Illinois Reporting Raises Questions About State Standards to Prevent Jail Suicides
by Michael Dean Thompson
In Illinois, the leading cause of death for incarcerated persons is suicide, according to the Illinois Criminal Justice Information Authority (ICJIA), a state agency that tracks deaths in prisons and jails.
IPM News discovered through a public-records request to ICJIA that there had been at least 30 successful suicides between 2019 and 2025. Yet, that was a clear underreporting. Coroner records contained at least two dozen more suicides the ICJIA data did not report. Coroners also indicate the most frequent cause of those jail deaths is by hanging.
Miriam Gohara, a law professor at Yale University, says a suicide in a jail or prison is “an indictment of the prison’s ability to monitor, assess and provide care for someone who’s suffering from a serious mental condition.” The isolation, poor quality food, lack of sunlight or fresh air and overall stress of the jail environment can make people look for any way out, according to Gohara. She added, “Or, they’re being subjected to conditions that are so horrible that they drive themselves to death by suicide.”
A history of mental health problems is a key predictor of suicide risk alongside substance abuse. Jails, however, are ill-equipped to handle mental problems. Often, those in need of assistance must wait in a county jail for an available state psychiatric hospital bed. Illinois’ Madison County Sheriff Jeff Connor admits his county cannot handle them, claiming “The state has dropped the ball for many years of not putting them in facilities that they need to be.” The sheriff added, “And we don’t have the staff that is properly trained, or a facility that’s properly equipped for that.” Even with the assistance of counties better equipped to handle the patients, there are just not enough mental health beds.
Solitary confinement for at-risk prisoners is a common approach even though the experience can be quite traumatic for mental health patients. Guards also have a poor record of performing timely inspections. For example, Madison County has failed to comply with requirements to check on detainees every half hour for six of the last seven years.
Peer companions are prisoners trained on suicide prevention and can help identify and watch over those at risk, but that offloads security responsibilities to the prisoners. A comprehensive approach other than simply tossing an at-risk prisoner into solitary is available. A 2022 meta-analysis by the Lancet that reviewed 24 studies found that programs combining multiple prevention strategies may be the most effective at reducing suicide deaths. A Department of Justice working group report in 2024 had similar findings and actually recommended reducing the reliance on solitary confinement while promoting a culture of wellness and safety.
Source: IPM News
As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.
Already a subscriber? Login

