Skip navigation
× You have 1 more free article available this month. Subscribe today.

$300,000 Settlement Reached in HRDC Challenge to Censorship at Albuquerque Jail

by Chuck Sharman

Under a settlement signed on September 30, 2026, New Mexico’s Bernalillo County agreed to pay $300,000 to the Human Rights Defense Center (HRDC), the nonprofit publisher of PLN and Criminal Legal News, to resolve claims that its publications were unconstitutionally censored at the County Metropolitan Detention Center (MDC) in Albuquerque.

After switching to a digital mail system in 2025, MDC officials intercepted over 160 items that HRDC mailed to detainees. The County apparently believed that the new system obviated any detainee’s need for paper books, magazines or letters. But the MDC never provided HRDC with a reason for rejecting the items, nor any chance to appeal the decision or even to provide digital copies of the items that could be delivered on the system’s electronic tablets. Moreover, as reported by KOB in Albuquerque, the jail’s limited number of electronic tablets restricted each detainee to just 30 minutes of use a day. Not only did this thwart HRDC’s attempts to exercise its free-­speech rights, it was also a breach of an earlier 2015 settlement with HRDC that prohibited the County from banning soft-­cover books at the MDC. That prompted HRDC to file suit in January 2026, bringing both First Amendment and breach-­of-­contract claims, as PLN reported. [See: PLN, Jan. 2026, p.14.]

Two months later, in March 2026, the U.S. District Court for the District of New Mexico granted HRDC’s motion for a preliminary injunction (PI), prohibiting further censorship or rejection of its publications and correspondence sent to people incarcerated at the jail. The PI provided an exception for any censorship based on a “legitimate penological interest,” under the factors set out in Turner v. Safley, 482 U.S. 78 (1987). In that event, HRDC was owed both (a) written notice of any undelivered mail, postmarked within five business days of the rejection decision, and (b) an opportunity to appeal within 30 days of receipt of the notice to a jail official not involved in the rejection decision. [See: PLN, May 2026, p.34.]

The settlement incorporated most of the provisions of the PI, including the ban on censorship or rejection of HRDC’s publications and correspondence addressed to named individuals incarcerated at the jail, subject to legitimate Turner factors. Notice of any such censorship or rejection must be sent to HRDC within five days, listing: “(1) the publication or correspondence at issue; (2) the name of the intended recipient; (3) whether the material was rejected or redacted; (4) identification of the objectionable portion of the publication or correspondence; (5) the reason for the rejection; (6) a reference to the policy provision or rule the material is alleged to violate; and (7) notification of the right to appeal, and of the method and procedural requirements for doing so.”

The agreement preserved a 30-­day appeal window that was included in the PI, along with a 72-­hour limit on any temporary restriction of delivery of publications or correspondence—a restriction that may be put in place only after jail leadership “determines that emergency circumstances exist affecting institutional safety, security, or order,” the agreement provided. HRDC must also receive notice of any such action within seven days.

In addition, Defendants agreed to make and post any necessary policy revisions within 30 days. Within that same time period, jail leadership was obligated to provided necessary training to staff to implement the new policies. Notice of any future change to relevant policies must be provided to HRDC within 14 days. If HRDC files notice of a breach of the agreement, County officials have just 30 days to cure it before the nonprofit can file a motion in the district court to enforce the agreement or file a new suit to defend its rights.

The settlement payment included costs and fees for HRDC’s attorneys from Rosen Bien Galvan and Grunfeld, LLP in San Francisco. The nonprofit was also represented by in-­house Litigation Director Jonathan P. Picard of Lake Worth, Florida. See: Hum. Rts. Def. Ctr. v. Cty. of Bernalillo, USDC (D.N.M.), Case No. 1:25-­cv-­01208.

Given that prisoners enjoy a “well-­established right to receive books and magazines via the mail from publishers and vendors,” HRDC Executive Director Paul Wright told KOB, “it is outrageous that we are having to fight to vindicate rights which were established decades ago.” Yet that is what HRDC has been forced to do in lockups around the country—most recently in Pennsylvania’s Lancaster County, as reported elsewhere in this issue. [See: PLN, Nov. 2026, p.17.]  

 

Additional source: KOB

As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.

Subscribe today

Already a subscriber? Login