Sixth Circuit: Failure-to-Train Claim Survives Pleading Stage in Detainee’s Overdose Death
by David M. Reutter
On October 8, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reversed an order dismissing a municipal liability claim alleging failure to train staff to treat detainees suffering from a drug overdose, allowing it to proceed beyond the pleading stage. The Court affirmed dismissal of the other municipality liability claims.
The lawsuit arose from the overdose death of Ricky Lynn Lewis while detained at the Knox County Jail. Lewis called 911 on May 25, 2023, to report that his truck had been stolen. When police arrived, Lewis was intoxicated and behaving erratically. Lewis admitted to using methamphetamine. Police conducted a consensual search of his truck, finding drug paraphernalia and a white substance that was suspected as heroin.
Lewis was charged with drug possession and transported to the Roger D. Wilson Detention Center. Surveillance footage was available to document the handling of Lewis. Upon booking, Lewis was unstable on his feet with his arms across his stomach. Tennessee and jail policies required a medical screening be conducted to determine if it was safe to admit Lewis to the jail, but no screening occurred. Lewis was subsequently moved to a holding cell in a wheel chair because he was unable to walk on his own.
According to the civil rights complaint filed by Lewis’ estate, Lewis was in apparent medical distress and “was clearly in the throes of overdose or acute drug withdrawal.” Yet, when a nurse attempted to take Lewis’ vital signs, she used smelling salts under his nose rather than administering naloxone, a drug commonly used to reverse the effects of opioid overdose.
It was in this condition that Lewis was placed in a holding cell, where he languished naked and in his own feces without being checked upon. Twice guards merely removed Lewis from the cell to wash him off. At one point, he exhibited a common overdose symptom of banging his head on the cell door. About seventeen hours after booking, Lewis was found unresponsive in his cell. Staff administered CPR, but 911 was not called until 45 minutes after he was found unresponsive. Lewis was transported to a hospital and placed on life support and died early the next morning. An autopsy report concluded Lewis died from “acute methamphetamine, fentanyl, xylazine, and morphine intoxication.”
Lewis’ Estate filed a 42 U.S.C. Section 1983 complaint against Knox County, various county officials and eight jail staffers. A “confusing” series of litigation moves led to the Estate pursuing only the municipal liability claims. Knox County moved to dismiss those claims at the pleading stage. The U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Tennessee granted the appeal. The Estate appealed.
The complaint asserted four causes of action to assert municipal liability. The Sixth Circuit found only the failure-to-train claim stated a cause of action. A failure to train claim is the “most tenuous” to hold a municipal liable, requiring application of “rigorous requirements of culpability and causation.”
First, the Court examined the complaint’s allegations concerning the jail’s training program. While the complaint failed to detail what training was provided to jail staff, the allegations led the Court to conclude an absence of proper training in jail policy when confronted with a detainee in the throes of drug overdose or withdrawal.
The complaint included allegations concerning policies requiring medical screening, the failure to medically screen and to provide medical care to Lewis, and the failure to monitor Lewis. The allegations exhibited a total failure to follow policies, which led to a “reasonable inference that jail staff were not trained to recognize and respond when detainees were the throes of drug-related medical emergency.”
The complaint alleged a failure to provide medical care for an obvious serious medical need. The failure to provide that care led to an inference of deliberate indifference from a failure-to-train staff on drug-related medical emergencies, which was also the causation of Lewis’ death.
Therefore, the Court reversed the district court’s order that dismissed the failure-to-train claim. The Court affirmed dismissal of the municipal liability claims based upon failure to medically screen, overcrowding, and underfunding. See: Byrum v. Knox Cty., 2026 U.S. App. LEXIS 30845 (6th Cir. 2026).
As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.
Already a subscriber? Login
Related legal case
Byrum v. Knox Cty.
| Year | 2026 |
|---|---|
| Cite | 2026 U.S. App. LEXIS 30845 (6th Cir. 2026) |
| Level | District Court |

