Skip navigation
Prison Legal News
× You've used up your 3 free articles for this month. Subscribe today.

Study Finds Just 1% of Prisoner’s Eighth Amendment Claims Succeed

Loaded on May 1, 2025 published in Prison Legal News May, 2025, page 12
Filed under: Retaliation for Filing Grievances, Systemic Medical Neglect, Eighth Amendment, Administrative Exhaustion (PLRA), Cruel and Unusual Punishment. Location: United States of America.

In a report published on December 19, 2024, Business Insider found just 1% of prisoners succeeded in claims against prison officials for violating the Eighth Amendment ban on “cruel and unusual” punishment.

To arrive at that figure, researchers combed through 1,488 prisoner complaints filed from 2018 to 2022, …

 

Full article and associated cases available to subscribers.

As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.

Subscribe today

Already a subscriber? Login

More from this issue:

  1. $1.2 Million in Settlements Reached in Suit Over Sacramento Jail Murder, by Douglas Ankney
  2. Multitudes Caged for Failure to Pay Child Support, Driving Mass Incarceration, by Matthew Clarke
  3. From the Editor, by Paul Wright
  4. Florida’s “Pay to Stay” Law: A Second Sentence for Former Prisoners
  5. Fifth Circuit Denies Qualified Immunity to Louisiana Officials Who Forced Prisoner to Work with Broken Surgical Screws in Ankle, by Anthony Accurso
  6. Study Finds Just 1% of Prisoner’s Eighth Amendment Claims Succeed
  7. Incarcerated Students Caught in Crosshairs of Trump War on Education Department
  8. Disbarred Cincinnati Defense Attorney Who Defrauded Prisoner Clients Gets Three-Year Sentence
  9. Wisconsin Prisoner Inhaled His Own Teeth in Fatal Beatdown
  10. South Carolina Conducts First U.S. Execution by Firing Squad in 15 Years
  11. Eleventh Circuit Revives Volunteer Pastor’s First Amendment Claim at Georgia Jail, by Douglas Ankney
  12. Trump Guts BOP Guard Union
  13. Los Angeles County Jails Record Almost One Death Every Nine Days
  14. Florida Prisoner Returns to Custody After Overturned Conviction Reinstated
  15. South Carolina Jailer Gets 10 Years for Sexually Assaulting Nine Detainees and Co-Workers
  16. Maryland Targets Highest-in-Nation Racial Incarceration Gap
  17. Idaho Warden Bought Execution Drugs on Roadside
  18. Connecticut Court Denies Access to Video of Prisoner’s Fatal Beat-Down by Guards
  19. Florida Prisoner Released to Die Settles With Centurion Over Ignored Prostate Cancer
  20. Wellpath Sanctioned for Discovery Violation in Suit Over Kentucky Prisoner’s Death, by Douglas Ankney
  21. Cruelty Is Now the Point for BOP
  22. New York Lifts Hiring Ban on Fired Striking Prison Guards, Announces Early Prisoner Releases
  23. Former Prisoner Appointed President’s Pardon “Czar”
  24. Oregon DOC Replaces Top Medical Staffers Amid Turmoil
  25. Rikers Island Staffers, Contractor and Detainee Sentenced for Smuggling
  26. Washington DOC On Hot Seat Over “Unexpected Fatalities,” Missed Autopsies
  27. 20 Charged in Nevada Prison Brawl That Left Three Dead
  28. Second Circuit Revives Connecticut Prisoner’s Challenge To Conditions In Virginia Lockup Where He Was Transferred, by Douglas Ankney
  29. Pittsburgh Lockup Accounts for 43% of Pennsylvania Jail TASER Use, Suit Filed
  30. Rikers Island Detainees Wait in “Black Hole” for Competency Treatment
  31. Mass Incarceration Weakens All Workers, by Eric Seligman, Brian Nam-Sonenstein
  32. Plans to Hold Migrants at Gitmo Hit Snag
  33. Third Circuit Denies Qualified Immunity to Pennsylvania DOC in Prisoner’s Challenge to 26 Years of Solitary Confinement
  34. Studies Link Incarceration with Lower Cancer Survival Rates—For Prisoner’s Partners, Too, by Anthony Accurso
  35. Virginia Bribes Prisoners Not to Set Themselves On Fire
  36. $2.95 Million Settlement for Untreated Pneumonia Death in Washington Jail
  37. Medical Copays Blamed for Reducing Prisoner Access to Healthcare
  38. New York Guards Indicted for Prisoner’s Murder
  39. Missouri Repeals “Pay-to-Stay” Law
  40. New Jersey DOC Sued Twice for Turning “Blind Eye” to “Pervasive” Drug-Smuggling Blamed for Prisoner Deaths
  41. $18,000 for New York Prisoner Who Alleged Guards Planted Shank in Cell
  42. Kansas Supreme Court Denies Compensation to Former Prisoner Whose Conviction Was Overturned
  43. Los Angeles County Pays $24 Million to Two Former Prisoners Wrongly Convicted as Teens of 1997 Murder, by Matthew Clarke
  44. Missouri Pays More Than $1.2 Million for Deputy Warden’s Sexual Harassment Claim Against Warden, by Douglas Ankney
  45. New Orleans Public Defender’s “Redeem Team” Says: “Re-entry Is Never Over”
  46. Texas Courts, Legislature at Odds over Executing Potentially Innocent Death Row Prisoner
  47. ACLU Sues BOP Over Failure to Implement First Step Act Release Credits, by Anthony Accurso
  48. Six Deaths in Eleven Months at Washington Jail
  49. New York Prisoner Awarded Almost $280,000 in Retaliation Claim Against Guards
  50. West Virginia Prison Chief Tapped to Helm BOP
  51. Crackdown On Pro-Palestinian Dissent Nabs New York Professor Who Found Link Between Cars and Incarceration
  52. Two California Prisoners Accused of Strangling Conjugal Visitors
  53. Wellpath Prepares Plan to Exit Bankruptcy
  54. Texas Prison Heat Declared Unconstitutional
  55. $3.4 Million Settlement for Minnesota Jail Death Called “Real-Life Nightmare”
  56. BOP Jettisons Transgender Offender Manual
  57. Kentucky Jail Sued for Detainee’s Death, Prisoner’s Stillborn Child
  58. Wait for Competency Restoration Averages 14 Months in Missouri Jails
  59. Jury Deadlocks at Trial of Last BOP Guard Accused at California “Rape Club”
  60. News in Brief

More from these topics: