewage touching his anus and genitals. … [T]he sewage smell caused him to experience nausea and headaches.”
Bonds experienced similar conditions in cell block 4 South C. Then when moved to a dry cell (a cell without a toilet) in 4 North B, a drain at the entrance of his cell “emitted noxious sewer gases” which “gave him severe headaches.” He was then moved to an open-dorm in cell block 3 East B where, multiple times each week, Bonds “observed raw sewage come out of the dorm shower drains, exposing his feet to sewage.” On one occasion, maintenance personnel yelled “stop flushing, stop flushing,” because raw sewage was flowing into a judge’s chamber that was beneath the cell block. He was then moved to cell block 2 West B where the conditions were the same as in 3 South E. Both Plaintiffs asserted that “these plumbing issues are widespread throughout the Jail and have been for years.”
They pointed to a 2014 engineering evaluation and report that found “the Jail’s plumbing non-compliant with current code and that adjacent cells’ toilets are connected such that when one is flushed, the other back flushes.”
The 2014 engineering report recommended overhauling the Jail’s plumbing and replacing the toilets at a cost of $3.1 million. The Plaintiffs alleged that 29 lawsuits filed in federal court over the Jail’s plumbing issues in 28 different cell blocks demonstrated the problem was widespread. (Note to Readers: The district court consolidated most of those suits with the instant suit after certifying the class.)
Plaintiffs also submitted declarations from twelve prospective class members. Each described the experience of “constant sewer odors and toilets regularly backflushing waste, including feces, urine, vomit, toilet paper, and menstrual products.” At least three attested to “sitting on their toilets when a back flush occurred, resulting in others’ urine, feces, vomit, and blood splashing onto their genitals, anuses.”
Eleven of the detainees reported the denial of, or inconsistent access to, cleaning supplies. Many used their clothes to clean up the sewage and were then denied clean clothing, forcing them to wear sewage-contaminated clothing for days and to sleep in contaminated clothing and bedding. All twelve detainees reported experiencing various ailments, including respiratory issues and diarrhea, that they did not experience prior to incarceration and ceased experiencing after release.
Eddie Parker, a Pierce County Facility Management employee for 32 years testified that “the majority of people in the maintenance department knew about the backflushing and odor issues since at least 2014.” Defendant Jackson testified that “odors related to the plumbing chases and dry p-traps have persisted since she started working at the Jail in 1989.” And in 2016, the Division of Occupational Safety and Health received a complaint from a Jail employee reporting “the smell of methane permeates the 5th floor housing unit and makes you sick to your stomach. This has been an ongoing problem for … 10 years.”
Class certification required satisfaction of the requirements of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(a). First, as to numerosity, “a class that includes at least forty members is considered sufficient to satisfy the numerosity requirement.” See: Rannis v. Recchia, 380 F.App’x 646 (9th Cir. 2010). The Jail held approximately 550 detainees at any given time, with thousands detained there annually. The requirement of commonality was satisfied because “in a civil-rights suit … commonality is satisfied where the lawsuit challenges a system-wide practice or policy that affects all of the putative class members.” See: Gonzalez v. United States Immigr. & Customs Enf’t, 975 F.3d 788 (9th Cir. 2020).
The Plaintiffs’ claims were “typical” of the class because “[u]nder the rule’s permissive standards, representative claims are ‘typical’ if they are reasonably coextensive with those of absent class members; they need not be substantially identical.” See: Hanlon v. Chrysler Corp., 150 F.3d 1011 (9th Cir. 1998).
Finally, as to “adequacy,” Vaughan observed that Plaintiffs were represented by experienced counsel who had vigorously pursued the matter to date and that counsel did not have conflicts of interest with other class members. Hanlon. Accordingly, Vaughan recommended that class certification be granted and a class certified that included: “All detainees who are presently or have at any time been held in any cell blocks at Pierce County Jail having unremedied plumbing defects leading to unsanitary living conditions, and all detainees who will be held in those cell blocks in the future.” See: Wolfclan v. Pierce County, 2026 U.S. Dist. Lexis 140490 (W.D. Wash. 2026). As noted above, the District Court later adopted Vaughan’s R & R. See also: Wolfclan v. Pierce County, 2026 U.S. Dist. Lexis 139318 (W.D. Wash. 2026).
Additional source: The News Tribune
As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.
Already a subscriber? Login
Related legal case
Wolfclan v. Pierce County
| Year | 2026 |
|---|---|
| Cite | 2026 U.S. Dist. Lexis 139318 (W.D. Wash. 2026) |
| Level | District Court |

