SCOTUS Denies Arizona Appeal of Prison Healthcare Receivership, But Ninth Circuit Grants Stay
by Chuck Sharman
On October 16, 2026, the Arizona Department of Corrections, Rehabilitation and Re-entry (DCRR) won a stay from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, pausing a lower court order which a week later would have placed healthcare in state prisons under receivership. The last-minute reprieve arrived just over two weeks after the Supreme Court of the U.S. (SCOTUS) refused the same request for a stay on October 1. See: Thornell v. Jensen, U.S., Case No. 26A370.
The three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit that changed its mind is set to hear arguments in the state’s appeal to receivership later in the year. In anticipation of that, the state tried and failed to get a stay from the U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona in August and the Ninth Circuit panel in September. When SCOTUS also refused to consider the request, it looked as though the DCRR would cede control of prisoner healthcare as scheduled on October 23 to Annette Chambers Smith, the former Director of the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction, whom the district court appointed to serve as receiver.
However, the Ninth Circuit panel said in its September decision that denial of the stay was subject to reconsideration. So after SOCTUS rebuffed them, Defendant state officials took their arguments back to the appellate Court, which this time agreed they might prove that the receivership order failed to pass the “least restrictive means” test outlined in the Prison Litigation Reform Act (PLRA), 42 U.S.C. § 1997e. Balancing the parties’ potential “irreparable harms,” the Court then decided that a partial stay of the order implementing the takeover was appropriate, though Chambers-Smith’s appointment and planning could proceed. See: Jensen v. Thornell, 2026 U.S. App. LEXIS 31579 (9th Cir.).
As PLN reported, the case was already 14 years old when the district court issued its receivership order in February. [See: PLN, May 2026, p.38.] That was after a stipulated settlement reached in 2014 was tossed in 2021, because it was obvious the DCRR had failed to comply with it. The case then went to a bench trial in 2022, when the district court found that state prisoners were subjected to unconstitutionally shoddy healthcare. A year later followed a detailed injunction to remedy such “overarching failures in the delivery of healthcare as seriously insufficient staffing, inappropriate use of nurses beyond the scope of their licensure, failure to manage complex patients or employ a differential diagnosis approach, substantially inadequate mental health treatment, and a deficient health care record system.”
Two years after that, the Plaintiff Class of prisoners complained that officials appointed to monitor the injunction remained unable to find the DCRR compliant with more than 23 of 154 healthcare provisions. Prison officials responded with a round of finger-pointing—at NaphCare, their contracted healthcare provider, at state lawmakers, whose funding process they blamed for missing staffing goals, and even at the monitors. “Either the Defendants are amnestic, or duplicitous or both,” the district court declared, agreeing with the Class that receivership was the last available option to stop the DCRR’s foot-dragging—not to mention the steady pile-up of preventable prisoner deaths and suicides.
As the case now heads into its 15th year, it’s incredible that DCRR attorneys are arguing that the district court has been too “impatient”—because they had just three years between the 2023 permanent injunction and the receivership order. That ignores the other decade-plus that prison officials were on notice that their healthcare system was deficient and refused to fix it.
“The facts and the history shows that [U.S. District Court Judge Roslyn O. Silver] has bent over backwards for years, and court judges before her tried to avoid receivership,” Corene Kendrick, an American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) attorney representing the prisoner Class, told the Arizona Mirror. But, she added, the DCRR “was just so intransigent that [the judge] found that it was absolutely necessary.”
Also incredible—after the threat of a PLRA challenge cowed the Ninth Circuit into granting a stay to that order—was the response by DCRR officials, who told ABC News that the agency “remains committed to improving healthcare inside its prisons.”
To which Kendrick said, “While the state continues to pull every lever to delay accountability, we remain focused on the underlying crisis and will continue fighting to ensure that people in prison are not needlessly suffering and dying because of the state’s failures.”
The case remains pending at the appellate Court, and PLN will continue to provide updates as developments unfold. In addition to Kendrick, ACLU attorneys representing the Class included Lauren K. Beall of Phoenix, as well as David C. Fathi and Maria V. Morris of Washington, D.C. They were joined by co-counsel from attorneys Donald Specter, Sophie J. Hart and Alison Hardy of the Prison Law Office in Berkeley, California. See: Jensen v. Thornell, USCA (9th Cir.), Case No. No. 26-1746 and Case No. 26-5060.
Additional sources: ABC News, Arizona Mirror
As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.
Already a subscriber? Login

